From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Porter v. Houghton

Supreme Court of Georgia
Feb 5, 2001
273 Ga. 407 (Ga. 2001)

Opinion

S00A1892.

DECIDED: FEBRUARY 5, 2001.

Title to land. Lee Superior Court. Before Judge Smith.

Adam R. Gaslowitz, Walter Hamberg III, Adam R. Gaslowitz Associates, Suite 2210 Marquis One Tower 245 Peachtree Center Avenue N.E., Atlanta Ga., 30303, Attorneys for Appellant.

John V. Harper, Harper Barnes, P.C., P.O. Drawer 784 Americus Ga., 31709, Attorney for Appellee.


Herman Houghton brought a declaratory action against his late wife's siblings seeking to establish that the siblings had no interest in lands Houghton claimed were owned by his wife at her death. However, we conclude that declaratory judgment was not available to establish his claim, and we reverse.

A declaratory judgment is not the proper action to decide all justiciable controversies. To proceed under a declaratory judgment a party must establish that it is necessary to relieve himself of the risk of taking some future action that, without direction, would jeopardize his interests. The record reveals that Houghton has failed to make that showing.

See Sapp v. ABC Credit Investment Co., 243 Ga. 151,159 (1979).

Id.

The current record would, however, allow Houghton to proceed under the Quiet Title Act of 1966, OCGA § 23-3-60, because a purpose of that statute is for "readily and conclusively establishing that certain named persons are the owners of all the interests in land defined by a decree entered in such proceeding." In cases such as this involving record title to numerous tracts of land and multiple parties, declaratory judgment relief will seldom, if ever, be available. However, the quiet title in rem action, which affords complete relief within a procedural framework providing adequate safeguards of the rights of all parties is always available, subject to the limitations of OCGA § 23-3-61.

Judgment reversed. All the Justices concur.

DECIDED FEBRUARY 5, 2001.


Summaries of

Porter v. Houghton

Supreme Court of Georgia
Feb 5, 2001
273 Ga. 407 (Ga. 2001)
Case details for

Porter v. Houghton

Case Details

Full title:PORTER et al. v. HOUGHTON

Court:Supreme Court of Georgia

Date published: Feb 5, 2001

Citations

273 Ga. 407 (Ga. 2001)
542 S.E.2d 491

Citing Cases

Acevedo v. Kim

After a brief detour through the Court of Appeals, we granted Acevedo's application for discretionary appeal…

Smith v. Jones

1. Smith does not challenge the trial court's determination that the Club is the owner of the school…