Opinion
Appeal from the superior court of Lake county.
COUNSEL
Cape & Boyd and T. A. O’Brien, for appellant.
John S. Bugbee, for respondent.
OPINION
BY THE COURT.
Appeals from an order granting a new trial. The decision and judgment, which the court set aside, were founded upon substantially conflicting evidence, bearing upon the main questions, as issue between the parties, as to the existence and extent of the subordinate claims and liens against the building in controversy; and as the court set the judgment aside and granted a new trial upon the ground that the evidence was insufficient to justify them, this court, in the absence of a manifest abuse of discretion, will not disturb the order. Guttierrez v. Brinkerhoff, 9 P. C. L. J. 734; Blum v. Sunol, 11 P. C. L. J. 275; Pierce v. Schaden, 55 Cal. 406; Bronner v. Wetzlar, Id. 419.
Order affirmed.