Summary
concluding detention of complainant was incidental to commission of uncharged crime of rape
Summary of this case from State v. SalamonOpinion
June 26, 1978
Appeal by defendant from a judgment of the Supreme Court, Kings County, rendered June 2, 1975, convicting him of kidnapping in the second degree, upon a jury verdict, and imposing sentence. Judgment modified, on the law, by reducing the conviction to one of unlawful imprisonment in the first degree and vacating the sentence imposed. As so modified, judgment affirmed and case remitted to Criminal Term for resentence in accordance herewith. The complainant was locking her car door when she was approached by the defendant-appellant, who took a revolver out "from the side of his jacket" and demanded money from her. Pressing the gun against her ribs, he forced her to accompany him to Prospect Park, where he raped her. The entire incident lasted more than one hour. Defendant was convicted of kidnapping in the second degree. In People v Cassidy ( 40 N.Y.2d 763, 767), the court stated: "The merger doctrine * * * preclude[s] conviction for kidnapping based on acts which are so much the part of another substantive crime that the substantive crime could not have been committed without such acts and that independent criminal responsibility may not fairly be attributed to them." We hold that defendant's conviction of kidnapping in the second degree (Penal Law, § 135.20) cannot stand. The proof of that crime was insufficient; the evidence revealed that any detention of the complainant was incidental to the commission of the uncharged crime of rape (cf. People v Fraser, 54 A.D.2d 965; People v Webster, 54 A.D.2d 703). However, this insufficiency should not result in a dismissal of the charge. Since the crime of unlawful imprisonment in the first degree was established beyond a reasonable doubt, we have modified the judgment accordingly (see People v Webb, 59 A.D.2d 618; People v Fraser, supra; People v Webster, supra; People v Ennis, 50 A.D.2d 935). Martuscello, J.P., Rabin, Gulotta and Cohalan, JJ., concur.