From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

People's Furniture Co., Inc. v. Harris

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Orleans
Jun 27, 1932
142 So. 878 (La. Ct. App. 1932)

Opinion

No. 14089.

June 27, 1932.

Appeal from First City Court of New Orleans, Wm. V. Seeber, Judge.

Action by the People's Furniture Company, Incorporated, against Henry Harris. Judgment for plaintiff, and defendant appeals.

Affirmed.

Frederick G. Veith, of New Orleans, for appellant.

Rolf I. Seeberg, of New Orleans, for appellee.


Plaintiff sues for a balance of $299 claimed to be due for furniture sold and delivered to defendant. A writ of sequestration was obtained and the furniture seized by the constable.

Defendant has left the state of Louisiana and is now sojourning in Atlanta, Ga.; but, on his behalf, his wife resists payment, claiming that the account is incorrect.

She testified that she had made certain payments which should have been credited on the furniture account, but which, through error, was entered on the books of plaintiff as payments on jewelry previously purchased.

She admitted that there was a balance due, but claimed that if the proper credit had been given the account would have been substantially reduced. This defense is in the nature of a plea of payment and a plea of payment should be specially made. Since there was no such plea, her evidence in support thereof should have been excluded, since there was timely objection thereto. However, if the plea had been specially made, the burden of proving payment would have been on defendant, and the only evidence given in support of the defense is that of defendant's wife, and it is most indefinite and uncertain.

The trial judge disregarded it, and we feel that he was correct.

The judgment appealed from is affirmed.

Affirmed.


Summaries of

People's Furniture Co., Inc. v. Harris

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Orleans
Jun 27, 1932
142 So. 878 (La. Ct. App. 1932)
Case details for

People's Furniture Co., Inc. v. Harris

Case Details

Full title:PEOPLE'S FURNITURE CO., Inc., v. HARRIS

Court:Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Orleans

Date published: Jun 27, 1932

Citations

142 So. 878 (La. Ct. App. 1932)

Citing Cases

Swann v. Holley

As correctly contended by plaintiff, the party relying upon payment as a defense bears the burden of proving…