From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Sadowska v. Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA—WESTERN DIVISION
Sep 25, 2013
Case No.: CV11-00665 BRO (AGRx) (C.D. Cal. Sep. 25, 2013)

Summary

approving attorneys' fees based on 3,115 hours over 23 months of litigation

Summary of this case from Nelson v. Avon Prods., Inc.

Opinion

Case No.: CV11-00665 BRO (AGRx)

2013-09-25

ANNA SADOWSKA, YANICK GODBOUT, and TONYA DENDEKKER, individually, and on behalf of a class of similarly situated individuals, Plaintiffs, v. VOLKSWAGEN GROUP OF AMERICA, INC., VOLKSWAGEN AG, and AUDI AG, Defendants.


CLASS ACTION


ORDER GRANTING FINAL APPROVAL OF CLASS ACTION

SETTLEMENT, ATTORNEY'S FEES, EXPENSES, COSTS, CLASS

REPRESENTATIVE INCENTIVE AWARDS, AND JUDGMENT

ORDER AND JUDGMENT

The Court has received and considered the proposed Amended Settlement Agreement ("Settlement Agreement") between Plaintiffs Anna Sadowska, Yanick Godbout, and Tonya DenDekker on behalf of themselves and the Settlement Class (collectively, "Plaintiffs") and Defendant Volkswagen Group of America, Inc., Audi AG, and Volkswagen AG ( "Defendants") (Dkt. No. 85-2), which is incorporated herein by reference, including the adoption of defined terms. The Court has: (1) previously granted preliminary approval of the Amended Settlement Agreement; (2) been informed by declaration that notice of the settlement has been given to the Class (as defined below); (3) held a final fairness hearing at which all parties appeared by their counsel and at which the Court afforded class members with an opportunity to object to the Settlement Agreement ("Approval Hearing"); (4) received and reviewed briefing and evidence as to why the proposed settlement is fair, adequate, and in the best interests of the represented class; and (5) considered all other arguments and submissions in connection with the proposed settlement.

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED AS FOLLOWS:

1. All terms used herein shall have the same meaning as defined in the Amended Settlement Agreement.

2. This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of this litigation and over the Parties to this litigation, including all Class Members.

3. The Court certifies the following Settlement Class for purposes of settlement only: "All persons and entities who purchased or leased, within the United States of America, a 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005 and 2006 model year Audi A4 vehicle (including Cabriolets) and Audi A6 vehicle originally equipped with a factory-installed CVT transmission, imported and distributed by Volkswagen Group of America, Inc., for sale or lease in the United States of America." Excluded from the Settlement Class are (a) anyone claiming personal injury, property damage and/or subrogation; (b) all Judges who have presided over this Action and their spouses; (c) all current employees, officers, directors, agents and representatives of Defendants, and their family members; (d) any affiliate, parent or subsidiary of Defendants and any entity in which Defendants have a controlling interest; (e) anyone acting as a used car dealer; (f) anyone who purchased a Settlement Class Vehicle for the purpose of resale; (g) anyone who purchased a Settlement Class Vehicle with salvaged title and/or any insurance company who acquired a Settlement Class Vehicle as a result of a total loss; (h) any insurer of a Settlement Class Vehicle; (i) any owners or lessees of Settlement Class Vehicles which were not manufactured for export specifically into the United States of America and were not imported or distributed by Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.; and (j) any Settlement Class Member who has filed a timely and proper Request for Exclusion from the Settlement Class.

4. The Court appoints Plaintiffs Anna Sadowska, Yanick Godbout and Tonya DenDekker as representatives of the above-described Settlement Class.

5. The Court finds that Strategic Legal Practices APC and The Law Office of Robert Starr are experienced in matters of this nature and the Court hereby appoints said law firms as Class Counsel.

6. The mailing and publication of the Class Notice to the Class as set forth in the Amended Settlement Agreement has been completed in conformity with the March 11, 2013 Preliminary Approval Order (Dkt. No. 89). The Class Notice provided adequate notice of the proceedings and about the case, including the proposed settlement terms as set forth in the Amended Settlement Agreement. The Class Notice fully satisfied due process requirements. As executed, the Class Notice was the best notice practicable under the circumstances.

7. The Court finds that appropriate notice was given by defendant to all "appropriate State and Federal Officials" pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1715(a), and that no objections were filed.

8. The Court hereby approves the terms set forth in the Amended Settlement Agreement and finds that the Amended Settlement Agreement is, in all respects, fair, adequate, and reasonable and directs the Parties to effectuate the Amended Settlement Agreement according to its terms. The Court finds that the Amended Settlement Agreement has been reached as a result of informed and non-collusive arm's-length negotiations. The Court further finds that Plaintiffs and Defendants have conducted extensive investigation and research, and their attorneys were able to reasonably evaluate their respective positions.

9. The Court notes that under the Amended Settlement Agreement, any reimbursement checks issued to class members pursuant to the Settlement will be valid for a period of ninety (90) days.

10. The Court also finds that Settlement now will avoid additional and potentially substantial litigation costs, as well as delay and risks if the Parties were to continue to litigate the case. Additionally, after considering the prospective and monetary relief provided as part of the Settlement in light of the challenges posed by continued litigation, the Court concludes that Class Counsel secured significant relief for Class Members.

11. The Amended Settlement Agreement is not an admission by Defendants or by any other released party, nor is this Order a finding of the validity of any allegations or of any wrongdoing by Defendants or any other released party. Neither this Order, the Amended Settlement Agreement, nor any document referred to herein, nor any action taken to carry out the Amended Settlement Agreement, may be construed as, or may be used as, an admission of any fault, wrongdoing, omission, concession, or liability whatsoever by or against Defendants or any of the other released parties.

12. All Class Members were given a full and fair opportunity to participate in the Approval Hearing, and all members of the Settlement Class wishing to be heard have been heard. The objections of Melissa Seiler, Gregory Cohen, Maryann Woolsey, Kyle Krebs, Gregory T. McSparran, Geng Tian, Nicole Hyra, James Gates, and Deborah Morrisette are hereby overruled. The objection of Sara McKinney has been withdrawn. Members of the Settlement Class also have had a full and fair opportunity to exclude themselves from the proposed settlement and the class. Accordingly, the terms of the Amended Settlement Agreement and of the Court's Order shall be forever binding on members of the Class who did not timely exclude themselves. Attached to this Order and Judgment as Exhibit A is a list setting forth the name of each person who has requested exclusion from the Class under the procedures set forth in the Preliminary Approval Order.

13. To effectuate the Settlement, the Court hereby orders that all Class Members who did not timely exclude themselves from the Settlement are barred, enjoined, and restrained from commencing, prosecuting, or asserting any Released Claims against any Released Parties.

14. The Court has considered the Motion for Attorneys' Fees, Expenses, and Incentive Awards separately from its consideration of the fairness, reasonableness, and adequacy of the Amended Settlement Agreement. Any order or proceedings relating to the Motion for Attorneys' Fees, Expenses, and Incentive Awards, or any appeal from any order relating thereto or reversal or modification thereof, shall not disturb or affect this Judgment or affect or delay the finality of this Judgment.

15. The Court awards $2,375,000 in fees, costs, and expenses. Each of Plaintiffs' Counsel shall be reimbursed for its actual expenses and costs, totaling $168,796 to all Plaintiffs' Counsel. Initiative Legal Group shall be paid $66,330.69 in costs; Strategic Legal Practices shall be paid $52,714.67 in costs; and the Starr Firm shall be paid $49,750.73 in costs. From the $2,206,204 balance, Class Counsel shall pay $43,517.50 to attorney Dara Tabesh. Class Counsel shall then allocate the remaining balance of $2,162,686.50 according to the following percentages: 45% to Initiative Legal Group APC; 33% to Strategic Legal Practices, APC; and 22% to The Law Office of Robert L. Starr. Moreover, Plaintiffs' Counsel have agreed to share equally in the 5% referral fee payment that Starr intends to pay attorney Marc Legget from Starr's 22% portion of attorney fees.

16. The Court also approves incentive awards of $5000 to Anna Sadowska, $5000 to Yanick Godbout, and $1000 to Tonya DenDekker for their services on behalf of the Settlement Class, and accordingly orders Defendants to pay those amounts to Class Counsel for distribution to these Named Plaintiffs and class representatives.

17. The Court retains jurisdiction over the Parties to enforce the terms of the Order and Judgment, and shall have continuing jurisdiction over the construction, interpretation, implementation, and enforcement of the Amended Settlement Agreement in accordance with its terms.

IT IS SO ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED.

____________________________________________

HONORABLE BEVERLY REID O'CONNELL

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT JUDGE

EXHIBIT A


Name

VIN

1

GRANTJ GORTON

WAUAC48HX3K019707

2

CHARLES N RUSSELL

WAUAC48HX3K025863

3

ANDREW N LOVE

WAUAC48HX4K011561

4

ENRIQUE MONGE

WAUAC48HX4K014198

5

MARGARET A OKRASKI

WAUAC48HX5K024604

6

VALENTINE LSCHUSZLER

WAUAC48HX6K005374

7

CHRISTOPHER SLAY

WAUAC48HX6K007917

8

LEE EBERLY

WAUAC48H04K023847

9

JULIE B BULLARD

WAUAC48H15K002197

10

LAWRENCE H FRANKLIN

WAUAC48H16K002461

11

GEORGE CAMANY

WAUAC48H16K003903

12

JOSEPH D THOMAS

WAUAC48H16K008776

13

VICTORIA M ALTVATER

WAUAC48H23K022486

14

VINCENT P BAKIES

WAUAC48H25K012351

15

ANELISE A SACKS

WAUAC48H34K021963

16

HARVEY L MITCHELL

WAUAC48H35K001892

17

TANIAJ HURT

WAUAC48H36K009234

18

ANITA E HIDDING

WAUAC48H56K010241

19

BARBARA J CRAIG

WAUAC48H64K020242

20

JACQUELINE BADLER

WAUAC48H73K029420

21

NANCYS FITZGERALD

WAUAC48H73K033127

22

DENNIS SEAHOLM

WAUAC48H83K018393

23

MOUSTAPHA 1 TOURE

WAUAC48H84K024325

24

BONNIE J ZUKERMAN

WAUAC48H85K000480

25

BERIT ASTEEN

WAUAC48H85K008594

26

MICHAEL J PETERSON

WAUAC48H93K019231

27

THE DARROW 2007 TRUST

WAUAC48H95K012542

28

JOAN K BENEDICT

WAUAC48H96K009612

29

KIMBERLY KRAFT

WAUAC68D91A148128

30

JOSESAMPERIO

WAUAF68E35A488008

31

COLE VANKOMEN

WAUAF68E65A445511

32

TOBYD DEGRANDPRE

WAUAF68E85A518331

33

TOMOMI HIKOSAKA

WAUAF68E95A513218

34

THOMAS H FRAME

WAUAF78EX6A247442

35

NEIL R MARTIN

WAUAF78E05A577265

36

C M TYLER

WAUAF78E06A160231

37

BRIAN A LESTER

WAUAF78E06A289487

38

ERENA KUROKAWA

WAUAF78E16A170413

39

GLENN PORBON

WAUAF78E36A121021

40

REGAN M ROBERTS

WAUAF78E36A169134

41

AMANDA IAMARO

WAUAF78E36A182904

42

PATRICIA D BOYETTE

WAUAF78E36A218414

43

GORDON F & BETTE R MASON LIVIN

WAUAF78E36A250277

44

FOREST PLAZA LEASING PTNRS LLC

WAUAF78E56A114202

45

CHARLES HOWARD

WAUAF78E56A233268



Name

VIN

46

DEBORAH J MILHOUSE

WAUAF78E65A532962

47

ANDREW NEUMANN

WAUAF78E66A117108

48

JAMES W PELOQUIN

WAUAH74FX6N168967

49

BRIAN K LAPP

WAUAH74F06N162031

50

JORGE MARTINEZ

WAUAH74F56N136928

51

BRADLEY R LARSON

WAUAH74F86N127785

52

EDWARD J KING

WAUAT48H03K016413

53

JOHN A KENNEDY

WAUAT48H13K012824

54

JUDYCARCEDO

WAUAT48H15K015404

55

CHRISTOPHER J BALLE

WAUAT48H33K014669

56

MICHELLE BEVILACQUA

WAUAT48H43K014664

57

JUDITH A JACKSON

WAUAT48H43K017371

58

GEORGE TZAMARAS

WAUAT48H44K009871

59

WILLIAM MCANLY

WAUAT48H45K005174

60

LUIZ R GONZAGA

WAUAT48H53K008078

61

GLORIA J TARADASH

WAUAT48H53K011000

62

JOSEPHS HINCKLEY

WAUAT48H53K014950

63

DEBORAH MVISCOMI

WAUAT48H53K027391

64

CRAIG W CLARK

WAUAT48H73K012861

65

ROBERT B MCLAUGHLIN

WAUAT48H73K020989

66

ARMAND MARTEL

WAUAT48H84K005371

67

JAY L GROSSMAN

WAUAT48H84K025054

68

JOYCE T KOCH

WAUAT48H93K021206

69

NANCY BIRD

WAUBA34B1XN010887

70

R L OR K SAMSAL CO TRSTEES OF THE R L

WAUBC5443LN024758

71

ANDERJIMENEZ

WAUBF78E16A243865

72

SCOTT KEAWEKANE

WAUBF78E76A054976

73

SUZANNE M MYCORN

WAUJC68EX3A159540

74

RAUL M GARCIA

WAUJC68EX4A072075

75

DEMIAN F WYMA

WAUJC68EX4A194063

76

CANGIR ELCIN

WAUJC68E14A167091

77

JOHNGCAARNEVALE

WAUJC68E23A337926

78

ROBERT M SAYAD

WAUJC68E24A146363

79

JU H CHOI

WAUJC68E34A069924

80

JAVIER H CARRILLO

WAUJC68E34A119446

81

HYUNDAI OF EVERETT LLC

WAUJC68E34A212077

82

DAVID KORNELY

WAUJC68E35A074641

83

TOM JONES FORD INC

WAUJC68E63A148017

84

CHARLES SHAYDEN

WAUJC68E63A168686

85

VICENTE M CASTRO

WAUJC68E63A275706

86

DIANNEJ JALANDONI

WAUJC68E64A139724

87

ORLANDO PENALOZA

WAUJC68E64A232274

88

JESSICA B ROMERO

WAUJC68E65A091224

89

AMANU DDIN

WAUJC68E65A109205

90

BETH A BADER

WAUJC68E73A315050



Name

VIN

91

ANN BBONOMI

WAUJC68E74A140056

92

WANDAS MOODY

WAUJC68E82A166730

93

HELMUT SASSENFELD

WAUJC68E93A218691

94

JUSTIN J PALMROSE

WAUJC68E94A032151

95

ALBERTC BURROWS

WAUJC68E95A054085

96

JAMES A MIMS

WAUJT54B82N075391

97

DONALD BARANY

WAUJT64BX3N020612

98

JAMES J PIETKA

WAUJT64B12N103604

99

ROLAND GALLIOTTE

WAUJT64B23N071960

100

SCOTT P DEGRAND

WAUJT64B24N059857

101

NATHAN V WRIGHT

WAUJT64B43N011288

102

PATRICK A SANTAVENERE

WAUJT68EX2A178183

103

STEPAN GRASHCHENKOV

WAUJT68E04A125284

104

ANIL KOTHAVALE

WAUJT68E24A055366

105

BURT C YOUNG

WAUJT68E72A242728

106

ACCURATE ENGINEERING

WAUJT68E75A040637

107

ANTONIO CORTES

WAUJT68E83A171606

108

JOSE A USSERY

WAUJT68E94A109083

109

LEWIS L IMMERMAN

WAUAC48HX4K014993

110

PAMELA OORCZYK-BECK

WAUAC48HX6K008341

111

ARTHUR MACZEI

WAUAC48H03K024205

112

PHILLIP A TYGART

WAUAC48H04K009625

113

MYRATESLUK

WAUAC48H15K003463

114

ROBERT LASH

WAUAC48H24K007732

115

STUART W JONES

WAUAC48H24K008220

116

DIANNE D GARDNER

WAUAC48H34K010526

117

DANNY DWOMBOLD

WAUAC48H36K004065

118

LEONA R LEVITT

WAUAC48H36K007337

119

WANDA MYERS

WAUAC48H45K019575

120

MARGUERITE B WERTZ

WAUAC48H55K005670

121

GAILA BENNETT

WAUAC48H56K002754

122

HERBERT A DIETZEL

WAUAC48H64K006390

123

DARREN L BAKER

WAUAC48H65K005077

124

PATRICIA A KARPOWICZ

WAUAC48H66K007526

125

MILTON 0 PETERSON

WAUAC48H66K009115

126

MADELINES BECKER

WAUAC48H75K015505

127

KAREN P HERMAN

WAUAC48H76K006739

128

SHIRLEY J NARKS

WAUAC48H76K007325

129

ROBIN C WINTER

WAUAC48H76K010127

130

TOMMY GJORGENSEN

WAUAC48H85K017490

131

ALBERT OETTINGER

WAUAC48H86K006622

132

DEBORAH SLEMMERMAN

WAUAC48H94K006660

133

ERIN A COOPER

WAUAC48H95K013061

134

LEE HILLIN

WAUAF68E05A490184

135

SEA AUTO SALES

WAUAF68E45A450108



Name

VIN

136

ROBERT H HALL

WAUAF68E45A462663

137

KEVIN A MCHUGH

WAUAF68E55A452174

138

LINDAAANTONE

WAUAF68E65A489895

139

DAVID L DEVENY

WAUAF68E75A462236

140

LAWRENCE D FAHLBERG

WAUAF68E75A497715

141

JOSE L OCADIZ

WAUAF68E85A466201

142

DANALBARONE

WAUAF78EX6A212920

143

RANDI LVALLEJO

WAUAF78E06A037092

144

MICHAEL C KARNES

WAUAF78E06A235056

145

JAYNE U KIM

WAUAF78E06A244646

146

JOAN CANIANO

WAUAF78E06A249216

147

ROBERTO LVALLEJO

WAUAF78E26A026451

148

DAVID M SMITH

WAUAF78E26A193201

149

GABRIEL B GARCIA

WAUAF78E56A134725

150

CHERYL M LASSITER

WAUAF78E66A161125

151

FRANCISCO ROMERO

WAUAF78E96A263258

152

JAMES E OR SHARON A ROBERTSON

WAUAF84D7VN006836

153

SERGIO DESANTIAGO

WAUAF98E86A185387

154

CHRISTOPHER SEBESTA

WAUAH74F46N127282

155

JUDY L LANCASTER

WAUAH78E56A261484

156

MICHELE A NANNINI

WAUAH78E86A244839

157

LYN PERDUE

WAUAT48HX3K010635

158

JEROME P SANDERS

WAUAT48HX3K014149

159

MARJORIE M SELDIN

WAUAT48HX3K023059

160

LENA M CRESSOTTI

WAUAT48H13K011656

161

TODD AJACKMAN

WAUAT48H13K017375

162

ANN S LAWRENCE

WAUAT48H15K011630

163

RAUL RDEPERSIA COLON

WAUAT48H24K012882

164

TERRYD HORNSETH

WAUAT48H33K016275

165

OVES ARVIDSON

WAUAT48H44K006887

166

CHERI L GAUL

WAUAT48H63K009725

167

WDUICE BENTON CO INC

WAUAT48H83K008401

168

JAMES DIAMOND

WAUBC48H36K002837

169

TRAVIS KEERAN

WAUBF78E66A026666

170

WARD CHEN

WAUBH74F56N171487

171

MESSICK,CLARENCE OR DOLORES

WAUBJ54A3NN052087

172

LUTHER GTROUTMAN

WAUJC58E82A188902

173

DEBORAH L BRANTS

WAUJC68EX2A133552

174

GARY W NUZUM

WAUJC68EX5A026926

175

STEVEN R EWING

WAUJC68EX5A075964

176

SHIRLEY KSIGGERS

WAUJC68E12A112377

177

HENRY SANABRIA

WAUJC68E13A114132

178

JOHN LASTOR-CASALDUC

WAUJC68E22A083729

179

AARON J CLARK

WAUJC68E23A336162

180

THOMAS J LINDELL

WAUJC68E32A183841



Name

VIN

181

CHUCKH NG

WAUJC68E35A106195

182

MARY M MOTT

WAUJC68E43A269922

183

STANLEY COVEY

WAUJC68E44A089633

184

MARY BLAKSTAD

WAUJC68E45A007918

185

LOIS H GREENBLUM

WAUJC68E53A203153

186

KELLY K PEREKOVICH

WAUJC68E53A295073

187

JENNIFER RFURLOTT

WAUJC68E54A002225

188

SUSAN M HARVELL

WAUJC68E63A269548

189

RICHARD CSCHENCK

WAUJC68E63A329733

190

BOB CALDWELL CHRYSLER JEEP DOD

WAUJC68E73A149841

191

SEAN HASSAN

WAUJC68E75A120505

192

EDDIE N LUGO

WAUJC68E82A212654

193

ASHLEY M LINNENBURGER

WAUJC68E84A169162

194

ROBERT LVALLEJO

WAUJC68E94A093158

195

SANDRA A ESQUIBEL

WAUJC68E95A101213

196

ATKINS DAVID & KIM OK CHA

WAUJT58E62A187800

197

GABOR F KISZLI

WAUJT64BX3N032243

198

ODETTA S BRYANT

WAUJT64BX3N071561

199

DAVID A DUPREY

WAUJT64B03N035071

200

PAMELA J WATSON

WAUJT64B14N045318

201

RICHARD H HUFFMAN

WAUJT64B32N052638

202

WILLIAM DCOUTURIE

WAUJT64B44N060430

203

CHARLES A TURACK

WAUJT64B52N043567

204

JANETS ROSSI

WAUJT64B63N079429

205

ROBERT J PAPLASKI

WAUJT64B82N068530

206

IONTVLAS

WAUJT64B83N015103

207

LAWRENCE HOWARD

WAUJT64B84N005141

208

JAMES BEDARD

WAUJT64B93N059269

209

RICHARD G NORBRATEN

WAUJT64B93N103755

210

CLAIRE HERRMANN

WAUJT68E12A153169

211

JOHN G LEHR

WAUJT68E14A086785

212

PATRICK OUJEZDSKY

WAUJT68E23A383871

213

BREEANN L LOUDEN

WAUJT68E24A227668

214

KAREN K MACDONALD

WAUJT68E33A288252

215

WHITNEY EBIRDWELL

WAUJT68E62A245054




Summaries of

Sadowska v. Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA—WESTERN DIVISION
Sep 25, 2013
Case No.: CV11-00665 BRO (AGRx) (C.D. Cal. Sep. 25, 2013)

approving attorneys' fees based on 3,115 hours over 23 months of litigation

Summary of this case from Nelson v. Avon Prods., Inc.

approving attorneys' fees based on 3,115 hours over 23 months of litigation

Summary of this case from Mendoza v. Hyundai Motor Co.

overruling objections where the objector was not required to purchase the third party service contract

Summary of this case from Corzine v. Whirlpool Corp.
Case details for

Sadowska v. Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.

Case Details

Full title:ANNA SADOWSKA, YANICK GODBOUT, and TONYA DENDEKKER, individually, and on…

Court:UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA—WESTERN DIVISION

Date published: Sep 25, 2013

Citations

Case No.: CV11-00665 BRO (AGRx) (C.D. Cal. Sep. 25, 2013)

Citing Cases

Tadepalli v. Uber Techs., Inc.

"'Because the Settlement Class has not changed, the Court sees no reason to revisit the analysis of Rule…

Ruch v. AM Retail Grp., Inc.

"'Because the Settlement Class has not changed, the Court sees no reason to revisit the analysis of Rule…