From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Spies v. Stone

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Mar 24, 1914
139 P. 951 (Okla. 1914)

Opinion

No. 3401

Opinion Filed March 24, 1914.

JUSTICES OF THE PEACE — Appeal — Jurisdiction of County Court. The law announced in the first section of the syllabus in Holcomb v. Chicago, R.I. P. Ry. Co., 27 Okla. 667, 112 P. 1023, rules this case.

(Syllabus by the Court.)

Error from District Court, Bryan County; Summers Hardy, Judge.

Action by J. E. Spies against R. A. Stone. Judgment for defendant before a justice. On appeal to the district court, judgment went for plaintiff. From the granting of a motion to vacate the judgment, plaintiff brings error. Affirmed.

Hatchett Ferguson, for plaintiff in error.


On September 22, 1908, plaintiff in error sued defendant in error before a justice of the peace, which resulted in a judgment for defendant. Thereupon plaintiff appealed to the district court, where defendant's motion to dismiss the appeal for want of jurisdiction was overruled. Later there was judgment rendered and entered for plaintiff, and defendant's motion for new trial was overruled. One of the grounds of the motion was error in overruling defendant's said motion to dismiss. Defendant did not appeal, but on January 23, 1911, moved the court to vacate the judgment, upon the ground that the same was void. The court sustained the motion, and plaintiff excepted, and brings the case here.

For the reason that the provisions of the Constitution (article 7, secs. 14, 18) conferred upon the county courts of the state exclusive appellate jurisdiction of all appeals from judgments of justices of the peace in civil cases ( Holcomb v. Chicago, R.I. P. Ry. Co., 27 Okla. 667, 112, Pac. 1023), the district court was without jurisdiction to enter the judgment, and hence the same was void. Rev. Laws 1910, sec. 5274, provides: "* * * A void judgment may be vacated at any time, on motion of a party, or any person affected thereby." Phoenix Bridge Co. v. Street, 9 Okla. 422, 60 P. 221; Nicoll v. Midland, etc., 21 Okla. 591, 96 P. 744; Harding v. Gillett et al., 25 Okla. 199, 107 P. 665.

Affirmed.

All the Justices concur.


Summaries of

Spies v. Stone

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Mar 24, 1914
139 P. 951 (Okla. 1914)
Case details for

Spies v. Stone

Case Details

Full title:SPIES v. STONE

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Mar 24, 1914

Citations

139 P. 951 (Okla. 1914)
139 P. 951

Citing Cases

Tiger v. Read

"A void judgment may be vacated at any time, on motion of a party, or any person affected thereby." Revised…

Gill v. Executive Committee of Home Missions of Presbyterian Church

"If it can be said that the judgment was erroneous as a matter of law, then movant had his remedy on motion…