From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Peppers v. Elder

Supreme Court of Georgia
Sep 9, 1981
281 S.E.2d 582 (Ga. 1981)

Opinion

37597.

DECIDED SEPTEMBER 9, 1981.

Cancellation, etc. Barrow Superior Court. Before Judge Brooks.

William D. Healan, Jr., for appellant.

John E. Stell, Richard B. Russell III, N. David Wages, for appellees.


The appeal is from the sustaining of a motion to dismiss.

Barrow County closed County Road Number 79 at the request of all of the adjacent landowners. The County then quitclaimed the former county roadway to the adjacent property owners. When the adjacent owners caused a ditch to be dug across the roadway, Jackson L. Peppers, in his capacity as a citizen-taxpayer of Barrow County, filed the present equity and mandamus action against the county and the adjoining landowners to set aside the conveyance, to remove the obstruction and to require the county to maintain the roadway as a public road.

After a jury was struck, Barrow County and the adjoining landowners orally moved to dismiss the complaint for failure to state a claim and for lack of standing to sue. The motion was heard in chambers without a reporter present and was granted, prompting this appeal.

1. Peppers first contends that he should have been given thirty days to respond to the motion because matters outside the pleadings were considered. Riverhill Community Assn. v. Cobb County Bd. of Commrs., 236 Ga. 856, 859 ( 226 S.E.2d 54) (1976). A respondent to a motion to dismiss is entitled to notice of conversion of the motion into one for summary judgment and to thirty days to respond to the motion for summary judgment unless such notice and opportunity are waived. Atlanta Associates v. Westminister Properties, Inc., 242 Ga. 462 ( 249 S.E.2d 252) (1978); Royston v. Royston, 236 Ga. 648 ( 225 S.E.2d 41) (1976). By consenting to the hearing of the motion in chambers that day and by arguing the merits of the motion without objecting to lack of notice, Peppers waived his right to notice and to further opportunity to respond. Register v. Kandlbinder, 231 Ga. 786 ( 204 S.E.2d 145) (1974).

2. Peppers concedes that the statutory notice to property owners required of a county before the closing of a county road need not have been given to him because he does not own property located on the road in issue. Code Ann. § 95A-619 (b); See, McIntosh County v. Fisher, 242 Ga. 66 ( 247 S.E.2d 863) (1978); see also, Avery v. Berry Schools, 211 Ga. 581 ( 87 S.E.2d 401) (1955). Instead, he asks, in essence, that this court create such a notice requirement so as to give all county residents an opportunity to object to the closing of a county road. We are of the opinion that the General Assembly has spoken on the subject of those persons to whom such a notice should be given, and that the question of whether all residents of the county should receive notice of county road closings is one which properly should be addressed to the General Assembly rather than to this court.

3. The court apparently considered without objection the affidavit of one of the adjacent property owners in which the affiant swore that the road had ceased to be used by the public to the extent that no substantial purpose is served by it. Accordingly, the road was closed for the benefit of the public rather than for the private benefit of property owners adjacent to it. McIntosh County v. Fisher, supra.

Judgment affirmed. Hill, P. J., Marshall, Clarke, Smith and Gregory, JJ., concur.

DECIDED SEPTEMBER 9, 1981.


Summaries of

Peppers v. Elder

Supreme Court of Georgia
Sep 9, 1981
281 S.E.2d 582 (Ga. 1981)
Case details for

Peppers v. Elder

Case Details

Full title:PEPPERS v. ELDER et al

Court:Supreme Court of Georgia

Date published: Sep 9, 1981

Citations

281 S.E.2d 582 (Ga. 1981)
281 S.E.2d 582

Citing Cases

Travis Pruitt Assocs., P.C. v. Hooper

The record shows that Hooper did not waive the requirement set forth in OCGA § 9-11-56 that she be given 30…

Spivey v. Safeway Ins. Co.

The record does not reflect what steps, if any, were taken to provide Spivey with notice and an opportunity…