From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

O'Neil v. Department of Finance

Supreme Court of Illinois
Apr 18, 1935
196 N.E. 463 (Ill. 1935)

Opinion

No. 22478. Decree affirmed.

Opinion filed April 18, 1935 Rehearing denied June 12, 1935.

APPEAL from the Circuit Court of Cook county; the Hon. WILLIAM V. BROTHERS, Judge, presiding.

BERNARD I. DEENY, and GEORGE F. KILLINGER, (LEO B. CONDIT, of counsel,) for appellants.

OTTO KERNER, Attorney General, (MONTGOMERY S. WINNING, JAMES G. SKINNER, and JOSEPH J. DRUCKER, of counsel,) for appellees.


Appellants, as owners and operators of restaurants, filed in the circuit court of Cook county, in their own behalf and on behalf of all other persons similarly situated, a bill to enjoin appellees, the Director of Finance and the Assistant Director of Finance, respectively, and all officials and agents of the Department of Finance of the State of Illinois, from prosecuting or arresting them or otherwise seeking to enforce against them an act entitled, "An act in relation to a tax upon persons engaged in the business of selling tangible personal property to purchasers for use or consumption," and known as the Retailers' Occupation Tax act, approved June 28, 1933. The basis of the complaint in the bill is that the officers of the Department of Finance are threatening to enforce the act against them, whereas the act does not apply to those engaged in the business of the appellants. Appellees demurred generally to the bill. The demurrer was sustained and the bill dismissed for want of equity.

The question arising here is whether the Retailers' Occupation Tax act applies to restaurant keepers. This question is decided in Brevoort Hotel Co. v. Ames, ( post, p. 485.) That decision is controlling here.

The decree will be affirmed.

Decree affirmed.


Summaries of

O'Neil v. Department of Finance

Supreme Court of Illinois
Apr 18, 1935
196 N.E. 463 (Ill. 1935)
Case details for

O'Neil v. Department of Finance

Case Details

Full title:HARRY O'NEIL et al. Appellants, vs. THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE et al…

Court:Supreme Court of Illinois

Date published: Apr 18, 1935

Citations

196 N.E. 463 (Ill. 1935)
196 N.E. 463

Citing Cases

Pappanastos v. State Tax Commission

Such operators sell commodities which are taxable. In re Opinion of the Justices, 266 Mass. 590, 165 N.E.…