From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Smith v. Murphey

Superior Court of North Carolina
Jan 1, 1802
3 N.C. 183 (N.C. Super. 1802)

Opinion

(Spring Riding, 1802.)

Where a course and distance is called for, and also a line of another tract, the distance is to be disregarded, if the line called for can be found; otherwise if such line cannot be found.

TRESPASS. Quare clausam fregit and liberum tenementum pleaded.


Defendant produced in evidence two deeds. The third course of the latter deed called for 42 poles to a corner standing on the other tract. Forty-two poles were completed before arriving at the first tract. If the last line of the second tract should be drawn from the point where the 42 poles were completed, the land which plaintiff had obtained a grant for was not within any of defendant's deeds; but if the line be extended beyond the 42 poles to an intersection with the lines of the other tract, then the land claimed by plaintiff was covered by defendant's second deed.


Where a course and distance is called for, and also a line of another tract, the distance is to be disregarded if the line called for can be found; if it cannot, you must stop at the end of the distance.

Verdict for defendant.

NOTE. — See the note to Bradford v. Hill, 2 N.C. 22, and, in addition to the cases there referred to, see Sasser v. Herring, 14 N.C. 340; Carson v. Burnett, 18 N.C. 546; Flannigan v. Lee, 19 N.C. 427; Hough v. Dumas, 20 N.C. 328.

Cited: Cherry v. Slade, 7 N.C. 90.


Summaries of

Smith v. Murphey

Superior Court of North Carolina
Jan 1, 1802
3 N.C. 183 (N.C. Super. 1802)
Case details for

Smith v. Murphey

Case Details

Full title:SMITH v. MURPHEY

Court:Superior Court of North Carolina

Date published: Jan 1, 1802

Citations

3 N.C. 183 (N.C. Super. 1802)

Citing Cases

Miller v. White

Upon the second point, see Allen v. Jordan, 3 N.C. 132, and the cases referred to in the note on the second…

Batson v. Bell

An established line of another tract is such a monument as controls course and distance. Coffey v. Greer, 241…