From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Panter v. Panter

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine
Nov 7, 1985
499 A.2d 1233 (Me. 1985)

Summary

In Panter, we vacated a divorce judgment in which the husband died after the entry of a divorce judgment, but during the pendency of an appeal that had already been filed.

Summary of this case from MacPherson v. Estate

Opinion

Argued June 7, 1984.

Decided November 7, 1985.

Appeal from the Superior Court, York County.

James M. Dineen, (orally), Kittery, for plaintiff.

Willard Kellis, Robert J. Foley, (orally), Basil L. Kellis, Sanford, for defendant.

Before McKUSICK, C.J., and NICHOLS, ROBERTS, WATHEN, GLASSMAN and SCOLNIK, JJ.


The Plaintiff, Annie C. Panter, appeals from a divorce judgment entered June 24, 1983, in the Superior Court, York County, contending that the divorce court erred in denying her motion for findings of fact and conclusions of law. She also assigns error to that court's division of the marital property between her and her late husband, William J. Panter, Jr., as well as to the court's failure to award her alimony and attorney's fees. When the husband's death occurred in December, 1984, his Personal Representative was substituted as the party Defendant.

When the wife appealed, it had the effect of staying the Superior Court's judgment of divorce during the pendency of her appeal. M.R.Civ.P. 62(e). With the husband's death the judgment of divorce — and, of course, the division of marital property as well — became mooted. The power of the court to determine property rights is dependent upon the granting of a divorce to one of the parties. Inasmuch as the entire action thus abated, this cause must be remanded to the Superior Court with instructions to dismiss this cause from its docket.

See generally Annot., 33 A.L.R.4th 47 (1984).

The entry:

Judgment vacated.

Remanded for further proceedings consistent with the opinion herein.

All concurring.


Summaries of

Panter v. Panter

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine
Nov 7, 1985
499 A.2d 1233 (Me. 1985)

In Panter, we vacated a divorce judgment in which the husband died after the entry of a divorce judgment, but during the pendency of an appeal that had already been filed.

Summary of this case from MacPherson v. Estate
Case details for

Panter v. Panter

Case Details

Full title:Annie C. PANTER v. Stephen W. PANTER, Personal Representative of the…

Court:Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Date published: Nov 7, 1985

Citations

499 A.2d 1233 (Me. 1985)

Citing Cases

MacPherson v. Estate

As M.R. Civ. P. 80(f) also provides, "any order granting a divorce . . . shall be a final judgment." [¶ 6]…

Estate of Banks v. Banks

[¶ 7] There is no question that the July 16, 2008, divorce judgment fully decided the matters incident to the…