From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Morgan v. Turnage Co., Inc.

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Apr 1, 1938
196 S.E. 307 (N.C. 1938)

Opinion

(Filed 13 April, 1938.)

1. Parties § 5 —

The trial court has the power to order the joinder of additional parties defendant when the order does not change the cause of action.

2. Appeal and Error § 37b —

Ordinarily, an order making additional parties is not prejudicial, and therefore such orders are usually discretionary and not reviewable.

APPEAL by defendant from Olive, Special Judge, at September Term, 1937, of PITT. Appeal dismissed.

Wm. J. Bundy and John Hill Paylor for plaintiff.

Albion Dunn for defendant.


The defendant appealed from an order of the court below making additional parties defendant. The power of the judge to make additional parties to an action is well settled, and it does not appear that the order appealed from will change the cause of action or work injustice to the appellant. Tillery v. Candler, 118 N.C. 888, 24 S.E. 709; Mills v. Callahan, 126 N.C. 756, 36 S.E. 164; Bernard v. Shemwell, 139 N.C. 446, 52 S.E. 64; Joyner v. Fiber Co., 178 N.C. 634, 101 S.E. 373; Barbee v. Cannady, 191 N.C. 529, 132 S.E. 281; Wilmington v. Board of Education, 210 N.C. 197, 185 S.E. 767.

As was said in Bernard v. Shemwell, supra, "It can very rarely happen that making an additional party will be a serious prejudice, and hence such orders are usually discretionary and not reviewable."

Appeal dismissed.


Summaries of

Morgan v. Turnage Co., Inc.

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Apr 1, 1938
196 S.E. 307 (N.C. 1938)
Case details for

Morgan v. Turnage Co., Inc.

Case Details

Full title:E. M. MORGAN v. THE TURNAGE COMPANY, INC

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Apr 1, 1938

Citations

196 S.E. 307 (N.C. 1938)
196 S.E. 307

Citing Cases

Raleigh v. Edwards

This conclusion has explicit support in well considered decisions recognizing and enforcing the specific rule…

Joyner v. Fiber Co.

Affirmed. Cited: Barber v. Cannady, 191 N.C. 534; Benevolent Assoc. v. Neal, 193 N.C. 403; Goins v. Sargent,…