From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Sharp v. Miller

Supreme Court of California
Nov 14, 1884
66 Cal. 98 (Cal. 1884)

Summary

In Sharp v. Miller, 66 Cal. 98, [4 P. 1065], upon a similar question, the court said: "The reversal of the judgment and order denying the motion for a new trial when the cause was here before, placed the parties in the lower court in the same position as if the case had never been tried, with the exception that the opinion of this court must be followed so far as applicable in the new trial."

Summary of this case from Estate of Pusey

Opinion

         Department Two

         Appeal from an order of the Superior Court of the city and county of San Francisco, refusing to strike from the files an amended complaint.

         COUNSEL:

         P. B. Ladd, and Frederick S. Stratton, for Appellant.

          Wm. H. Sharp, for Respondent.


         OPINION

         THE COURT          The order appealed from in this case is not appealable. The appellant contends that it is a special order made after final judgment. The judgment formerly rendered was reversed, and there was no judgment in the cause, when the order appealed from was made. The reversal of the judgment and order denying the motion for a new trial when the cause was here before (see 54 Cal. 329), placed the parties in the lower court in the same position as if the case had never been tried, with the exception that the opinion of this court must be followed so far as applicable in the new trial. (Stearns v. Aguirre , 7 Cal. 447.)

         Appeal dismissed.


Summaries of

Sharp v. Miller

Supreme Court of California
Nov 14, 1884
66 Cal. 98 (Cal. 1884)

In Sharp v. Miller, 66 Cal. 98, [4 P. 1065], upon a similar question, the court said: "The reversal of the judgment and order denying the motion for a new trial when the cause was here before, placed the parties in the lower court in the same position as if the case had never been tried, with the exception that the opinion of this court must be followed so far as applicable in the new trial."

Summary of this case from Estate of Pusey
Case details for

Sharp v. Miller

Case Details

Full title:GEORGE F. SHARP, Respondent, v. THOMAS S. MILLER, Appellant

Court:Supreme Court of California

Date published: Nov 14, 1884

Citations

66 Cal. 98 (Cal. 1884)
4 P. 1065

Citing Cases

Rinaldo v. Superior Court

But in that regard, especially when an ordinary civil action is concerned, as promulgated by judicial…

Schubert v. Bates

If that dismissal be deemed effective, we have a case where there is no final judgment and the order of…