From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State on relation of W. H. Howerton v. S. McD. Tate

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jan 1, 1872
66 N.C. 431 (N.C. 1872)

Summary

In State ex rel. Howerton v. Tate, 66 N.C. 431, the Supreme Court of North Carolina held that the clerk of the superior court of one county could not issue a summons returnable in a superior court of another county.

Summary of this case from State ex rel. v. Bosworth

Opinion

(January Term, 1872.)

Since the passage of the Act of 1870-'71, chap. 42, the Clerk of the Supreme Court of one county, cannot issue a summons returnable in the Superior Court of another.

This was an action in which the summons was issued by the Clerk of the Superior Court of Rowan county, and made returnable to the Superior Court of Buncombe county.

Fowle, Blackmer McCorkle and W. H. Bailey for the appellants.

Phillips Merrimon, and David Coleman for the appellees.


At Fall Term 1871 of Buncombe Superior Court, His Honor Judge Henry, presiding, it being the summons term, the relators filed their complaint, whereupon the defendants moved to dismiss the action for want of jurisdiction. This motion was sustained by His Honor, and the relators appealed.


The only question in this case is whether the Clerk of Rowan Superior Court could issue a summons to be served in Buncombe Superior Court. The summons was dated 14th November 1871.

The Judge below, thought the Clerk had no such right, and dismissed the action. We concur with His Honor.

The practice is regulated by the Act of 1870-'71, ch. 42, which was ratified on the 25th of January 1871, and says, "that the summons shall be signed by the Clerk of the Superior Court having jurisdiction to try the action."

PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed.


Summaries of

State on relation of W. H. Howerton v. S. McD. Tate

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jan 1, 1872
66 N.C. 431 (N.C. 1872)

In State ex rel. Howerton v. Tate, 66 N.C. 431, the Supreme Court of North Carolina held that the clerk of the superior court of one county could not issue a summons returnable in a superior court of another county.

Summary of this case from State ex rel. v. Bosworth
Case details for

State on relation of W. H. Howerton v. S. McD. Tate

Case Details

Full title:STATE on the relation of W. H. HOWERTON et al. vs . S. McD. TATE et al

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Jan 1, 1872

Citations

66 N.C. 431 (N.C. 1872)

Citing Cases

State ex rel. v. Bosworth

The provision of Section 5, Article 1, Chapter 53, Code, 1931, as amended, that the rule shall be returnable…

Moore v. R. R

RODMAN, J. The Clerk of the Superior Court of Mecklenburg has no right to issue a summons returnable to the…