From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Ryan v. Brown

Supreme Court, Appellate Term
Jun 1, 1906
51 Misc. 67 (N.Y. App. Term 1906)

Opinion

June, 1906.

Isaac Josephson, for appellant.

Respondents filing no brief.


This case was tried and judgment rendered on January 16, 1906, dismissing the complaint with costs. On January 25, 1906, a motion was made to "correct" the judgment. This motion came on to be heard on January twenty-ninth and an order was entered which provided "that the judgment of dismissal rendered herein on the 16th day of January, 1906, in favor of the defendant and against the plaintiffs be and the same hereby is corrected by giving and rendering a judgment for the plaintiffs against the defendant for the sum of seventeen dollars and forty cents with interest amounting to eighty-seven cents, amounting in all to eighteen dollars and twenty-seven cents as conceded due by the defendant on the trial hereof as appears by the stenographer's minutes." The only power given a justice of the Municipal Court to "vacate, amend or modify any judgment" rendered by him is conferred by section 254 of the Municipal Court Act. A motion to "correct" a judgment is simply another way of asking for an amendment or modification of a judgment. Even if a trial justice can, under the guise of a modification of a judgment, entirely change it from being in favor of a party to one against him, the motion for such purpose must be made within the statutory time (five days), which was not done in this case. Buchsbaum v. Feldman, 43 Misc. 85; Lissner v. Cohen, 49 id. 272.

The order is reversed, with costs.

Present: GILDERSLEEVE, LEVENTRITT and McCALL, JJ.

Order reversed, with costs.


Summaries of

Ryan v. Brown

Supreme Court, Appellate Term
Jun 1, 1906
51 Misc. 67 (N.Y. App. Term 1906)
Case details for

Ryan v. Brown

Case Details

Full title:JAMES F. RYAN and JOHN LEVER, Respondents, v . GEORGE BROWN, Appellant

Court:Supreme Court, Appellate Term

Date published: Jun 1, 1906

Citations

51 Misc. 67 (N.Y. App. Term 1906)
99 N.Y.S. 863

Citing Cases

Willis v. Willis

"A motion to 'correct' a judgment is simply another way of asking for an amendment or modification of a…

Rice v. Simmons

We have found no federal case to the contrary. See also Columbia River Packers Ass'n, Inc., v. Hinton, D.C.D.…