From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. Chisholm

Supreme Court of Connecticut
Dec 12, 1967
155 Conn. 706 (Conn. 1967)

Opinion

Decided December 12, 1967

Petition by the defendant for certification of the case for appeal from the Appellate Division of the Circuit Court. Petition denied.

Albert G. Murphy, for the appellant (defendant) before the Appellate Division.

Harry W. Edelberg, prosecuting attorney, for the appellee (state) before the Appellate Division.


Certification is denied. Although we do not approve the opinion of the Appellate Division of the Circuit Court in the present case, the record is so deficient that on appeal we could not decide the constitutional issues which the defendant seeks to have determined. Under the circumstances, we deem it particularly necessary to reenunciate what we said in State v. Cullum, 149 Conn. 728, 730, 176 A.2d 587: "Our function on a petition for certification is to determine whether the petition raises a substantial question which should be considered by us in the interests of justice to the particular litigants or in the interests of preserving a stable, sound and consistent body of case law in the state. It follows that a denial of certification does not necessarily indicate our approval either of the result reached by the Appellate Division or of the opinion rendered by it."

Justice Cotter concurs in the foregoing but would grant certification.


Summaries of

State v. Chisholm

Supreme Court of Connecticut
Dec 12, 1967
155 Conn. 706 (Conn. 1967)
Case details for

State v. Chisholm

Case Details

Full title:STATE OF CONNECTICUT v. EARL L. CHISHOLM

Court:Supreme Court of Connecticut

Date published: Dec 12, 1967

Citations

155 Conn. 706 (Conn. 1967)
236 A.2d 465

Citing Cases

State v. Doscher

Practice Book 742. We repeat what we said in State v. Chisholm, 155 Conn. 706, 707, 236 A.2d 465: "[A] denial…

Republic Insurance v. Pat Dinardo Auto Sales, Inc.

A denial of certification does not necessarily indicate the Supreme Court's approval of the result reached by…