From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Rowland v. Mitchell

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Feb 1, 1884
90 N.C. 649 (N.C. 1884)

Summary

In Mitchell v. Rowland, 95 Iowa 314, 63 N.W. 606, an appeal was taken from an order appointing a receiver after appeal and supersedeas of the judgment, the other facts being similar to those in this case, and the Iowa statute being practically identical with our own.

Summary of this case from Perkins v. National Bond Investment Co.

Opinion

(February Term, 1884.)

Appeal, cause remanded.

Where a transcript on appeal contains only the judgment of the court below, and shows no process or pleading, the cause will be remanded.

( Weil v. Everitt, 83 N.C. 685, cited and approved).

APPEAL from a judgment rendered at Fall Term, 1883, of GRANVILLE Superior Court, by MacRae, J.

Messrs. J. B. Batchelor and L. C. Edwards, for plaintiff.

No counsel for defendant.


The plaintiff appealed.


The transcript of the record before us certified to be "full and accurate," contains only the judgment rendered in the superior court, reciting that the case comes up on appeal from a justice's court, the case embodying the exceptions signed by the respective counsel, and the appeal undertaking.

There is no process, nor waiver, nor pleading by which we can see that the cause was properly constituted in the superior court, nor, except from the case, what was the subject of contention.

We cannot assume jurisdiction upon such a record, and must, according to the rules for such imperfections, remand the cause. Weil v. Everitt, 83 N.C. 685.


Summaries of

Rowland v. Mitchell

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Feb 1, 1884
90 N.C. 649 (N.C. 1884)

In Mitchell v. Rowland, 95 Iowa 314, 63 N.W. 606, an appeal was taken from an order appointing a receiver after appeal and supersedeas of the judgment, the other facts being similar to those in this case, and the Iowa statute being practically identical with our own.

Summary of this case from Perkins v. National Bond Investment Co.
Case details for

Rowland v. Mitchell

Case Details

Full title:ROWLAND BROTHERS v. R. J. MITCHELL SON

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Feb 1, 1884

Citations

90 N.C. 649 (N.C. 1884)

Citing Cases

Daniel v. Rogers

No counsel for the defendants. ( Rowland v. Mitchell, 90 N.C. 649, cited and approved). For the reasons set…

Bethea v. Byrd

3. The irregular practice of sending up, by piecemeal, essential portions of the record will be no further…