From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

MOTOR CO. v. REEP

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Nov 1, 1923
119 S.E. 821 (N.C. 1923)

Opinion

(Filed 21 November, 1923.)

Appeal and Error — Motions — Certiorari — Record — Dismissal — Rules of Court.

It is indispensable for the appellant to conform to the rule requiring that he aptly file the record proper of his case with his motion for a certiorari to bring it up to the Supreme Court; otherwise, it will be dismissed upon appellee's motion made in accordance with the rules regulating appeals.

THIS was a motion under Rule 17 of this Court, 185, N.C. 792, regularly made, upon the proper certificate, to docket and dismiss this appeal. The case was tried at April Term of GASTON, and the certificate is in proper form and filed in proper time, and the appellants failed to bring up and file a transcript of the record seven days before the call of the docket of the causes from that district.

S. T. Durham for plaintiff.

Woltz Woltz and George W. Wilson for defendant.


This case was tried at the April Term, 1923, of Gaston. It was requisite that the appellant should docket his appeal in this Court seven days before the call of the Fourteenth District, to which it belongs. The only exception under Rule 17 is that if for any sufficient reason the full record of the case on appeal could not be docketed in time, the appellant must file, seven days before the call of the district, the record proper, and upon sufficient cause apply for a certiorari. The plaintiff makes this motion, but has not filed any record proper, or in any respect complied with the requirements of the rule which applies to all other appellants.

The appellant filed, it is true, a statement that he appealed, and that he asked the clerk of the court below to send up the record, but avers that by some mistake the clerk confused it with another record and has failed to send it up. The clerk of the court below, in contradiction, filed a statement that such application to send up the case was not made so far as is recalled by the clerk's office, but, however that might be, it was incumbent upon this appellant, as upon all others, to see that his case was sent up and docketed in time; and in any event if, without fault of the appellant, this was not done, it was his duty to have gotten a copy of the record proper, duly certified by the clerk, and filed it in the office of this Court seven days before the call of the docket as an indispensable requisite for a motion for certiorari to cure the defect to bring up the appeal in time. This has not been done, and the appellant does not even allege that he has paid, or tendered the cost of making out the record, or has taken any steps whatever to have it sent up.

The motion for certiorari in this, as in all other cases under like circumstances, must be denied, and the motion to docket and dismiss must be allowed. The precedents to this effect are numerous and uniform.

Motion for certiorari denied.

Motion to docket and dismiss allowed.


Summaries of

MOTOR CO. v. REEP

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Nov 1, 1923
119 S.E. 821 (N.C. 1923)
Case details for

MOTOR CO. v. REEP

Case Details

Full title:WASHAM PATTERSON MOTOR COMPANY v. H. B. REEP

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Nov 1, 1923

Citations

119 S.E. 821 (N.C. 1923)
119 S.E. 821

Citing Cases

Citizens Co. v. Typographical Union

It is an unincorporated association and cannot be sued. In Tucker v. Eatough, individually and as agent for…