From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. Chicago N.W. Ry. Co.

Supreme Court of Minnesota
Sep 19, 1930
233 N.W. 108 (Minn. 1930)

Summary

In State v. Chicago N.W. Ry. Co., 147 Neb. 970, 25 N.W.2d 824, this court held: "Injunction is a proper remedy to be used by the state in the protection of public rights, property, or welfare, whether or not the acts complained of violate a penalty statute and whether or not they constitute a nuisance."

Summary of this case from State ex rel. Beck v. Associates Discount Corp.

Opinion

No. 28,033.

September 19, 1930.

Case followed. [Reporter]

Defendant appealed from a judgment of the district court for Ramsey county, McNally, J. entered in favor of plaintiff for $3,703.07 representing the tax on certain alleged gross earnings of defendant. Reversed, following State v. C. R.I. P. Ry. Co. 181 Minn. 615, 232 N.W. 105.

Fritz Foster, William T. Faricy, Warren Newcome and Alfred E. Rietz, for appellant.

Henry N. Benson, Attorney General, and William K. Montague, Assistant Attorney General, for the state.



This is a companion case to State v. C. R.I. P. Ry. Co. 181 Minn. 615, 232 N.W. 105.

In this case the only item involved is the so-called Pullman excess receipts. The court awarded judgment for recovery of the gross earnings tax on that item. The decision in the companion case determines all questions raised here.

The judgment appealed from is reversed.


Summaries of

State v. Chicago N.W. Ry. Co.

Supreme Court of Minnesota
Sep 19, 1930
233 N.W. 108 (Minn. 1930)

In State v. Chicago N.W. Ry. Co., 147 Neb. 970, 25 N.W.2d 824, this court held: "Injunction is a proper remedy to be used by the state in the protection of public rights, property, or welfare, whether or not the acts complained of violate a penalty statute and whether or not they constitute a nuisance."

Summary of this case from State ex rel. Beck v. Associates Discount Corp.
Case details for

State v. Chicago N.W. Ry. Co.

Case Details

Full title:STATE v. CHICAGO NORTH WESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY

Court:Supreme Court of Minnesota

Date published: Sep 19, 1930

Citations

233 N.W. 108 (Minn. 1930)
233 N.W. 108

Citing Cases

State v. Hooker

The maintenance of the public health, morals, safety, and welfare is on a plane above mere pecuniary damage,…

State v. Hoffman

Where a portion of a taxpayer's taxes is legal and the other portion is illegal, and he has the opportunity…