MONSANTO COMPANY v. E.I. DU PONT DE NEMOURS COMPANY

Full title: MONSANTO COMPANY and MONSANTO TECHNOLOGY LLC, Plaintiffs, v. E.I. DU PONT…

Court: United States District Court, E.D. Missouri, Eastern Division

Date published: Sep 22, 2011

Case No. 4:09CV00686 ERW (E.D. Mo. Sep. 22, 2011)

Opinion

Case No. 4:09CV00686 ERW.

September 22, 2011

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

E. WEBBER JR., District Judge

This matter comes before the Court in connection with the in camera review of allegedly privileged documents related to Plaintiffs' Monsanto Company and Monsanto Technology LLC's ("Monsanto") Ninth Motion to Compel Production of Withheld Documents [ECF No. 750] and Defendants E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company and Pioneer Hi-Bred International, Inc.'s ("Defendants") Cross-Motion to Compel Production of Withheld Documents [ECF No. 767]. In this Memorandum and Order, the Court addresses Monsanto's partially privileged redacted and unredacted documents, binders 1-29; Monsanto's supplemental binder of August 4, 2011; Monsanto's supplemental binder of previously produced redacted documents; and Defendants' redacted documents, volumes 1 — 46.

I. ATTORNEY — CLIENT PRIVILEGE

One common formulation of the attorney-client privilege is that "where legal advice of any kind is sought from a professional legal advisor in his capacity as such, the communications relevant to that purpose, made in confidence by the client, are at his instance permanently protected from disclosure by himself or by the legal advisor except the protection be waived." Diversified Industries, Inc. v. Meredith, 572 F.2d 596, 602 (8th Cir. 1977) (internal quotations and citations omitted). Another formulation is: "(1) [w]here legal advice of any kind is sought (2) from a professional legal adviser in his capacity as such, (3) the communications relating to that purpose, (4) made in confidence (5) by the client, (6) are at his instance permanently protected (7) from disclosure by himself or by the legal adviser, (8) except the protection be waived." Simon v. G.D. Searle Co., 816 F.2d 397, 403 n. 7 (8th Cir. 1987) (internal quotations and citations omitted).

Under these formulations, "[a] communication is not privileged simply because it is made by or to a person who happens to be a lawyer." Diversified Industries, 572 F.2d at 602. The Eighth Circuit therefore has recognized that including an attorney in a discussion or as an addressee of a communication does not make that communication privileged:

[T]he special master stated: "A business document is not made privileged by providing a copy to counsel. . . . Thus, those documents from one corporate officer to another with a copy sent to an attorney do not qualify as attorney client communications." [citation omitted]. We perceive no error in this statement of the law. . . .

Simon, 816 F.2d at 403.¹ "Just as the minutes of business meetings attended by attorneys are not automatically privileged, business documents sent to corporate officers and employees, as well as the corporation's attorneys, do not become privileged automatically." Id. (internal citations omitted). With respect to the level of confidentiality required, the client's "intent to maintain confidentiality" can be inferred from the circumstances, and drafts of documents ultimately intended to be shared with third parties may therefore be privileged if the draft was provided in order to solicit confidential advice concerning its content. Robbins Myers, Inc. v. J.M. Huber Corp., 274 F.R.D. 63, 84-85 (W.D.N.Y. 2011).

1 The Simon court was applying Minnesota law, but the Minnesota standard for attorney-client privilege is identical to the federal standard. For that reason, Simon interchangeably cites to Minnesota and federal cases in the opinion.

Additionally, "[t]he privilege only protects [against] disclosure of communications; it does not protect [against] disclosure of the underlying facts by those who communicated with the attorney. . . ." Upjohn Co. v. United States, 449 U.S. 383, 395 (1981). As a result, attorney-client privilege does not cover client communications that "relate only business or technical data," where the client is not sharing that information in order to solicit legal advice. Simon, 816 F.2d at 403; see also Robbins Myers, 274 F.R.D. at 86 ("Even if the client's communications with an attorney are confidential, merely because an attorney is consulted by a client does not render the ensuing communications privileged if the purpose of the consultation is to obtain [services] other than legal advice or services.").

In the corporate context, there may also be some question about whether the privilege applies to a low-level employee's communications. The Eighth Circuit has held that in that situation, a communication is privileged if:

(1) the communication was made for the purpose of securing legal advice; (2) the employee making the communication did so at the direction of his corporate superior; (3) the superior made the request so that the corporation could secure legal advice; (4) the subject matter of the communication is within the scope of the employee's corporate duties; and (5) the communication is not disseminated beyond those persons who, because of the corporate structure, need to know its contents.

In re Bieter Co., 16 F.3d 929, 936 (8th Cir. 1994). This same test applies when the person making the communication is not an employee but is instead an independent contractor, such as a consultant. See id. at 937.

"[T]he party who claims the benefit of the attorney-client privilege has the burden of establishing the right to invoke its protection." Hollins v. Powell, 773 F.2d 191, 196 (8th Cir. 1985).

II. THE WORK PRODUCT DOCTRINE

The work product doctrine shelters from discovery documents and tangible things that are prepared in anticipation of litigation. Fed.R.Civ.P. 26(b)(3). This rule especially protects those document and tangible things that contain the mental impressions, "investigative endeavors," conclusions, opinions, or other legal theories of a party's attorney. In re Murphy, 560 F.2d 326, 337 (8th Cir. 1977). "The primary purpose of the work product privilege is to assure that an attorney is not inhibited in his representation of his client by the fear that his files will be open to scrutiny upon demand of an opposing party." Id. at 334. This privilege is held and may be asserted by the attorney and the client. In re Green Grand Jury Proceedings, 492 F.3d 976, 980 (8th Cir. 2007).

The Eighth Circuit has stated the following about the protections that apply to attorney work product:

There are two kinds of work product-ordinary work product and opinion work product. Ordinary work product includes raw factual information. Opinion work product includes counsel's mental impressions, conclusions, opinions or legal theories. Ordinary work product is not discoverable unless the party seeking discovery has a substantial need for the materials and the party cannot obtain the substantial equivalent of the materials by other means. In contrast, opinion work product enjoys almost absolute immunity and can be discovered only in very rare and extraordinary circumstances, such as when the material demonstrate that an attorney engaged in illegal conduct or fraud.

Baker v. Gen. Motors Corp., 209 F.3d 1051, 1054 (8th Cir. 2000) (internal citations omitted). The work product doctrine does not protect documents from discovery unless they were prepared in anticipation of litigation. Simon, 816 F.2d at 401 (8th Cir. 1987); see also Fed.R.Civ.P. 26 advisory committee's note to 1970 amendment ("Materials assembled in the ordinary course of business, or pursuant to public requirements unrelated to litigation, or for other nonlitigation purposes are not" protected from disclosure as work product.). The test for determining if documents were prepared in anticipation of litigation is "whether, in light of the nature of the document and the factual situation in the particular case, the document can fairly be said to have been prepared or obtained because of the prospect of litigation." Simon, 816 F.2d at 401 (internal citations omitted).

To a certain extent, an attorney or his or her agents must be involved in producing the work product in order for it to be protectible work product. For example, "[s]tatements and documents which represent the impressions and observations of the witnesses and not those of the attorney or his investigators, are not part of the attorney's `work product.'" Virginia Elec. Power Co. v. Sun Shipbuilding Dry Dock Co., 68 F.R.D. 397, 403 (E.D. Va. 1975). However, if these impressions and observations originate from an attorney or a discussion with an attorney, this material then comes within the work product doctrine. See Simon, 816 F.2d at 402 (holding that attorney-drafted material found within a document that was prepared in the ordinary course of business and not in anticipation for litigation was protected by the work product doctrine even if the other portions of the document were not protected).

"The work product privilege extends beyond the termination of litigation." Pamida, Inc. v. E.S. Originals, Inc., 281 F.3d 726, 731 (8th Cir. 2002). In Pamida, the court found that materials prepared in anticipation of an earlier suit between the two parties were entitled to work product protection. See id.

Work product protection may be waived. For example, intentionally disclosing the materials to an adversary may waive the protection. Gundacker v. Unisys Corp., 151 F.3d 842, 848. The work product protection remains, however, if the client passes the information generated by the attorney to a non-adversarial party. Peralta v. Cendant Corp., 190 F.R.D. 38, 42 (D. Conn. 1999); see also Ayers Oil Co. v. Am. Bus. Brokers, Inc., 2009 WL 4725297 at *3-4 (E.D. Mo. 2009) (finding privilege intact even though the client forwarded an email containing an attorney's legal advice to a non-adversarial third party). A so-called "at-issue waiver" may also occur "where the client places the subject matter of the privileged communication at issue," in that (1) "proof of a party's legal contention implicates evidence encompassed in the contents of an attorney-client communication — for example, when a client uses reliance on legal advice as a defense or when a client brings a legal malpractice action"; or (2) "a client's testimony refers to a specific privileged document." Baker, 209 F.3d at 1055.

III. DISCUSSION

After reviewing the applicable law, the Court has identified nine principal reasons why a given communication might not be protected from disclosure:

(1) the communication only concerns underlying facts, such as business or technical data, and was not shared in order to solicit legal advice;

(2) privilege was waived because the communication was disclosed to a third party;

(3) no attorney was involved in the communication and it does not reflect privileged advice from an attorney;

(4) the attorney's only involvement in the communication was as a passive recipient;

(5) the attorney's advice is not legal in nature;

(6) the communication was not made to the attorney for the purpose of obtaining legal advice;

(7) privilege does not extend to the employee who made the communication;

(8) the communication was not intended to be confidential;

(9) the document is attorney work product but the party seeking production has demonstrated that it is discoverable.

Using this rubric, the Court has created comprehensive tables that document its rulings on each produced document. The column on the far right contains the Court's conclusion: "P" (privileged), "WP" (work product), "NP" ("not privileged"), "DWP" (discoverable work product), or some combination thereof. For those documents found not to be protected, the Court also states its rationale, with reference to the list of nine reasons set forth above. Thus, if the Court determined that a document was not privileged because it only contained underlying facts and was not made in order to obtain legal advice, that column would contain "NP: 1."

The parties presented the redacted documents for review in different formats. The Court is aware of the parties' efforts in preparing and presenting the material to the Court. The "source" of the claimed privilege in Defendants' documents was easier to interpret. The source of privilege in the Court's Rulings on In Camera Review (or tables) attached to this order do not always comport with the identification stated by the parties.

The Court has reviewed many hundreds of documents in the past few weeks. Due to the scope of this in camera review, the Court recognizes that errors likely have been made in classifying individual documents. Therefore, the Court orders each party to review the attached Rulings on In Camera Review (or tables). Within ten (10) days of this order, each party may make up to twenty (20) brief requests to the Court for reexamination of specific documents determined by the Court to be "not privileged."

Any request for reexamination must be accompanied by a brief, individualized statement that explains why the party believes the judgment of "not privileged" is erroneous. Each request must also be supported by legal authority that supports the party's position.

The requests for reexamination are to be compiled in a binder and delivered to the Court. The binder should be organized as follows: a cover page identifying the document number, memorandum in support of a contrary determination, and the document in redacted and unredacted format. The parties should utilize tabs to separate each request for reexamination (tab, cover page, memorandum, document). Parties are to file on CM/ECF a one-page motion for reexamination in order for this Court action to be docketed properly. The Court will not review noncompliant requests.

After the Court conducts this reexamination, the Court shall order all documents determined to be "not privileged" in the reexamination and all other documents in the Court's Rulings on In Camera Review (or tables), which the Court has determined to be not privileged, delivered to the other party in unredacted format.

The Court is now beginning document review of up to 100 documents designated as fully privileged by each party at the request of the opposing party, which the parties have already delivered to the Court. See August 30, 2011 order [ECF No. 853]. See also ECF Nos. 872, 875.

Accordingly,

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Monsanto's Ninth Motion to Compel Production of Withheld Documents [ECF No. 750] is GRANTED in part and DENIED in part. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Defendants' Cross-Motion to Compel Production of Withheld Documents [ECF No. 767] is GRANTED in part and DENIED in part. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that within ten (10) days of this order, each party may make up to twenty (20) requests for reexamination to the Court as described above.

Binder 1 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

Note: An "x" after production number indicates an unredacted document.

^{1a 2}

1a Don Doherty is not on Attorney list, but entry shows he is with Husch Blackwell.

2 Not work product.

TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1441246 1441246-x AC 1441247-x 1441248-x 1441249-x 1441250-x 1441251-x 1441252-x 1441253-x 1441254-x 1441255-x 1441256 Bunning-Stevens, B. P 1441257-x 1441258-x 1441259-x 1441260-x 1441261-x 1441262-x 1441263-x 1441264 Bunning-Stevens, B P 1441265-x MOGAT1441266 1441266 AC NP: 1, 3 1441267 NP: 1, 3 1441268-x 1441269-x 1441270-x MOGAT1441271 1441271 AC NP: 1, 3 1441272 Hansen, Myles P 1441273 Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1441274 1441274 AC Carrato, Tom P 1441275 Carrato, Tom P 1441276-x MOGAT1441277 1441277 AC Carrato, Tom P 1441278 Woods, Jennifer P 1441279-x MOGAT1441280 1441280 AC Rands, Todd; P Degroot, Tom 1441281-x MOGAT1441282 1441282 AC NP: 1 1441283-x 1441284-x 1441285-x 1441286-x 1441287-x 1441288-x 1441289-x 1441290-x 1441291-x 1441292-x 1441293-x 1441294-x 1441295-x 1441296-x MOGAT1441297 1441297 AC Rands, Todd P 1441298-x MOGAT1441299 1441299 AC Partridge, Scott; P Hoerner, Dennis 1441300-x 1441301-x 1441302-x 1441303-x 1441304-x 1441305-x 1441306-x 1441307-x 1441308-x MOGAT1441309 1441309 AC NP: 1, 3 1441310-x MOGAT 1441311 1441311 AC NP: 1 1441312 NP: 1 MOGAT1441313 1441313 AC Carrato, Tom P 1441314 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1441315 1441315 AC Carrato, Tom P 1441316 Carrato, Tom P 1441317-x 1441318-x MOGAT1441319 1441319 AC Carrato, Tom P 1441320 Carrato, Tom P 1441321 Carrato, Tom P 1441322 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1441323 1441323 AC Carrato, Tom P 1441324-x 1441325-x MOGAT1441326 1441326-x AC 1441327 Carrato, Tom P 1441328 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1441329 1441329 AC NP: 1, 3 1441330-x MOGAT1441345 1441345 AC Mariani, Randy P 1441346-x 1441347-x 1441348-x 1441349-x MOGAT1441350 1441350 AC Mariani, Randy P 1441351 Mariani, Randy P 1441352-x 1441353-x 1441354-x 1441355-x MOGAT1441356 1441356 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott 1441357-x MOGAT1441358 1441358-x AC 1441359 Doherty, Don P 1441360 Doherty, Don P 1441361-x 1441362-x MOGAT1441363 1441363 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1441369 1441369 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1441375 1441375 AC Spears, Steven P 1441376 Spears, Steven P 1441377-x MOGAT1441379 1441379 AC Degroot, Tom P MOGAT1441381 1441381 AC Lawson, Clifford P 1441382 Lawson, Clifford P 1441383-x 1441384-x MOGAT1441385 1441385 AC Roth, Mike P MOGAT1441388 1441388 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Hansen, Myles MOGAT1441395 1441395-x AC 1441396 Carrato, Tom P 1441397-x MOGAT1441398 1441398 AC Carrato, Tom P 1441399-x 1441400-x MOGAT1441401 1441401 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1441408 1441408-x AC 1441409 Rands, Tom P 1441410-x MOGAT1441416 1441416 AC Degroot, Tom P 1441417 Degroot, Tom P 1441418 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1441419 1441419 AC Mariani, Randy P 1441420 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1441454 1441454-x AC; WP 1441455-x 1441456-x 1441457-x 1441458-x MOGAT1441459 1441459 AC; WP NP: 1 1441460 Roth, Michael P 1441461 Lawson, Clifford P 1441462-x 1441463-x MOGAT1441482 1441482 AC Carrato, Tom P 1441483-x MOGAT1441484 1441484 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles; Partridge, Scott MOGAT1441491 1441491 AC Patridge, Scott; P Hansen, Myles; Degroot, Tom; Mariani, Randy 1441492 Hansen, Myles P 1441493-x 1441494-x 1441495-x MOGAT1441496 1441496 AC; WP Partridge, Scott; P Mariani, Randy Hansen, Myles MOGAT1441498 1441498 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1441519 1441519-x AC MOGAT1441526 1441526 AC Bosch, Henry P 1441527 Bosch, Henry P 1441528-x MOGAT1441529 1441529 AC Carrato, Tom P 1441530-x MOGAT1441533 1441533 AC Carrato, Tom P 1441534 Carrato, Tom P 1441535-x 1441536-x MOGAT1441537 1441537 AC Stater, Stacey; P Carrato, Tom; Doherty, Don 1441538 Stater, Stacey; P Doherty, Don 1441539-x 1441540-x MOGAT1441550 1441550-x AC 1441551-x 1441552-x 1441553-x MOGAT1441569 1441569 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1441572 1441572 AC Hansen, Myles; P Degroot, Tom Hoerner, Dennis Stater, Stacey MOGAT1441580 1441580-x AC 1441581 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1441585 1441585 WP Hoerner, Dennis P 1441586-x MOGAT1441587 1441587 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1441588 Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1441589 1441589-x AC 1441590 Hoerner, Dennis P 1441591-x 1441592 Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1441593 1441593 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1441594-x 1441595 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1441596 1441596-x AC 1441597 Rands, Todd; P Hoerner, Dennis; Mariani, Randy 1441598 Rands, Todd; P Hoerner, Dennis; Mariani, Randy 1441599 NP: 1, 3 1441600 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1441601 1441601 AC; WP NP: 1, 3 1441602-x MOGAT1441605 1441605-x AC 1441606-x 1441607 Hoerner, Dennis P 1441608 Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1441609 1441609 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1441610 Mariani, Randy P 1441611 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1441612 1441612 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1441637 1441637-x AC 1441638 Bunning-Stevens, B. P 1441639 Bunning, Stevens, B. P MOGAT1441640 1441640-x AC 1441641 NP: 3 MOGAT1441642 1441642 AC NP: 3 1441643-x MOGAT1441644 1441644 AC Roman, Robert P 1441645-x MOGAT1441669 1441669 AC Snively, David P 1441670-x 1441671-x 1441672-x MOGAT1441673 1441673 AC Degroot, Tom P Hoerner, Dennis Roth, Mike 1441674-x 1441675-x 1441676-x MOGAT1441677 1441677 AC Degroot, Tom P Hoerner, Dennis Roth, Mike MOGAT1441681 1441681 AC Hansen, Myles P 1441682-x MOGAT1441683 1441683-x AC 1441684 Roman, Robert P 1441685 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1441686 1441686 AC Roman, Robert P 1441687-x 1441688-x MOGAT1441689 1441689 AC Hansen, Myles P 1441690 Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy 1441691-x 1441692-x MOGAT1441693 1441693-x 1441694-x 1441695-x 1441696-x 1441697-x 1441698-x MOGAT1441699 1441699-x AC 1441700 Roman, Robert P 1441701 Hansen, Myles; P Partridge, Scott MOGAT1441702 1441702-x AC 1441703 Roman, Robert P 1441704 Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1441705 1441705 AC Roman, Robert P 1441706 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1441707 1441707-x AC 1441708-x MOGAT1441719 1441719-x AC 1441720 Stater, Stacey P MOGAT1441731 1441731 AC NP: 1, 3 1441732-x MOGAT1441740 1441740-x AC 1441741 NP: 3 1441742-x

Binder 2 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents ^1b see fn 1 ^2a see fn 2 ³

1b 09/08/08 8:36 email — P (Roth, Mike).
09/01/08 9:35 email — NP: 3.

2a No redaction on document 14422170. The following Tabs are not listed on Amended Privilege Redaction Log of Challenged Entries: MOGAT1442171, MOGAT1442172 and MOGAT1442175. However, documents 1442173 and 1442174 are redacted and not listed as protected documents. The Court considered the redacted material. 1442173 — P (Snively, David; Shelton, Reuben) and 1442174 — P (Snively, David; Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis).

3 Documents for this Tab in Binders 2 and 3.

TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1441775 1441775 AC Roman, Robert P 1441776-x 1441777 Rands, Todd; P Hoerner, Dennis; Mariani, Randy; Roman, Robert 1441778 Hoerner, Dennis P 1441779-x MOGAT1441780 1441780-x AC 1441781-x 1441782 Roman, Robert P 1441783-x 1441784-x 1441785-x 1441786-x 1441787-x 1441788-x MOGAT1441806 1441806-x AC 1441807-x MOGAT1441812 1441812 AC Roman, Robert P MOGAT1441847 1441847 AC Winski, John P 1441848 Winski, John P MOGAT1442043 1442043 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Stater, Stacey; Bunning-Stevens, B.; Degroot, Tom; Hansen, Myles 1442044-x MOGAT1442068 1442068 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1442081 1442081 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Stater, Stacey; Doherty, Don 1442082-x 1442083-x MOGAT1442096 1442096-x AC 1442097-x 1442098 Chandran, Bhaskar P 1442099-x MOGAT1442100 1442100 AC Stater, Stacey P 1442101 Stater, Stacey P MOGAT1442102 1442102 AC Roth, Mike; P Hoerner, Dennis 1442103-x MOGAT1442104 1442104 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1442105 1442105 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1442106 1442106 AC Roth, Mike; P Winski, John 1442107 Roth, Mike P 1442108-x MOGAT1442109 1442109 AC Roth, Mike P 1442110 Stater, Stacey P 1442111-x 1442112-x 1442113-x MOGAT1442114 1442114 AC Stater, Stacey; P Roth, Mike 1442115 Roth, Mike; P Stater, Stacey 1442116 Stater, Stacey; P Roth, Mike; Hoerner, Dennis 1442117 Stater, Stacey; P Roth, Mike; Hoerner, Dennis 1442118 Roth, Mike; P Stater, Stacey 1442119 Stater, Stacey P 1442120-x 1442121-x MOGAT1442122 1442122x AC 1442123-x 1442124 Chandran, Bhaskar P 1442125-x MOGAT1442126 1442126 AC Roth, Mike; P Hoerner, Dennis 1442127-x 1442128 1442129-x MOGAT1442130 1442130 AC Stater, Stacey; P Hoerner, Dennis 1442131 Stater, Stacey; P Hoerner, Dennis 1442132 Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1442133 1442133 AC Stater, Stacey; P Roth, Mike 1442134 Roth, Mike; P Stater, Stacey 1442135 Stater, Stacey; P Roth, Mike; Hoerner, Dennis 1442136 Stater, Stacey; P Roth, Mike 1442137 Roth, Mike; P Stater, Stacey 1442138 Stater, Stacey P 1442139-x 1442140-x MOGAT1442141 1442141 AC Roth, Mike; P Hoerner, Dennis 1442142 Roth, Mike; P Hoerner, Dennis 1442143-x 1442144-x MOGAT1442145 1442145 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Stater, Stacey; Bunning-Stevens, B.; Degroot, Tom Hansen, Myles 1442146-x MOGAT1442170 1442170 AC MOGAT1442187 1442187 AC Hoerner, Dennis; Hansen, Myles 1442188-x MOGAT1442197 1442197 AC Snively, David; P Hansen, Myles; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis 1442198-x MOGAT1442199 1442199-x AC 1442200-x 1442201-x 1442202-x 1442203-x 1442204-x 1442205-x 1442206-x 1442207-x 1442208-x 1442209-x 1442210-x 1442211-x 1442212-x 1442213-x 1442214-x 1442215-x 1442216-x 1442217-x 1442218-x 1442219-x 1442220-x 1442221-x 1442222-x 1442223-x 1442224-x 1442225-x 1442226-x 1442227-x 1442228-x MOGAT1442229 1442229 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Carrato, Tom MOGAT1442259 1442259 AC Hansen, Myles; P Roth, Mike; Snively, David MOGAT1442265 1442265 AC Hansen, Myles P 1442266 Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1442301 1442301 AC NP: 1, 3 1442302-x 1442303-x 1442304-x MOGAT1442306 1442306 AC Partridge, Scott; P Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy 1442307-x 1442308-x 1442309-x 1442310-x 1442311-x 1442312-x 1442313-x MOGAT1442314 1442314 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1442318 1442318 AC Hoerner, Dennis; Degroot, Tom; Snively, David MOGAT1442320 1442320 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1442333 1442333 AC Roman, Robert P MOGAT1442350 1442350-x AC 1442351-x MOGAT1442358 1442358 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1442396 1442396 AC Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy 1442397-x MOGAT1442406 1442406 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles 1442407 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1442436 1442436 AC Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy; Stater, Stacey; Hansen, Myles MOGAT1442439 1442439 AC Mariani, Randy; P Martin, Chris 1442440-x MOGAT1442444 1442444 AC Roman, Robert; P Mariani, Randy; Carrato, Tom 1442445 Roman, Robert; P Mariani, Randy; Carrato, Tom 1442446 NP: 3 1442447-x MOGAT1442451 1442451 AC Duros, Karen; P Hansen, Myles MOGAT1442456 1442456 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1442459 1442459 AC Snively, David; P Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1442460-x MOGAT1442480 1442480 AC Mariani, Randy; P Duros, Karen MOGAT1442522 1442552 AC Mariani, Randy P 1442553 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1442530 1442530 AC; WP Hansen, Myles; P Hoerner, Dennis; Snively, David; Patridge, Scott 1442531-x MOGAT1442534 1442534 AC NP: 1 1442535-x MOGAT1442542 1442542 AC Mariani, Randy P 1442543 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1442558 1442558 AC Mariani, Randy P 1442559-x 1442560-x 1442561-x MOGAT1442562 1442562 AC Hansen, Myles; P Martin, Chris MOGAT1442577 1442577 AC Martin, Chris; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles; Stater, Stacey; Partridge, Scott 1442578-x

Binder 3 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1c see fn 1 ^2b TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1442594 1442594 AC Roman, Robert; P Mariani, Randy 1442595 Roman, Robert; P Stater, Stacey MOGAT1442637 1442637 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1442673 1442673 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Hansen, Myles 1442674 Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy 1442675-x MOGAT1442683 1442683 AC Mariani, Randy; P Bunning-Stevens, B.; Degroot, Tom Woods, Jennifer MOGAT1442747 1442747 AC Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy; Doherty, Don 1442748 Duros, Karen; P Doherty, Don; Hansen, Myles 1442749-x MOGAT1442756 1442756 AC Mariani, Randy; P Duros, Karen 1442757 Stater, Stacey; P Hansen, Myles; Durons, Karen MOGAT1442760 1442760 AC Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy 1442761-x MOGAT1442762 1442762 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles 1442763-x 1442764-x MOGAT1442784 1442784 AC Snively, David; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles 1442785 Snively, David P 1442786-x MOGAT1442791 1442791 AC Snively, David; P Mariani, Randy; Bunning-Stevens, B.; Degroot, Tom MOGAT1442855 1442855-x AC 1442856-x 1442857-x 1442858-x 1442859-x 1442860-x 1442861-x 1442862-x 1442863-x 1442864-x 1442865-x 1442866-x 1442867-x 1442868 1442869 NP: 1, 3 1442870-x 1442871 NP: 1, 3 1442872-x 1442873 NP: 1, 3 1442874-x 1442875-x 1442876-x 1442877-x 1442878 NP: 1, 3 1442879 NP: 1, 3 1442880-x 1442881-x 1442882 NP: 1, 3 1442883-x 1442884-x 1442885-x 1442886-x 1442887-x 1442888-x 1442889-x 1442890-x 1442891-x 1442892-x 1442893-x 1442894-x 1442895-x 1442896-x 1442897-x 1442898-x 1442899-x 1442900-x 1442901-x 1442902-x 1442903-x 1442904-x 1442905-x 1442906-x 1442907-x 1442908-x 1442909-x 1442910-x 1442911-x 1442912-x 1442913-x 1442914-x 1442915-x 1442916-x 1442917-x 1442918-x 1442919-x 1442920-x 1442921-x 1442922-x 1442923-x 1442924-x 1442925-x 1442926-x 1442927-x 1442928-x 1442929-x 1442930-x 1442931-x 1442932-x 1442933-x 1442934-x 1442935-x 1442936-x 1442937-x 1442938-x 1442939-x 1442940-x 1442941-x 1442942-x 1442943-x 1442944-x 1442945-x 1442946-x 1442947-x 1442948-x 1442949-x 1442950-x 1442951-x 1442952-x 1442953-x 1442954-x 1442955-x 1442956-x 1442957-x 1442958 NP: 1, 3 1442959-x 1442960-x 1442961-x 1442962-x 1442963-x 1442964-x 1442965-x 1442966-x 1442967-x 1442968-x 1442969-x 1442970-x 1442971-x 1442972-x 1442973-x 1442974-x 1442975-x 1442976-x 1442977-x 1442978-x 1442979-x 1442980-x 1442981-x 1442982-x 1442983-x 1442984-x 1442985-x 1442986-x 1442987-x 1442988-x 1442989-x 1442990-x 1442991-x MOGAT1442922 1442922 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1443000 1443000-x AC 1443001-x 1443002 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443003 1443003-x AC 1443004 Roth, Mike P MOGAT1443037 1443037 AC NP: 1 1443038-x 1443039-x MOGAT1443040 1443040-x AC 1443041-x 1443042-x 1443043-x 1443044-x 1443045-x 1443046-x 1443047 Snively, David P 1443048 Snively, David P MOGAT1443054 1443054 AC Partridge, Scott P 1443055-x 1443056-x 1443057-x MOGAT1443073 1443073 AC Mariani, Randy P Hansen, Myles 1443074-x 1443075-x 1443076-x MOGAT1443083 1443083 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1443122 1443122 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles 1443123-x 1443124-x 1443125-x MOGAT1443126 1443126 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles 1443127-x 1443128-x 1443129-x MOGAT1443130 1443130 AC Rands, Todd; P Shelton, Reuben; Hoerner, Dennis; Mariani, Randy 1443131-x 1443132-x 1443133-x MOGAT1443134 1443134 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443157 1443157 AC Partridge, Scott; P Hansen, Myles; Snively, David 1443158 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1443159-x MOGAT1443160 1443160 AC Partridge, Scott; P Snively, David; Hansen, Myles 1443161 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1443162 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1443163-x MOGAT1443164 1443164 AC Snively, David; P Hansen, Myles; Partridge, Scott 1443165-x 1443166-x 1443167-x 1443168-x 1443169-x 1443170 Snively, David P 1443171 Snively, David P 1443172 Snively, David P MOGAT1443173 1443173 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles 1443174-x 1443175-x 1443176-x MOGAT1443177 1443177 AC; WP Partridge, Scott P 1443178-x 1443179-x 1443180-x MOGAT1443181 1443181 AC Hansen, Myles; P Martin, Chris MOGAT1443196 1443196 AC Lavin, Larry P 1443197-x 1443198 Lavin, Larry; P Roth, Mike 1443199-x 1443200-x MOGAT1443219 1443219 AC NP: 1, 3 1443220-x MOGAT1443222 1443222 AC Duros, Karen P MOGAT1443272 1443272 AC Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy 1443273-x MOGAT1443279 1443279-x AC 1443280 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1443281 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1443282 Snively, David P 1443283-x MOGAT1443284 1443284-x AC; WP 1443285 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott Hansen, Myles 1443286-x 1443287 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1443288-x MOGAT1443289 1443289-x AC; WP 1443290-x 1443291 Snively, David P 1443292 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1443293 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1443294-x MOGAT1443295 1443295 AC Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy 1443296 Hansen, Myles P 1443297-x MOGAT1443311 1443311 AC NP: 1

Binder 4 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1d see fn 1 ^2c see fn 2 ^3a TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1443314 1443314 AC; WP Clark, Scott P 1443315 Clark, Scott P 1443316 Clark, Scott P MOGAT1443320 1443320-x AC 1443321-x 1443322 Carrato, Tom P 1443323 Carrato, Tom P 1443324 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443326 1443326 AC Carrato, Tom P 1443327-x 1443328 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443331 1443331 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1443342 1443342 AC Carrato, Tom P 1443343-x MOGAT1443357 1443357 AC Carrato, Tom P 1443358-x 1443359-x 1443360-x 1443361-x MOGAT1443364 1443364 AC Carrato, Tom; P Hoener, Dennis; Mariani, Randy 1443365 Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1443366 1443366 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles 1443367 Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles MOGAT1443368 1443368 AC Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy 1443369 Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1443370 1443370 AC; WP Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1443371 1443371 AC Myles, Hansen; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1443376 1443376 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott 1443377 NP: 1 MOGAT1443378 1443378 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott 1443379 Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1443380 1443380 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott 1443381 Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1443382 1443382 AC NP: 1 1443383-x MOGAT1443384 1443384-x AC 1443385-x 1443386 Carrato, Tom P 1443387 Carrato, Tom P 1443388 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443390 1443390 AC Carrato, Tom; P Hansen, Myles; Partridge, Scott 1443391 1443392-x 1443393-x 1443394-x MOGAT1443395 1443395 AC Carrato, Tom P 1443396 Carrato, Tom P 1443397 Carrato, Tom; P Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1443398-x 1443399-x 1443400-x 1443401-x MOGAT1443402 1443402 AC Carrato, Tom P 1443403 NP: 1 1443404 Carrato, Tom P 1443405 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443415 1443415 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1443420 1443420 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1443423 1443423 AC Carrato, Tom P 1443424 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443429 1443429 AC Carrato, Tom P 1443430-x MOGAT1443440 1443440 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443443 1443443 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1443450 1443450 AC Carrato, Tom; Stater, Stacey MOGAT1443452 1443452 AC Roth, Mike; P Degroot, Tom MOGAT1443476 1443476 AC Degroot, Tom; Hoerner, Dennis 1443477-x 1443478-x MOGAT1443497 1443497 AC Degroot, Tom; P Carrato, Tom; Hansen, Myles 1443498 NP: 1 1443499-x MOGAT1443502 1443502 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443509 1443509-x AC 1443510 Carrato, Tom P 1443511 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443529 1443529 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1443532 1443532 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443542 1443542 AC Carrato, Tom P 1443543 Carrato, Tom P 1443544-x MOGAT1443545 1443545-x AC 1443546-x 1443547-x 1443548 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1443550 1443550-x AC 1443551-x 1443552 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1443553 1443553 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1443590 1443590-x AC 1443591 Partridge, Scott; P Hansen, Myles 1443592 Partridge, Scott; P Hansen, Myles MOGAT1443595 1443595 AC Carrato, Tom P 1443596-x 1443597-x 1443598-x 1443599 NP: 3 MOGAT1443602 1443602 AC Carrato, Tom P 1443603 Carrato, Tom P 1443604-x 1443605-x 1443606-x 1443607 NP: 3 MOGAT1443608 1443608 AC Carrato, Tom P 1443609 Carrato, Tom P 1443610-x 1443611-x 1443612-x 1443613 NP: 3 MOGAT1443614 1443614 AC Carrato, Tom P 1443615-x 1443616-x 1443617-x 1443618 NP: 3 1443619 NP: 3 MOGAT1443620 1443620 AC Carrato, Tom P 1443621 Carrato, Tom P 1443622-x 1443623-x 1443624-x 1443625 NP: 3 MOGAT1443626 1443626-x AC 1443627 NP: 1 MOGAT1443665 1443665 AC NP: 1, 3 1443666 NP: 1, 3 1443667-x MOGAT1443679 1443679-x AC 1443680 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1443708 1443708 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1443718 1443718-x AC 1443719 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443722 1443722 AC Rands, Todd; Lavin, Larry; Martin, Chris; Stater, Stacey; Hansen, Myles; Snively, David; Degroot, Tom Bunning-Stevens, B.; Partridge, Scott; Woods, Jennifer 1443723 Martin, Chris; P Woods, Jennifer MOGAT1443744 1443744 AC Shelton, Reuben P 1443745 Shelton, Reuben P 1443746-x MOGAT1443757 1443757 AC Roth, Mike P MOGAT1443784 1443784 AC Snively, David; P Martin, Chris 1443785-x 1443786-x MOGAT1443787 1443787 AC Hansen, Myles P 1443788 Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1443789 1443789-x AC MOGAT1443830 1443830 AC; WP Shelton, Reuben P 1443831 NP: 1 MOGAT1443876 1443876 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy 1443877-x 1443878-x 1443879-x 1443880-x MOGAT1443881 1443881-x AC 1443882 NP: 1 MOGAT1443890 1443890 AC NP: 1

Binder 5 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1e see fn 1 ^2d see fn 2 ^3b see fn 3 ⁴ see fn 4 ⁵ see fn 5 ⁶ see fn 6 ⁷ see fn 7 ⁸ see fn 8 ⁹ see fn 9 ¹⁰ TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1443910 1443910 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1443911 Hoerner, Dennis P 1443912 Hoerner, Dennis 1443913-x 1443914-x MOGAT1443915 1443915 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1443916 Hoerner, Dennis P 1443917 Hoerner, Dennis P 1443918 1443919-x 1443920-x MOGAT1443921 1443921 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443925 1443925 AC NP: 1, 3 1443926-x MOGAT1443928 1443928 AC NP: 1 1443929-x MOGAT1443936 1443936 AC Carrato, Tom P 1443937-x MOGAT1443941 1443941-x AC 1443942 Carrato, Tom P 1443943 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443946 1443946-x AC 1443947-x 1443948 Carrato, Tom P 1443949 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1443950 1443950-x AC MOGAT1443984 1443984-x AC MOGAT1443989 1443989-x AC 1443990 Stater, Stacey P 1443991 Stater, Stacey; P Carrato, Tom 1443992 Carrato, Tom P 1443993-x MOGAT1443994 1443994 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1443998 1443998 AC MOGAT1444002 1444002-x AC; WP 1444003-x 1444004-x 1444005-x 1444006-x 1444007-x MOGAT1444025 1444025-x AC: WP 1444026 Rands, Todd P 1444027 Rands, Todd P 1444028 Rands, Todd P 1444029-x MOGAT1444047 1444047 AC Rands, Todd P 1444048-x 1444040-x 1444050 Rands, Todd P 1444051 Rands, Todd P MOGAT1444069 1444069-x AC 1444070 NP: 1 MOGAT1444101 1444101 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1444103 1444103 AC Mariani, Randy 1444104-x MOGAT1444107 1444107 AC Spears, Steven P 1444108-x 1444109-x 1444110-x MOGAT1444111 1444111 AC Knoll, Susan P MOGAT1444128 1444128 AC Degroot, Tom P MOGAT1444140 1444140 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1444141-x MOGAT1444368 1444368 AC NP: 1 1444369-x MOGAT1444402 1444402 AC Degroot, Tom; P Hoerner, Dennis 1444403-x MOGAT1444413 1444413 AC NP: 1 1444414 Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1444415 1444415 AC 1444416 Roman, Robert P 1444417 Roman, Robert P 1444418-x 1444419-x 1444420-x 1444421-x 1444422-x 1444423-x 1444424-x MOGAT1444425 1444425 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1444426 1444426 AC Duros, Karen P MOGAT1444596 1444596 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1444601 1444601-x AC 1444602 Hoerner, Dennis P 1444603-x 1444604-x 1444605-x MOGAT1444606 1444606 AC Roman, Robert P 1444607 1444608 1444609-x MOGAT1444651 1444651 AC Roman, Robert P MOGAT1444659 1444659 AC Hansen, Myles P 1444660 Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1444670 1444670 AC Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1444672 1444672 AC MOGAT1444709 1444709 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1444710-x MOGAT1444713 1444713-x AC 1444714 Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1444717 1444717 AC 1444718-x MOGAT1444723 1444723 AC Roman, Robert P MOGAT1444730 1444730 AC Hansen, Myles P 1444731 Hansen, Myles; P Roman, Robert

Binder 6 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1f TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1444752 1444752 AC Roman, Robert P 1444753-x MOGAT1444767 1444767 AC Snively, David P 1444768 Snively, David P 1444769-x MOGAT1444774 1444774 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1444777 1444777 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1444778-x MOGAT1444789 1444789-x AC 1444790 Degroot, Tom P MOGAT1444797 1444797-x AC 1444798-x 1444799-x 1444800-x 1444801-x 1444802-x 1444803-x 1444804 NP: 1 1444805-x 1444806-x 1444807-x MOGAT1444808 1444808 AC Stater, Stacey P MOGAT1444811 1444811 AC NP: 1 1444812-x 1444813-x 1444814-x 1444815-x 1444816-x 1444817 Hansen, Myles P 1444818-x MOGAT1444819 1444819 AC NP: 3 1444820 Marvin, Tom; P Stater, Stacey 1444821-x MOGAT1444822 1444822-x AC 1444823 Roman, Robert P 1444824-x MOGAT1444825 1444825 AC NP: 1 1444826-x 1444827-x MOGAT1444828 1444828 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1444832 1444832 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1444836 1444836 AC Roman, Robert P MOGAT1444839 1444839 AC NP: 3 1444840 Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1444848 1444848 AC NP: 3 1444849 NP: 3 1444850-x 1444851-x 1444852-x 1444853-x 1444854-x MOGAT1444855 1444855 AC NP: 1, 3 1444856-x MOGAT1444867 1444867 AC NP: 3 1444868-x 1444869-x 1444870-x 1444871-x 1444872-x 1444873-x MOGAT1444888 1444888 AC Li, Chunping P 1444889 Li, Chunping P 1444890-x MOGAT1444926 1444926 AC NP: 1 1444927-x 1444928-x MOGAT1444929 1444929-x AC 1444930 Roman, Robert P 1444931-x MOGAT1444932 1444932-x AC 1444933 NP: 1 1444934-x MOGAT1444937 1444937-x AC 1444938 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1444941 1444941-x AC 1444942-x 1444943 Roman, Robert P 1444944 Roman, Robert P 1444945-x MOGAT1444946 1444946-x AC 1444947 Roman, Robert P 1444948-x MOGAT1444949 1444949 AC NP: 1, 3 1444950-x MOGAT1444951 1444951 AC NP: 1, 3 1444952-x MOGAT1444953 1444953-x AC 1444954-x 1444955-x 1444956 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1444957 1444957 AC Roman, Robert P 1444958 Roman, Robert P 1444959-x 1444960-x 1444961-x MOGAT1444962 1444962 AC NP: 1 1444963-x MOGAT1444965 1444965 AC NP: 3 1444966 Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1444967 1444967-x AC 1444968 Stater, Stacey P 1444969 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1444970 Roman, Robert P 1444971 Stater, Stacey P 1444972-x 1444973-x MOGAT1444974 1444974 AC NP: 1, 3 1444975-x 1444976-x MOGAT1444996 1444996 AC Rands, Todd P MOGAT1444997 1444997-x AC 1444998 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1445009 1445009-x AC 1445010-x 1445011-x MOGAT1445111 1445111-x AC 1445112-x 1445113-x MOGAT1445213 1445213-x AC 1445214 Roman, Robert P 1445215 Mariani, Randy P 1445216-x MOGAT1445217 1445217 AC Carrato, Tom P 1445218 Carrato, Tom P 1445219 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1445224 1445224 AC NP: 1, 3 1445225-x MOGAT1445243 1445243 AC NP: 1 1445244-x 1445245-x MOGAT1445246 1445246 AC Carrato, Tom P 1445247-x 1445248-x MOGAT1445249 1445249 AC Snively, David; P Patridge, Scott 1445250 Snively, David; P Patridge, Scott 1445251 Snively, David; P Patridge, Scott 1445252 Snively, David; P Patridge, Scott 1445253 Snively, David; P Patridge, Scott MOGAT1445254 1445254-x AC 1445255 Snively, David P 1445256 Snively, David P 1445257 Snively, David P 1445258 Snively, David P MOGAT1445259 1445259-x AC 1445260 Snively, David P 1445261 Snively, David P 1445262 Snively, David P 1445263 Snively, David P MOGAT1445264 1445264 AC NP: 1 1445265 NP: 1 1445266-x MOGAT1445273 1445273 AC DeCamp, Michael P 1445274 DeCamp, Michael; P Partridge, Scott 1445275 DeCamp, Michael; P Partridge, Scott MOGAT1445276 1445276 AC; WP Snively, David P 1445277 Snively, David P MOGAT1445278 1445278 AC DeCamp, Michael P 1445279 DeCamp, Michael P MOGAT1445280 1445280 AC Stater, Stacey 1445281-x MOGAT1445284 1445284 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1445285 Carrato, Tom P 1445286 Carrato, Tom P 1445287 Carrato, Tom P 1445288 Stater, Stacey P 1445289 Carrato, Tom P 1445290 Carrato, Tom P 1445291 Carrato, Tom P 1445292 Carrato, Tom P 1445293 Carrato, Tom P 1445294 Carrato, Tom P 1445295-x 1445296-x 1445297-x 1445298-x 1445299-x 1445300 Stater, Stacey; P Hoerner, Dennis 1445301-x MOGAT1445302 1445302 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1445305 1445305 AC; WP Roth, Mike P 1445306 Roth, Mike P 1445307 Roth, Mike P 1445308-x 1445309-x MOGAT1445311 1445311 AC Rands, Todd; P Degroot, Tom 1445312-x MOGAT1445318 1445318 AC Degroot, Tom; P Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1445330 1445330 AC Degroot, Tom; P Hoerner, Dennis 1445331-x 1445332-x MOGAT1445342 1445342 AC Hansen, Myles; P Hoerner, Dennis 1445343 Hansen, Myles; P Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1445356 1445356 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1445367 1445367 AC Bunning- Stevens, B. P 1445368 Bunning- Stevens, B. P 1445369 Bunning- Stevens, B. P MOGAT1445376 1445376-x AC 1445377-x 1445378 Hoerner, Dennis; P Ball, Timothy; McBride, Thomas 1445379-x MOGAT1445380 1445380-x AC 1445381 Hansen, Myles P 1445382 Hansen, Myles P

Binder 7 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^{1g 2e} see fn 2 TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1445394 1445394 AC NP: 1, 3 1445395-x 1445396 Doherty, Don; P Hansen, Myles MOGAT1445397 1445397 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1445410 1445410 AC Carrato, Tom P 1445411 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1445418 1445418 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1445455 1445455 AC Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy 1445456 Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles 1445457-x MOGAT1445464 1445464 AC Mariani, Randy P 1445465 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1445467 1445467 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles; Martin, Chris; Partridge, Scott 1445468 Martin, Chris; P Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott MOGAT1445471 1445471 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1445487 1445487 AC NP: 1 1445488-x 1445489-x MOGAT1445499 1445499 AC Duros, Karen; P Stater, Stacey; Woods, Jennifer; Mariani, Randy 1445500-x MOGAT1445509 1445509 AC Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy 1445510 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1445541 1445541 AC Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy; Roman, Robert 1445542 Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy 1445543 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1445545 1445545 Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy; Neuschafer; Brandon 1445546 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1445577 1445577 AC Mariani, Randy; P Duros, Karen 1445578-x MOGAT1445585 1445585 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1445624 1445624 AC Hansen, Myles; P Snively, David; Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis; Stater, Stacey MOGAT1445647 1445647 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Mariani, Randy; Duros, Karen 1445648 Bunning-Stevens, B. P MOGAT1445650 1445650 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Mariani, Randy; Duros, Karen 1445651-x MOGAT1445660 1445660 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1445667 1445667-x AC; WP 1445668-x MOGAT1445677 1445677 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Snively, David; Mariani, Randy; Duros, Karen 1445678-x 1445679 thru 1445684 MOGAT1445685 1445685 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles 1445686 Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles 1445687-x 1445688-x 1445689-x 1445690-x 1445691-x 1445692-x 1445693-x 1445694-x 1445695-x MOGAT1445696 1445696 AC Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy; Nelson, John; Hansen, Myles 1445697 Degroot, Tom; P Hoerner, Dennis; Hansen, Myles; Snively, David MOGAT1445703 1445703 AC Mariani, Randy; P Partridge, Scott 1445704-x MOGAT1445706 1445706 AC Mariani, Randy P 1445707-x 1445708-x 1445709-x 1445710-x MOGAT1445711 1445711 AC Mariani, Randy; P Roman, Robert; DeCamp, Michael 1445712-x 1445713-x 1445714-x MOGAT1445717 1445717-x AC; WP MOGAT1445720 1445720 AC Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott 1445721-x MOGAT1445726 1445726 AC Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles MOGAT1445735 1445735 AC Partridge, Scott; P Mariani, Randy; DeCamp, Michael; Hoerner, Dennis 1445736 DeCamp, Michael; P Mariani, Randy 1445737-x MOGAT1445738 1445738 AC Mariani, Randy P 1445739-x 1445740-x MOGAT1445748 1445748 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis 1445749 Partridge, Scott; P Mariani, Randy Snively, David MOGAT1445766 1445766 AC Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis; Partridge, Scott MOGAT1445925 1445925 AC DeCamp, Michael; P Duros, Karen; Mariani, Randy 1445926 DeCamp, Michael; P Duros, Karen Mariani, Randy 1445927 NP: 1, 3 1445928-x MOGAT1445930 1445930 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles; Woods, Jennifer MOGAT1445950 1445950 AC Mariani, Randy P 1445951 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1445952 1445952 AC Mariani, Randy; P Duros, Karen; Woods, Jennifer MOGAT1445960 1445960 AC Partridge, Scott P 1445961-x 1445962-x MOGAT1445963 1445963 AC Mariani, Randy; P Bunning-Stevens, B. 1445964 Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Duros, Karen MOGAT1445965 1445965 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1445970 1445970 AC DeCamp, Michael; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles; Hoerner; Dennis 1445971 Hansen, Myles; P Hoerner, Dennis; Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott; DeCamp, Michael MOGAT1445973 1445973 AC Roman, Robert; P Mariani, Randy 1445974-x 1445975-x MOGAT1445976 1445976 AC Mariani, Randy; P Partridge, Scott MOGAT1445979 1445979 AC Mariani, Randy; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott; Hoerner, Dennis; Hansen, Myles 1445980 Mariani, Randy; P Partridge, Scott 1445981-x MOGAT1445982 1445982 AC Hansen, Myles; P Roman, Robert MOGAT1445986 1445986 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Roth, Mike 1445987-x 1445988 Snively, David; P Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott 1445989-x MOGAT1445990 1445990 AC; WP Partridge, Scott P 1445991 Partridge, Scott P 1445992-x MOGAT1445993 1445993 AC Mariani, Randy; P Duros, Karen 1445994-x MOGAT1445995 1445995 WP Mariani, Randy; P Partridge, Scott 1445996 Mariani, Randy P 1445997-x MOGAT1445998 1445998 AC; WP Mariani, Randy; P Martin, Chris; Hansen, Myles MOGAT1446017 1446017-x AC 1446018 Mariani, Randy; P Roman, Robert 1446019-x 1446020-x MOGAT1446021 1446021-x AC 1446022 Mariani, Randy; P Roman, Robert 1446023-x 1446024-x MOGAT1446025 1446025 AC Mariani, Randy; P Roman, Robert 1446026-x 1446027-x MOGAT1446030 1446030 AC Mariani, Randy P 1446031-x MOGAT1446032 1446032 AC Carrato, Tom P 1446033 Carrato, Tom P 1446034-x 1446035-x MOGAT1446041 1446041 AC DeCamp, Michael; P Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1446042 Mariani, Randy; P DeCamp, Michael; Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles; Roman, Robert 1446043 Randy, Mariani; P DeCamp, Michael; Partridge, Scott; Roman, Robert; Hansen, Myles 1446044-x MOGAT1446045 1446045 AC Mariani, Randy P 1446046-x MOGAT1446047 1446047-x AC 1446048-x MOGAT1446056 1446056 AC Mariani, Randy P 1446057 Mariani, Randy P 1446058-x 1446059-x 1446060 NP: 1, 3 1446061-x 1446062-x 1446063-x 1446064-x 1446065-x 1446066-x 1446067-x

Binder 8 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1446068 1446068 AC; WP Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy; Martin, Chris; Hamilton, Nancy; Lowry, Brian MOGAT1446576 1446576 AC Duros, Karen P 1446577 NP: 3 MOGAT1446583 1446583 AC Martin, Chris; P Hamilton, Nancy; Hansen, Myles; Roman, Robert; Stater, Stacey 1446584-x MOGAT1446612 1446612 AC Marvin, Thomas; P Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis 1446613 Mariani, Randy; P Marvin, Thomas MOGAT1446619 1446619 AC Snively, David P MOGAT1446620 1446620 AC Snively, David P 1446621-x 1446622-x MOGAT1446623 1446623 AC Mariani, Randy; P Martin, Chris 1446624-x 1446625-x 1446626 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1446631 1446631 AC Martin, Chris; P Hamilton, Nancy 1446632-x 1446633-x MOGAT1446634 1446634 AC Martin, Chris; P Hamilton, Nancy 1446635-x 1446636-x MOGAT1446637 1446637 AC Mariani, Randy; P Martin, Chris 1446638-x 1446639 Mariani, Randy; P Martin, Chris 1446640 MOGAT1446641 1446641 AC Martin, Chris; P Hamilton, Nancy MOGAT1446643 1446643 AC Mariani, Randy; P Martin, Chris MOGAT1446653 1446653 AC Martin, Chris; P Hamilton, Nancy MOGAT1446665 1446665 AC Mariani, Randy P 1446666 Mariani, Randy P 1446667-x MOGAT1556668 1556668 AC Stater, Stacey; P Mariani, Randy; Bunning-Stevens, B.; Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1556669 Stater, Stacey P 1556670-x 1556671-x 1556672-x MOGAT1446706 1446706 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Stater, Stacey; Mariani, Randy 1446707 Stater, Stacey; P Mariani, Randy; Bunning-Stevens, B. 1446708-x 1446709-x 1446710-x MOGAT1446734 1446734 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Stater, Stacey; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy 1446735 Stater, Stacey; P Mariani, Randy; Bunning-Stevens, B. 1446736 Stater, Stacey P 1446737-x 1446738-x 1446739-x MOGAT1446740 1446740 AC Partridge, Scott; P Mariani, Randy Bunning-Stevens, B.; Stater, Stacey 1446741 Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Stater, Stacey; Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott 1446742 Stater, Stacey; P Mariani, Randy; Bunnings-Stevens, B. 1446743 Stater, Stacey P 1446744 -x 1446745-x 1446746-x MOGAT1446747 1446747 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hamilton, Nancy; Hansen, Myles; Martin, Chris MOGAT1446833 1446833 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1446853 1446853 AC Martin, Chris; P Hansen, Myles; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy Woods, Jennifer MOGAT1446859 1446859 AC Martin, Chris; P Mariani, Randy 1446860 Lavin, Larry; P Bunning-Stevens, B.

Binder 9 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1h TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1446875 1446875 AC Stater, Stacey; P DeCamp, Michael 1446876-x MOGAT1446878 1446878 AC Mariani, Randy P 1446879 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1446881 1446881 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hamilton, Nancy MOGAT1446915 1446915-x AC

Binder 10 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^{1i 2f} TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1448249 1448249 AC Martin, Chris; P Hansen, Myles; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Woods; Jennifer MOGAT1448255 1448255 AC DeCamp, Michael; P Mariani, Randy 1448256-x MOGAT1448258 1448258 AC Sisson, Pamela P MOGAT1448283 1448283-x AC 1448284-x 1448285-x 1448286-x 1448287 McBride, Tom P 1448288-x 1448289-x 1448290-x MOGAT1448291 1448291 AC Rands, Todd P 1448292-x 1448293-x MOGAT1448487 1448487 AC Rands, Todd P 1448488-x 1448489-x MOGAT1448580 1448580-x AC 1448581-x 1448582-x 1448583-x 1448584-x 1448585 NP: 1, 3 1448586 NP: 1, 3 1448587-x 1448588-x 1448589-x 1448590-x 1448591-x 1448592-x 1448593-x 1448594-x MOGAT1448595 1448595 AC NP: 3 1448596-x MOGAT1448617 1448617-x AC 1448618-x 1448619 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1448624 1448624 AC Partridge, Scott P 1448625 Partridge, Scott P 1448626 Partridge, Scott P 1448627 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1448628 1448628 AC: WP NP: 1, 3 1448629 Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1448658 1448658 AC; WP Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy MOGAT1448662 1448662 AC Stater, Stacey P MOGAT1448664 1448664 AC Mariani, Randy; P Partridge, Scott 1448665-x 1448666-x 1448667-x 1448668-x MOGAT1448675 1448675 AC Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1448690 1448690 AC Snively, David P 1448691 Snively, David P MOGAT1448692 1448692 AC Snively, David P 1448693 Snively, David P

Binder 11 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1j see fn 1 TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1448712 1448712 AC Mariani, Randy; P Partridge, Scott MOGAT1448713 1448713 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1448743 1448743 AC Partridge, Scott; P Hansen, Myles MOGAT1448748 1448748 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles 1448749 Mariani,Randy P 1448750-x MOGAT1448754 1448754 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1448757 1448757-x AC; WP 1448758-x 1448759-x MOGAT1448767 1448767 AC Hansen, Myles P 1448768 Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1448775 1448775 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1448776 Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1448804 1448804 AC Martin, Chris P 1448805 Martin, Chris; P Mariani, Randy 1448806 Mariani, Randy P 1448807-x MOGAT1448816 1448816 AC NP: 1,3 1448817-x 1448818-x MOGAT1448819 1448819 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1448836 1448836 AC Duros, Karen P MOGAT1448839 1448839 AC Partridge, Scott; P Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy MOGAT1448844 1448844-x AC 1448845 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1448846-x MOGAT1448850 1448850 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1448851 Hansen, Myles; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott 1448852 Partridge, Scott; P Snively, David; Hansen, Myles 1448853 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1448854-x MOGAT1448855 1448855 AC; WP Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1448856 Snively, David P Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1448857 Snively, David; P Scott Partridge 1448858 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1448859 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1448860-x MOGAT1448861 1448861 AC Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy; McClain, Kyle MOGAT1448865 1448865 AC Roth, Mike P 1448866 Roth, Mike; P Mariani, Randy 1448867 Roth, Mike P MOGAT1448868 1448868-x AC 1448869-x 1448870-x 1448871 Carrato, Tom P 1448872-x MOGAT1448873 1448873 AC Carrato, Tom P 1448874-x 1448875-x 1448876-x 1448877-x MOGAT1448878 1448878-x AC 1448879 Walsh, Kevin; P Giannoni, Fernando; Bosch, Henry 1448880 Giannoni, Fernando; P Walsh, Kevin MOGAT1448881 1448881 AC Partridge, Scott P 1448882-x MOGAT1448883 1448883-x AC 1448884 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1448888 1448888 AC Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott 1448889 Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott 1448890 Partridge, Scott; P Carrato, Tom; Snively, David 1448891 Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott 1448892 Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott 1448893 Snively; David P Partridge, Scott Snively, David; 1448894 Partridge, Scott; P Snively, David 1448895 David, Snively; P Partridge, Scott 1448896 1448897 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1448898 1448898 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1448902 1448902 AC Partridge, Scott P 1448903 Partridge, Scott P 1448904 Partridge, Scott P 1448905-x MOGAT1448908 1448908 AC Partridge, Scott P 1448909-x MOGAT1448913 1448913 AC Partridge, Scott P 1448914-x 1448915-x MOGAT1448916 1448916 AC Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert; Hoerner, Dennis; Rands, Todd 1448917 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert; Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1448919 1448919 AC Hansen, Myles; P Roman, Robert 1448920 Hansen, Myles; P Roman, Robert 1448921 Hansen, Myles; P Roman, Robert 1448922 Roman, Robert P 1448923 Roman, Robert P 1448924 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1448925 1448925-x AC 1448926-x 1448927-x 1448928 NP: 1 MOGAT1448929 1448929 AC Roman, Robert P 1448930 Roman, Robert; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1448931 1448931 AC Mariani, Randy; P Rands, Todd; Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1448932 1448932-x AC 1448933 Roman, Robert P 1448934-x 1448935 Roman, Robert P 1448936-x MOGAT1448937 1448937 AC NP: 3 MOGAT1448945 1448945-x WP 1448946-x 1448947-x 1448948-x 1448949-x 1448950-x 1448951-x 1448952-x 1448953 NP: 1, 3 1448954-x 1448955-x 1448956-x MOGAT1448957 1448957 AC Hansen, Myles P 1448958-x 1448959-x 1448960-x MOGAT1448961 1448961 AC Roman, Robert P 1448962 Roman, Robert P 1448963-x 1448964-x 1448965-x MOGAT1448966 1448966 AC Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1448968 1448968 AC Hansen, Myles; P Roman, Robert 1448969 Hansen, Myles P 1448970-x MOGAT1448972 1448972 AC Roman, Robert P 1448973 Roman, Robert P 1448974 Roman, Robert P 1448975 Roman, Robert P 1448976-x MOGAT1448977 1448977 AC Roman, Robert P MOGAT1448980 1448980-x AC 1448981 Rands, Todd; P DeCamp, Michael MOGAT1448982 1448982-x AC 1448983 Rands, Todd; P DeCamp, Michael 1448984-x MOGAT1448985 1448985 AC NP: 3 1448986-x 1448987-x 1448988-x 1448989-x 1448990-x 1448991 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1449006 1449006-x AC 1449007 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1449018 1449018-x AC 1449019-x 1449020 NP: 1 1449021-x 1449022-x 1449023-x MOGAT1449025 1449025-x AC 1449026-x 1449027-x 1449028-x 1449029-x 1449030 NP: 1 MOGAT1449031 1449031 AC Roman, Robert P MOGAT1449043 1449043 AC Roman, Robert P 1449044 Roman, Robert P 1449045 Roman, Robert P 1449046 Roman, Robert P 1449047-x 1449048-x 1449049-x 1449050-x MOGAT1449052 1449052-x AC 1449053 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1449056 1449056 AC Roman, Robert P MOGAT1449084 1449084 AC Rands, Todd P MOGAT1449088 1449088-x AC 1449089 Snively, David; P Hoerner, Dennis; Mariani, Randy; Hamilton, Nancy; Woods, Jennifer MOGAT1449101 1449101 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1449114 1449114-x AC 1449115 Hansen, Myles P 1449116-x

Binder 12 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1k see fn 1 ^2g see fn 2 ^3c TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1449173 1449173 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1449176 1449176 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1449178 1449178-x AC 1449179-x 1449180 NP: 1 1449181-x MOGAT1449182 1449182-x AC 1449183 NP: 1 MOGAT1449201 1449201 AC Carrato, Tom P 1449202-x MOGAT1449206 1449206 AC Carrato, Tom P 1449207-x MOGAT1449208 1449208 AC Carrato, Tom; P Stater, Stacey; Degroot, Tom 1449209 Degroot, Tom; P Stater, Stacey; Carrato, Tom 1449210 Stater, Stacey P MOGAT1449218 1449218 AC Carrato, Tom P 1449219-x 1449220-x 1449221-x 1449222-x MOGAT1449223 1449223 AC Stater, Stacey P 1449224-x 1449225-x MOGAT1449226 1449226-x AC 1449227 Carrato, Tom P 1449228-x MOGAT1449229 1449229 AC Carrato, Tom P 1449230-x MOGAT1449231 1449231 AC Rands, Todd P MOGAT1449234 1449234 AC NP: 1 1449235 NP: 1 MOGAT1449245 1449245-x AC 1449246 Carrato, Tom; P Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1449249 1449249 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1449256 1449256-x AC 1449257 Carrato, Tom P 1449258 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1449259 1449259 AC; WP Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1449266 1449266 AC; WP Degroot, Tom P 1449267 Degroot, Tom P 1449268 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1449269 1449269 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1449273 1449273 AC; WP Partridge, Scott P 1449274 1449275-x 1449276-x MOGAT1449277 1449277-x AC 1449278-x 1449279-x 1449280 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1449282 1449282 AC Rands, Todd P MOGAT1449288 1449288 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Carrato, Tom MOGAT1449318 1449318 AC Carrato, Tom P 1449319 Carrato, Tom P 1449320-x MOGAT1449334 1449334 AC Degroot, Tom; Carrato, Tom MOGAT1449341 1449341-x AC 1449342 NP: 1 1449343-x 1449344-x 1449345-x 1449346-x MOGAT1449347 1449347 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1449348 Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1449349 1449349 AC Hamilton, Nancy P MOGAT1449353 1449353 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott MOGAT1449360 1449360 AC Li, Chunping P MOGAT1449395 1449395 AC Snively, David P MOGAT1449413 1449413 AC Carrato, Tom P 1449414-x 1449415-x MOGAT1449416 1449416 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1449420 1449420 AC Carrato, Tom P 1449421 Carrato, Tom P 1449422-x MOGAT1449423 1449423 AC Carrato, Tom P 1449424-x 1449425-x MOGAT1449431 1449431-x AC 1449432 DeCamp, Michael; P Partridge, Scott; Snively, David; Carrato, Tom 1449433 DeCamp, Michael; P Partridge, Scott; Snively, David; Carrato, Tom 1449434 DeCamp, Michael; P Partridge, Scott; Snively, David; Carrato, Tom MOGAT1449435 1449435 AC Carrato, Tom P 1449436-x MOGAT1449438 1449438 AC Carrato, Tom P 1449439-x 1449440-x MOGAT1449446 1449446 AC Carrato, Tom P 1449447-x 1449448-x MOGAT1449454 1449454-x AC MOGAT1449474 1449474 AC NP: 1 1449475 NP: 1 1449476 Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1449477 1449477-x AC 1449478-x 1449479 Carrato, Tom P 1449480-x MOGAT1449481 1449481 AC Stater, Stacey P 1449482 Stater, Stacey P 1449483 Stater, Stacey P 1449484 Stater, Stacey P MOGAT1449485 1449485 AC Hansen, Myles; P Carrato, Tom MOGAT1449488 1449488 AC Duros, Karen P MOGAT1449500 1449500 AC NP: 1 1449501-x 1449502 NP: 1 MOGAT1449503 1449503 AC NP: 1 1449504-x 1449505-x 1449506 NP: 1 MOGAT1449507 1449507 AC NP: 1 1449508 NP: 1 1449509-x 1449510-x 1449511 NP: 1 MOGAT1449512 1449512 AC NP: 1 1449513-x 1449514-x 1449515 NP: 1 1449516-x MOGAT1449517 1449517 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Roman, Robert 1449518-x 1449519-x MOGAT1449520 1449520 AC Spears, Steven; P Knoll, Susan 1449521-x 1449522-x 1449523-x 1449524-x MOGAT1449525 1449525 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1449526-x MOGAT1449534 1449534 AC DeCamp, Michael P 1449535-x 1449536-x MOGAT1449537 1449537 AC Martin, Chris; Bunning-Stevens, B.; Stater, Stacey; Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1449550 1449550 AC NP: 1 1449551-x MOGAT1449555 1449555 AC NP: 1 1449556-x 1449557-x 1449558 Snively, David; Woods, Jennifer 1449559-x 1449560-x MOGAT1449563 1449563 AC; WP Mariani, Randy P 1449564 1449565 NP: 1 1449566 NP: 1 1449567 NP: 1 1449568-x MOGAT1449569 1449569 AC Snively, David P 1449570-x 1449571-x 1449572-x 1449573-x MOGAT1449605 1449605-x AC 1449606 Roman, Robert; P DeCamp, Michael; Duros, Karen 1449607 Roman, Robert; P DeCamp, Michael; Duros, Karen 1449608-x MOGAT1449609 1449609 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1449610-x MOGAT1449611 1449611 AC Partridge, Scott P 1449612-x MOGAT1449614 1449614 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1449615 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott MOGAT1449617 1449617 AC Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1449619 1449619 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1449620 1449620 AC NP: 1 1449621-x MOGAT1449635 1449635 AC NP: 1, 3 1449636-x 1449637-x 1449638-x MOGAT1449639 1449639 AC Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy; Roman, Robert MOGAT1449646 1449646 AC Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy; Roman, Robert MOGAT1449653 1449653 AC Roman, Robert P 1449654 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1449691 1449691 AC Hansen, Myles P 1449692 Hansen, Myles P 1449693-x 1449694-x 1449695-x 1449696-x 1449697-x 1449698-x 1449699-x 1449700-x 1449701-x 1449702-x 1449703-x 1449704-x 1449705-x 1449706-x MOGAT1449707 1449707 AC Roman, Robert P MOGAT1449714 1449714 AC Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1449720 1449720-x AC 1449721 Hansen, Myles P 1449722-x

Binder 13 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1l see fn 1 ^2h see fn 2 ^3d see fn 3 ^4a TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1449754 1449754 AC Roman, Robert P 1449755 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1449784 1449784-x AC 1449785-x 1449786-x 1449787-x 1449788 Nelson, John P 1449789 Nelson, John P MOGAT1449791 1449791 AC Duros, Karen; P Boswell, Mark 1449792-x 1449793-x 1449794-x MOGAT1449795 1449795-x AC 1449796 Rands, Todd P 1449797 Rands, Todd P 1449798 Rands, Todd P 1449799-x 1449800-x 1449801-x 1449802-x 1449803-x MOGAT1449804 1449804 AC NP: 1, 3 1449805-x 1449806 Maroli, Alcides P 1449807 Maroli, Alcides P 1449808 Maroli, Alcides P MOGAT1449809 1449809 AC Carrato, Tom; P Woods, Jennifer 1449810 Woods; Jennifer; P Hoerner, Dennis 1449811 Stater, Stacey; P Woods, Jennifer; Doherty, Don 1449812-x 1449813-x 1449814-x 1449815-x MOGAT1449830 1449830 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1449831-x 1449832-x 1449833-x 1449834-x MOGAT1449835 1449835 AC Stater, Stacey P 1449836-x MOGAT1449837 1449837 NP: 1 1449838-x 1449839-x 1449840-x MOGAT1449847 1449847 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1449852 1449852 AC Mariani, Randy P 1449853-x 1449854-x 1449855-x MOGAT1449856 1449856 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1449857-x 1449858-x 1449859-x MOGAT1449860 1449860 AC Stater, Stacey P 1449861-x MOGAT1449862 1449862 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1449902 1449902 AC Hansen, Myles; P Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1449960 1449960 AC Hansen, Myles; P Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1449978 1449978 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1449979 1449979 AC; WP Snively, David; Knoll, Susan; Spears, Steven 1449980-x MOGAT1449983 1449983 AC Snively, David; P Letzler, Kenneth; Gleklen, Jonathan MOGAT1449986 1449986 AC Snively, David P 1449987-x MOGAT1449988 1449988 AC Snively, David P 1449989-x 1449990-x MOGAT1449991 1449991 AC; WP Snively, David P 1449992-x MOGAT1449993 1449993 AC Martin, Chris; P Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy; Lavin, Larry; Bunning-Stevens, B.; McClain, Kyle MOGAT1450011 1450011 AC Lavin, Larry; P Hoerner, Dennis; Olson, Byron; Martin, Chris; Davis, Nikki; Ball, Timothy; Li, Chunping 1450012 Martin, Chris; P Hansen, Myles; Stater, Stacey; Bunning-Stevens, B.; McClain, Kyle; Lavin, Larry MOGAT1450037 1450037 WP Snively, David P 1450038-x MOGAT1450058 1450058 AC Roth, Mike; P Hoerner, Dennis; Stater, Stacey 1450059 Hoerner, Dennis; P Roth, Mike; Stater, Stacey; Winski, John 1450060 Roth, Mike; P Winski, John; Hoerner, Dennis 1450061 Roth, Mike; P Winski, John; Hoerner, Dennis 1450062 Roth, Mike; P Winski, John; Hoerner, Dennis 1450063 Roth, Mike; P Winski, John; Hoerner, Dennis 1450064 Roth, Mike; P Winski, John; Hoerner, Dennis 1450065 Roth, Mike; P Winski, John; Hoerner, Dennis; Stater, Stacey 1450066 Roth, Mike P Winski, John; Hoerner, Dennis; 1450067 Winski, John; P Hoerner, Dennis; Roth, Mike P 1450068 Hoerner, Dennis; Roth, Mike; Winski, John 1450069 Roth, Mike; P Winski, John; Stater, Stacey 1450070 Winski, John; P Roth, Mike; Hoerner, Dennis; Stater, Stacey 145071 Roth, Mike P 145072 Roth, Mike; P Winski, John 145073 Roth, Mike; P Winski, John 145074 Roth, Mike P MOGAT1450077 1450077 AC Carrato, Tom; P Shelton, Reuben 1450078 Carrato, Tom P Shelton, Reuben 1450079-x MOGAT1450080 1450080 AC Carrato, Tom; P Shelton, Reuben 1450081-x 1450082-x MOGAT1450083 1450083 AC; WP 1450084-x MOGAT1450109 1450109 AC; WP 1450110 MOGAT1450135 1450135 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1450136 Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1450137 1450137 AC Letzler, Kenneth P MOGAT1450149 1450149-x AC 1450150 DeCamp, Mike P MOGAT1450160 1450160 AC Hansen, Myles; P Hoerner, Dennis 1450161-x 1450162-x MOGAT1450167 1450167 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1450170 1450170 AC Hansen, Myles; P Partridge, Scott 1450171 Hansen, Myles; P Partridge, Scott MOGAT1450172 1450172 AC; WP Partridge, Scott P

Binder 14 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1m TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1450415 1450415 AC Partridge, Scott P 1450416-x 1450417-x MOGAT1450419 1450419 AC; WP Mariani, Randy; P; WP Snively, David 1450420 Mariani, Randy; P; WP Snively, David MOGAT1450435 1450435 AC; WP Snively, David P; WP MOGAT1450438 1450438 AC Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy; Hamilton, Nancy; Hoerner, Dennis; Carrato, Tom 1450439 Mariani, Randy; P Hamilton, Nancy; Hansen, Myles; Hoerner, Dennis 1450440-x MOGAT1450444 1450444 AC DeCamp, Michael; P Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1450447 1450447 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles; Partridge, Scott; McClain, Kyle 1450448-x 1450449-x MOGAT1450455 1450455 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1450456 1450456 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles; Partridge, Scott; Hoerner, Dennis; McClain, Dennis 1450457-x 1450458-x MOGAT1450459 1450459 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis; Roman, Robert 1450460 Rands, Todd; P Hoerner, Dennis 1450461 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1450468 1450468 AC Mariani, Randy P 1450469 Mariani, Randy P 1450470 Mariani, Randy P 1450471 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1450472 1450472 AC Mariani, Randy P 1450473 Mariani, Randy P 1450474 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1450475 1450475 AC Mariani, Randy P 1450476 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1450477 1450477 AC Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles; Rands, Todd 1450478-x MOGAT1450480 1450480 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Duros, Karen; Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles 1450481 Mariani, Randy; P Bunning-Stevens, B.; Stater, Stacey 1450482-x MOGAT1450483 1450483 AC Mariani, Randy; P Ugarte, Mike; Woods, Jennifer 1450484-x 1450485-x MOGAT1450487 1450487 AC Duros, Karen P 1450488-x 1450489-x 1450490-x 1450491-x MOGAT1450492 1450492 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1450499 1450499 AC Mariani, Randy; P Stater, Stacey 1450500-x 1450501-x 1450502-x 1450503-x MOGAT1450504 1450504-x AC 1450505 Mariani, Randy; P Stater, Stacey 1450506-x 1450507-x 1450508-x 1450509-x MOGAT1450510 1450510 AC DeCamp, Michael; P Hoerner, Dennis; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles 1450511 DeCamp, Michael; P Hoerner, Dennis Hansen, Myles 1450512-x MOGAT1450513 1450513 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1450552 1450552 AC Martin, Chis; P Hansen, Myles; McClain, Kyle; Lavin, Larry MOGAT1450569 1450569 AC Mariani, Randy P 1450570 Martin, Chris; P Mariani, Randy 1450571 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1450576 1450576 AC Mariani, Randy; P Duros, Karen; Stater, Stacey MOGAT1450595 1450595 AC Carrato, Tom P 1450596 Carrato, Tom P 1450597-x 1450598-x MOGAT1450601 1450601 AC Martin, Chris; P Hamilton, Nancy; Mariani, Randy; Lowry, Brian; Hansen, Myles 1450602-x MOGAT1450685 1450685 AC Hamilton, Nancy; P Snively, David; Lowry, Brian; Stater, Stacey; Lavin, Larry; Mariani, Randy; Bunning-Stevens, B.; Partridge, Scott; McClain, Kyle 1450686-x MOGAT1450726 1450726 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles; Stater, Stacey MOGAT1450768 1450768 AC Mariani, Randy P 1450769 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1450777 1450777 AC Mariani, Randy; P Bunning-Stevens, B. MOGAT1450785 1450785 AC Mariani, Randy P 1450786-x 1450787-x 1450788-x 1450789-x 1450790-x MOGAT1450793 1450793 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy 1450794 Hoerner, Dennis P Mariani, Randy 1450795-x MOGAT1450799 1450799 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles; Hoerner, Dennis; McClain, Kyle 1450800-x 1450801-x MOGAT1450805 1450805 AC Mariani, Randy; P Carrato, Tom; Partridge, Scott 1450806 Carrato, Tom; P Partridge, Scott MOGAT1450807 1450807 AC Hamilton, Nancy; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis; Hansen, Myles; Martin, Chris 1450808-x MOGAT1450855 1450855 AC Mariani, Randy; P Martin, Chris; Stater, Stacey 1450856-x 1450857-x 1450858-x 1450859-x MOGAT1450860 1450860 AC DeCamp, Michael; P Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy MOGAT1450863 1450863 AC DeCamp, Michael P MOGAT1450868 1450868 AC Hamilton, Nancy; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1450875 1450875 AC Mariani, Randy P 1450876 NP: 1, 3 1450877 NP: 1, 3 1450878-x 1450879-x 1450880-x MOGAT1450881 1450881 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1450882 1450882 AC Mariani, Randy P 1450883 NP: 1, 3 1450884-x 1450885-x 1450886-x 1450887-x MOGAT1450888 1450888 AC Mariani, Randy P 1450889-x 1450890-x 1450891-x MOGAT1450892 1450892 AC Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles Ugarte, Mike MOGAT1450897 1450897 AC Woods, Jennifer; P Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles

Binder 15 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^{1n 2i} TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1450930 1450930 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hamilton, Randy; Martin, Chris; Hansen, Myles MOGAT1450970 1450970 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1451026 1451026 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1451056 1451056 AC Woods, Jennifer P 1451057 Woods, Jennifer; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy MOGAT1451081 1451081 AC Duros, Karen; P Stater, Stacey 1451082 Duros, Karen; P Stater, Stacey; Woods, Jennifer 1451083 NP: 3 MOGAT1451096 1451096 AC; WP Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1451123 1451123 AC Partridge, Scott; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1451132 1451132 AC Mariani, Randy P 1451133 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1451146 1451146 AC Mariani, Randy; P Martin, Chris 1451147 Martin, Chris P 1451148-x 1451149-x MOGAT1451150 1451150 AC Mariani, Randy P 1451151 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1451152 1451152 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1451169 1451169 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hamilton, Nancy MOGAT1451375 1451375 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1451403 1451403 AC Martin, Chris; P Hansen, Myles; Lavin, Larry; Bunning-Stevens, B.; Stater, Stacey; McClain, Kyle 1451404 Martin, Chris; P Snively, David 1451405-x 1451406-x 1451407-x 1451408-x 1451409-x MOGAT1451414 1451414 AC Mariani, Randy

Binder 16 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^{1o 2j} see fn 2 ^3e TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1451487 1451487 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles; Duros, Karen; Rands, Todd 1451488-x MOGAT1451495 1451495 AC Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles; Rands, Todd; Bunning-Stevens, B. 1451496-x MOGAT1451498 1451498 AC Snively, David; P Hansen, Myles 1451499-x 1451500-x MOGAT1451501 1451501 AC Hansen, Myles; P Snively, David; Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott; Degroot, Tom; Ugarte, Mike 1451502 Snively, David; P Hamilton, Nancy 1451503-x Woods, Jennifer MOGAT1451504 1451504 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1451507 1451507 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hamilton, Nancy MOGAT1451513 1451513 AC Duros, Karen; P Carrato, Tom; Bunning-Stevens, B.; Hansen, Myles 1451514-x MOGAT1451517 1451517 AC Stater, Stacey; P Hansen, Myles; Duros, Karen; Mariani, Randy MOGAT1451520 1451520 AC Mariani, Randy; P Duros, Karen; Bunning-Stevens, B.; Stater, Stacey 1451521-x MOGAT1451522 1451522 AC Mariani, Randy; P Duros, Karen 1451523-x MOGAT1451534 1451534 AC Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1451537 1451537 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1451557 1451557 AC Mariani, Randy P 1451558-x MOGAT1451569 1451569 AC Woods, Jennifer; P Hamilton, Nancy; Hansen, Myles; Stater, Stacey; Bunning-Stevens, B.; Lavin, Larry; Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott 1451570-x MOGAT1451584 1451584 AC Duros, Karen; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles; Rands, Todd 1451585-x MOGAT1451587 1451587 AC Carrato, Tom P 1451588 Mariani, Randy P 1451589 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1451590 1451590 AC Rands, Todd P 1451591 Rands, Todd P 1451592 Rands, Todd P 1451593 Rands, Todd P MOGAT1451608 1451608 AC Rands, Todd P 1451609-x MOGAT1451612 1451612 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1451639 1451639-x AC 1451640 Woods, Jennifer P P MOGAT1451663 1451663 AC Lavin, Larry P 1451664 NP: 1 1451665-x 1451666-x 1451667-x 1451668-x 1451669-x 1451670-x 1451671-x 1451672-x 1451673-x MOGAT1451674 1451674 AC Bosch, Henry; Partridge, Scott; Rands, Todd; Shelton; Reuben; Snively, David 1451675 Bosch, Henry; P Partridge, Scott; Rands, Todd; Shelton; Reuben; Snively, David 1451676 Bosch, Henry; P Partridge, Scott; Rands, Todd; Shelton; Reuben; Snively, David MOGAT1451721 1451721 AC Bosch, Henry; P Rands, Todd 1451722-x MOGAT1451723 1451723 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles 1451724-x 1451725-x 1451726-x MOGAT1451727 1451727 AC Shelton, Reuben; P Snively, David; Hansen, Myles; Partridge, Scott 1451728-x 1451729-x MOGAT1451730 1451730 AC Partridge, Scott; P DeCamp, Michael; Hansen, Myles; Snively, David 1451731-x 1451732-x 1451733-x 1451734-x 1451735-x 1451736-x MOGAT1451737 1451737 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; DeCamp, Michael; Hansen, Myles 1451738-x 1451739-x 1451740-x 1451741-x 1451742-x 1451743-x MOGAT1451744 1451744 AC NP: 1 1451745-x MOGAT1451746 1451746-x AC 1451747 NP: 1, 3 1451748-x 1451749-x MOGAT1451750 1451750 AC Lavin, Larry P 1451751 Lavin, Larry P MOGAT1451757 1451757-x AC 1451758 NP: 1, 3 1451759-x MOGAT1451762 1451762 AC Coates, Evelyn P MOGAT1451785 1451785 AC Macek, Gary P MOGAT1451800 1451800-x AC 1451801 Hansen, Myles; P Carrato, Tom; Bunning-Stevens, B. 1451802-x MOGAT1451808 1451808 AC Hansen, Myles P 1451809-x 1451810 Hansen, Myles P 1451811-x MOGAT1451812 1451812-x AC 1451813-x 1451814 Partridge, Scott; P Snively, David 1451815-x MOGAT1451816 1451816 AC; WP NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1451821 1451821-x AC 1451822 Partridge, Scott P 1451823-x MOGAT1451824 1451824-x AC 1451825-x 1451826 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1451827 1451827-x AC 1451828-x 1451829 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1451830 1451830-x AC 1451831 Snively, David P 1451832 Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David 1451833 Snively, David; P Carrato, Tom MOGAT1451834 1451834 AC DeCamp, Michael P 1451835-x 1451836-x 1451837-x MOGAT1451840 1451840 AC Carrato, Tom P 1451841 Carrato, Tom P 1451842 Carrato, Tom P 1451843 Carrato, Tom P 1451844-x MOGAT1451845 1451845 AC Carrato, Tom P 1451846 Carrato, Tom P 1451847 Carrato, Tom P 1451848 Carrato, Tom P 1451849 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1451850 1451850 AC Carrato, Tom P 1451851 Carrato, Tom P 1451852 Carrato, Tom P 1451853 Carrato, Tom P 1451854-x MOGAT1451855 1451855-x AC 1451856 1451857-x 1451858-x 1451859-x MOGAT1451860 1451860-x AC 1451861-x 1451862-x 1451863-x MOGAT1451867 1451867 AC Roman, Robert P 1451868-x 1451869-x MOGAT1451870 1451870 AC Hansen, Myles; P DeCamp, Michael MOGAT1451883 1451883 AC Roman, Robert P 1451884 Roman, Robert P 1451885 Roman, Robert P 1451886 Roman, Robert P 1451887-x 1451888-x 1451889-x 1451890-x 1451891-x MOGAT1451893 1451893-x AC 1451894 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1451900 1451900-x AC 1451901 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1451902 1451902 AC Roman, Robert P MOGAT1451909 1451909 AC Hansen, Myles; P Ugarte, Mike; Doros, Karen; Roman, Robert; Mariani, Randy 1451910 Hansen, Myles; P Ugarte, Mike; Doros, Karen; Roman, Robert; Mariani, Randy MOGAT1451913 1451913 AC Bunning-Stevens, B. P 1451914 Bunning, Stevens, B. P MOGAT1451923 1451923-x AC 1451924 Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1451925 1451925 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis 1451926-x MOGAT1451928 1451928 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1451932 1451932 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1451933 Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1451948 1451948 AC Slater, Stacey P MOGAT1451968 1451968 AC Carrato, Tom; P Doherty, Don; Stater, Stacey 1451969 Carrato, Tom; P Stater, Stacey; Doherty, Don 1451970 Doherty, Don; P Stater, Stacey 1451971 Stater, Stacey; P Doherty, Don 1451972 Stater, Stacey P 1451973 Stater, Stacey P 1451974-x 1451975 Stater, Stacey P 1451976 Doherty, Don; P Stater, Stacey 1451977 Stater, Stacey P 1451978 Doherty, Don P 1451979-x 1451980-x 1451981-x 1451982-x 1451983-x 1451984-x MOGAT1451985 1451985 AC Rands, Todd P 1451986-x MOGAT1451994 1451994 AC Woods, Jennifer; P Carrato, Tom; Mariani, Randy 1451995 Woods, Jennifer; P Carrato, Tom 1451996 Mariani, Randy; P Tom Carrato 1451997 Mariani, Randy P 1451998 Mariani, Randy P 1451999 Mariani, Randy P 1452000 Mariani, Randy P 1452001 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1452006 1452006 AC Carrato, Tom P 1452007-x 1452008-x 1452009-x 1452010 NP: 1 MOGAT1452011 1452011-x AC 1452012-x MOGAT1455013 1455013 AC Carrato, Tom P 1455014 Carrato, Tom P 1455015-x MOGAT1452016 1452016 AC; WP Carrato, Tom P 1452017-x 1452018-x MOGAT1452021 1452021 AC Partridge, Scott; P Carrato, Tom; Mariani, Randy; Roth, Mike 1452022-x 1452023-x MOGAT1452024 1452024-x AC; WP MOGAT1452030 1452030 AC Carrato, Tom P 1452031-x 1452032-x 1452033-x MOGAT1452035 1452035 AC Carrato, Tom P 1452036-x

Binder 17 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^{1p 2k} TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1452050 1452050 AC Carrato, Tom P 1452051 Carrato, Tom P 1452052 Carrato, Tom P 1452053 Carrato, Tom P 1452054 Carrato, Tom P 1452055 Carrato, Tom P 1452056-x 1452057-x 1452058-x 1452059-x 1452060-x 1452061-x 1452062-x 1452063 Carrato, Tom P 1452064-x MOGAT1452065 1452065 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1452069 1452069 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1452070-x MOGAT1452080 1452080 AC Roth, Mike P MOGAT1452081 1452081 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1452085 1452085 AC; WP McClain, Kyle; P Partridge, Scott; Snively, David; Hoerner, David; Hansen, Myles 1452086-x MOGAT1452087 1452087 AC; WP McClain, Kyle; P Partridge, Scott 1452088 Partridge, Scott; P McClain, Kyle; Snively, David; Hoerner, Dennis; Hansen, Myles MOGAT1452090 1452090 AC; WP McClain, Kyle P 1452091 McClain, Kyle; P Partridge, Scott; Snively, David; Hoerner, David Hansen, Myles 1452092-x 1452093-x MOGAT1452094 1452094 AC Olsen, Byron; P Hoerner, Dennis 1452095 Olsen, Byron; P Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1452096 1452096-x AC 1452097-x 1452098 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1452099 1452099-x AC 1452100 Carrato, Tom P 1452101 Carrato, Tom P 1452102-x 1452103-x MOGAT1452104 1452104-x AC 1452105-x MOGAT1452110 1452110 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1452113 1452113 AC NP: 1 1452114-x MOGAT1452115 1452115-x AC 1452116 Carrato, Tom P 1452117 Carrato, Tom P 1452118 NP: 1, 3 1452119 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1452120 1452120 AC NP: 1, 3 1452121 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1452122 1452122 AC Rands, Todd P 1452123 Rands, Todd P 1452124 Rands, Todd P MOGAT1452167 1452167 AC; WP NP: 3 MOGAT1452217 1452217 AC; WP Spears, Steven P 1452218 Spears, Steven P 1452219 Spears, Steven P 1452220-x MOGAT1452221 1452221 AC NP: 1, 3 1452222-x 1452223-x 1452224-x 1452225-x MOGAT1452229 1452229-x AC 1452230 Hamilton, Nancy; P Martin, Chris; Snively, David 1452231-x 1452232-x MOGAT1452235 1452235 AC Hamilton, Nancy; P Martin, Chris; Snively, David MOGAT1452246 1452246 AC Martin, Chris; P Snively, David 1452247-x 1452248-x 1452249-x 1452250-x 1452251-x 1452252-x 1452253-x 1452254-x 1452255-x 1452256-x 1452257-x 1452258-x MOGAT1452263 1452263 AC Snively, David P 1452264 Snively, David P MOGAT1452269 1452269 AC Snively, David P 1452270-x 1452271-x 1452272-x MOGAT1452273 1452273-x AC 1452274-x 1452275 Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David 1452276-x 1452277 Carrato, Tom; P Stater, Stacey 1452278-x MOGAT1452279 1452279 AC Snively, David P Hamilton, Nancy; Woods, Jennifer; Hansen, Myles MOGAT1452318 1452318 AC Snively, David; P Hamilton, Nancy; Woods, Jennifer 1452319-x 1452320-x MOGAT1452324 1452324 AC Martin, Chris; P Hansen, Myles; Bunning-Stevens, B.; Stater, Stacey; Lavin, Larry; McClain, Kyle; Partridge, Scott; Hamilton, Nancy Mariani, Randy; Lowry, Brian MOGAT1452368 1452368 AC Snively, David; P Hamilton, Nancy; Martin, Chris 1452369-x MOGAT1452380 1452380 AC Hamilton, Nancy; P Snively, David; Woods, Jennifer 1452381-x 1452382-x 1452383-x 1452384-x 1452385-x 1452386-x 1452387-x 1452388-x 1452389-x 1452390-x 1452391-x 1452392-x 1452393-x 1452394-x 1452395-x 1452396-x 1452397-x 1452398-x 1452399-x 1452400-x 1452401-x 1452402-x 1452403-x 1452404-x 1452405-x 1452406-x 1452407-x 1452408-x 1452409-x MOGAT1452410 1452410 AC; WP Snively, David P MOGAT1452411 1452411 AC NP: 1, 3 1452412-x MOGAT1452418 1452418-x AC 1452419 Partridge, Scott; P Snively, David 1452420 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1452421-x MOGAT1452422 1452422 AC Hamilton, Nancy P MOGAT1452432 1452432-x AC 1452433 Li, Chunping P 1452434-x MOGAT1452435 1452435-x AC 1452436-x 1452437-x MOGAT1452445 1452445-x AC 1452446-x 1452447 NP: 1 MOGAT1452450 1452450 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis 1452451 Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1452452 1452452 AC Snively, David P MOGAT1452453 1452453 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles; Degroot, Tom; Shelton, Reuben; Hoerner, Dennis 1452454 Gleklen, Jonathan; P Weiner, Robert; Hansen, Myles 1452455-x 1452456-x 1452457-x MOGAT1452458 1452458 AC Snively, David P MOGAT1452459 1452459 AC Woods, Jennifer P MOGAT1452477 1452477 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1452495 1452495 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1452502 1452502 AC DeCamp, Michael; P Hamilton, Nancy; Partridge, Scott 1452503-x 1452504-x 1452505-x 1452506-x 1452507-x MOGAT1452508 1452508 AC Snively, David P 1452509-x MOGAT1452510 1452510-x AC; WP MOGAT1452514 1452514 AC; WP Stater, Stacey; P DeCamp, Michael; Mariani, Randy; Snively, David 1452515 Stater, Stacey; P DeCamp, Michael; Mariani, Randy; Snively, David MOGAT1452523 1452523 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles; Partridge, Scott MOGAT1452530 1452530 AC Snively, David; P Woods, Jennifer; Hamilton, Nancy 1452531-x MOGAT1452534 1452534-x AC MOGAT1452542 1452542-x AC MOGAT1452575 1452575 AC NP: 1, 3 1452576-x 1452577 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1452678 1452578-x AC 1452579-x 1452580-x

Binder 18 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1q see fn 1 see fn 1 ^2l see fn 2 ^3f see fn 3 ^4b see fn 4 ^5a see fn 5 ^6a TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1452683 1452683 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1452784 1452784-x AC 1452785-x 1452786-x 1452787-x 1452788-x 1452789-x 1452790-x 1452791 NP: 1 1452792-x 1452793-x 1452794-x 1452795-x 1452796-x 1452797-x 1452798-x 1452799-x 1452800-x 1452801-x 1452802-x 1452803-x 1452804-x 1452805 NP: 1 1452806-x 1452807-x 1452808-x 1452809-x 1452810-x MOGAT1452811 1452811-x AC MOGAT1452833 1452833 AC; WP NP: 1 MOGAT1452837 1452837 AC; WP NP: 1 MOGAT1452839 1452839 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1452849 1452849 AC Hamilton, Nancy P MOGAT1452857 1452857 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1452863 1452863 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1452867 1452867 AC Woods, Jennifer P MOGAT1452873 1452873 AC Hamilton, Nancy P MOGAT1452881 1452881-x AC 1452882 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1452883 1452883-x AC 1452884-x 1452885-x MOGAT1452886 1452886 AC Mariani, Randy P 1452887-x MOGAT1452898 1452898-x AC 1452899 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1452900 1452900 AC NP: 1 1452901 NP: 1 MOGAT1452913 1452913 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1452933 1452933 AC Bonner, Grace P MOGAT1452958 1452958 AC DeCamp, Michael P 1452959-x 1452960-x MOGAT1452961 1452961 AC Mariani, Randy P 1452962-x MOGAT1452973 1452973-x AC 1452974-x 1452975-x 1452976-x 1452977-x 1452978-x 1452979-x 1452980-x 1452981-x 1452982-x 1452983-x 1452984-x 1452985-x 1452986-x 1452987-x 1452988-x 1452989-x 1452990-x 1452991-x 1452992-x 1452993-x 1452994-x 1452995-x 1452996-x 1452997-x 1452998-x 1452999-x 1453000-x 1453001-x 1453002-x 1453003-x 1453004-x 1453005-x 1453006-x 1453007-x 1453008-x 1453009-x 1453010-x 1453011-x 1453012 NP: 1 1453013-x 1453014-x 1453015-x 1453016-x 1453017-x 1453018-x MOGAT1453019 1453019 AC NP: 1 1453020 1453021-x 1453022-x 1453023-x MOGAT1453024 1453024 AC NP: 1 1453025-x 1453026-x 1453027-x 1453028-x 1453029-x MOGAT1453030 1453030 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1453056 1453056 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453057 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1453062 1453062 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1453085 1453085 AC NP: 1 1453086-x 1453087 Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1453088 1453088-x AC 1453089 Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1453090 1453090 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453091 Carrato, Tom P 1453092 1453093-x 1453094 Carrato, Tom P 1453095-x MOGAT1453096 1453096 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453097 Carrato, Tom P 1453098 NP: 1 1453099 NP: 1 1453100 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1453101 1453101-x AC 1453102 Carrato, Tom P 1453103 Carrato, Tom P 1453104-x 1453105-x 1453106 1453107 Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott; Hoerner, Dennis; Mariani, Randy MOGAT1453108 1453108 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453109-x 1453110-x 1453111-x 1453112 Carrato, Tom P 1453113 Carrato, Tom P 1453114 Carrato, Tom P 1453115 NP: 1 1453116 1453117 Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1453118 1453118 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1453122 1453122 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1453123-x MOGAT1453127 1453127 AC NP: 1 1453128 NP: 1 1453129-x 1453130-x 1453131-x 1453132-x 1453133-x MOGAT1453134 1453134-x AC 1453135 NP: 1, 3 1453136 NP: 1, 3 1453137-x 1453138-x 1453139-x 1453140-x MOGAT1453141 1453141 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453142 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1453143 1453143-x AC 1453144-x 1453145 NP: 1, 3 1453146 Carrato, Tom P 1453147-x MOGAT1453149 1453149-x AC 1453150-x 1453151-x 1453152 1453153 MOGAT1453155 1453155 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453156 Carrato, Tom P 1453157 Carrato, Tom P 1453158-x 1453159 Carrato, Tom P 1453160-x MOGAT1453167 1453167-x AC 1453168 Carrato, Tom P 1453169-x MOGAT1453172 1453172 AC NP: 1 1453173-x 1453174 Carrato, Tom P 1453175-x MOGAT1453200 1453200-x AC MOGAT1453242 1453242-x AC 1453243 DeCamp, Michael P 1453244 DeCamp, Michael; P Partridge, Scott; Snively, David; Carrato, Tom 1453245 DeCamp, Michael; P Partridge, Scott; Snively, David; Carrato, Tom MOGAT1453246 1453246 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453247 Carrato, Tom P 1453248 Carrato, Tom P 1453249-x MOGAT1453250 1453250 AC Stater, Stacey; P Doherty, Don 1453251 Stater, Stacey; P Doherty, Don; Carrato, Tom 1453252 Stater, Stacey P 1453253 Doherty, Don P 1453254-x MOGAT1453255 1453255 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453256 Carrato, Tom P 1453257 Carrato, Tom P 1453258-x MOGAT1453273 1453273 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1453323 1453323 AC NP: 1, 3

Binder 19 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1r see fn 1 ^2m TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1453373 1453373 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453374 Carrato, Tom P 1453375 Carrato, Tom P 1453376-x MOGAT1453380 1453380-x AC 1453381 Carrato, Tom P 1453382-x 1453383 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1453384 1453384-x AC 1453385 Carrato, Tom P 1453386-x 1453387 Carrato, Tom P 1453388-x MOGAT1453389 1453389 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453390-x MOGAT1453392 1453392-x AC 1453393 Carrato, Tom P 1453394-x 1453395-x 1453396-x MOGAT1453397 1453397 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453398 Carrato, Tom P 1453399 Carrato, Tom P 1453400 Carrato, Tom P 1453401 Carrato, Tom P 1453402 Carrato, Tom P 1453403 Carrato, Tom P 1453404 Carrato, Tom P 1453405-x MOGAT1453412 1453412 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1453441 1453441 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453442 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1453507 1453507-x AC 1453508 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1453511 1453511-x AC 1453512 Carrato, Tom P 1453513 Carrato, Tom P 1453514 Carrato, Tom MOGAT1453539 1453539 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1453545 1453545 AC Carrato, Tom; P Roth, Mike 1453546-x MOGAT1453566 1453566 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453567-x MOGAT1453613 1453613 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453614-x MOGAT1453618 1453618 AC NP: 1 1453619-x 1453620-x MOGAT1453641 1453641 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1453642 NP: 1 1453643-x MOGAT1453644 1453644 AC NP: 1 1453645-x MOGAT1453646 1453646 AC Stater, Stacey P 1453647-x MOGAT1453648 1453648 AC Maroli, Alcides P 1453649-x MOGAT1453650 1453650-x AC 1453651 Lowry, Brian P 1453652-x MOGAT1453657 1453657 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Maroli, Alcides 1453658 Hoerner, Dennis P Maroli, Alcides 1453659 Maroli, Alcides P 1453660-x MOGAT1453661 1453661-x AC 1453662-x 1453663-x 1453664-x 1453665-x 1453666-x 1453667-x 1453668-x 1453669-x 1453670-x 1453671-x MOGAT1453672 1453672 AC Stater, Stacey; P Walsh, Kevin 1453673 Stater, Stacey; P Chandran, Bhaskar; Walsh, Kevin 1453674 Stater, Stacey P 1453675 Stater, Stacey P MOGAT1453685 1453685 AC 1453686 NP: 1 1453687 NP: 1 1453688-x 1453689-x 1453690-x MOGAT1453691 1453691-x AC 1453692 NP: 1 1453693-x 1453694-x MOGAT1453697 1453697 AC Stater, Stacey P 1453698 Stater, Stacey; P Chandran, Bhaskar; Walsh, Kevin 1453699 Stater, Stacey; P Chandran, Bhaskar; Walsh, Kevin 1453700 Stater, Stacey P MOGAT1453710 1453710-x AC 1453711 Stater, Stacey P 1453712 Stater, Stacey P 1453713-x 1453714-x MOGAT1453715 1453715 AC Stater, Stacey; P Partridge, Scott 1453716 Stater, Stacey P 1453717-x MOGAT1453718 1453718 AC NP: 1 1453719 NP: 1 1453720-x 1453721-x 1453722-x MOGAT1453723 1453723 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453724-x 1453725-x MOGAT1453728 1453728 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453729-x 1453730-x MOGAT1453733 1453733 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453734-x 1453735-x MOGAT1453736 1453736-x AC 1453737 Carrato, Tom P 1453738-x MOGAT1453741 1453741 AC Carrato, Tom P 1453742 NP: 1 1453743-x MOGAT1453744 1453744 AC Stater, Stacey; P Walsh, Kevin 1453745 Stater, Stacey; P Walsh, Kevin; Chandran, Bhaskar 1453746 Stater, Stacey; P Walsh, Kevin; Chandran, Bhaskar 1453747 Stater, Stacey P MOGAT1453757 1453757 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1453758 1453758-x AC 1453759 NP: 1 MOGAT1453764 1453764-x AC 1453765-x 1453766-x 1453767-x 1453768-x 1453769-x 1453770-x 1453771-x 1453772-x 1453773-x 1453774-x 1453775-x 1453776-x 1453777-x 1453778-x 1453779-x 1453780-x 1453781-x 1453782-x 1453783-x 1453784-x 1453785-x 1453786-x 1453787-x 1453788-x 1453789-x 1453790-x 1453791-x 1453792-x 1453793-x 1453794-x 1453795-x 1453796-x 1453797-x 1453798-x 1453799-x 1453800-x 1453801-x 1453802-x MOGAT1453803 1453803 AC Baucum, Scott P 1453804 Baucum, Scott P 1453805-x 1453806-x 1453807-x 1453808-x MOGAT1453830 1453830 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1453833 1453833-x AC 1453834 Stater, Stacey P MOGAT1453835 1453835 AC Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1453864 1453864 AC Baucum, Scott; P Stater, Stacey P 1453865 Baucum, Scott; Stater, Stacey 1453866-x 1453867-x MOGAT1453868 1453868-x AC 1453869 Hoerner, Dennis P 1453870-x MOGAT1453871 1453871-x AC MOGAT1453901 1453901 AC NP: 1 1453902 NP:1 MOGAT1453914 1453914 AC NP: 1 1453915-x MOGAT1453919 1453919 AC NP: 1 1453920-x MOGAT1453936 1453936 AC NP: 1 1453937 NP:1 MOGAT1453947 1453947 AC Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1453962 1453962 AC NP: 1 1453963-x 1453964-x

Binder 20 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1s TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1453973 1453973 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1453992 1453992 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1454017 1454017 AC Rands, Todd P MOGAT1454036 1454036 AC Roman, Robert P MOGAT1454038 1454038 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1454052 1454052 AC Rands, Todd P 1454053 Rands, Todd MOGAT1454054 1454054 AC Roman, Robert; P Hoerner, Dennis; Rands, Todd; Stater, Stacey MOGAT1454057 1454057 AC Roman, Robert; P Hoerner, Dennis; Rands, Todd 1454058 Roman, Robert; P Hoerner, Dennis; Rands, Todd MOGAT1454067 1454067-x AC 1454068 NP:1 1454069 NP:1 MOGAT1454070 1454070 AC NP: 3 MOGAT1454096 1454096-x AC 1454097-x 1454098 DeCamp, Michael P 1454099 Rands, Todd; P DeCamp, Michael; Partridge, Scott MOGAT1454100 1454100 AC Rands, Todd P 1454101-x MOGAT1454117 1454117 AC Roman, Robert P MOGAT1454120 1454120 AC NP: 1 1454121-x 1454122-x MOGAT1454123 1454123 AC Rands, Todd P 1454124-x 1454125-x MOGAT1454126 1454126 AC Hansen, Myles; P Rands, Todd; Roman, Robert; Hoerner, Dennis Letzler, Kenneth; Gleklen, Jonathan 1454127 Hansen, Myles; P Rands, Todd; Roman, Robert MOGAT1454128 1454128 AC Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert; Hoerner, Dennis; Rands, Todd 1454129-x MOGAT1454138 1454138 AC Hansen, Myles P 1454139-x 1454140-x MOGAT1454159 1454159 AC Rands, Todd P 1454160-x MOGAT1454163 1454163 AC Rands, Todd P 1454164 Rands, Todd P 1454165 Rands, Todd P 1454166-x MOGAT1454167 1454167 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1454170 1454170 AC; WP McClain, Kyle P MOGAT1454584 1454584 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1454592 1454592 AC Hamilton, Nancy P MOGAT1454601 1454601 AC Knoll, Susan P 1454602 Knoll, Susan P 1454603-x MOGAT1454604 1454604-x AC; WP 1454605 Knoll, Susan P 1454606-x MOGAT1454607 1454607 AC Knoll, Susan P 1454608-x MOGAT1454609 1454609-x AC 1454610 Knoll, Susan P MOGAT1454611 1454611 AC Snively, David P MOGAT1454614 1454614 AC Knoll, Susan P 1454615-x 1454616-x MOGAT1454617 1454617-x AC 1454618 NP:1 1454619-x MOGAT1454620 1454620-x AC MOGAT1454621 1454621-x AC 1454622 Li, Chunping; P Roth, Mike 1454623 Li, Chunping; P Roth, Mike MOGAT1454624 1454624 AC Snively, David P 1454625 Snively, David; P McClain, Kyle; Partridge, Scott; Letzler, Kenneth; Gleklen, Jonathan; Stargard, Andreas 1454626-x 1454627-x MOGAT1454628 1454628 AC NP: 1 1454629-x 1454630-x 1454631 NP: 1 MOGAT1454632 1454632-x AC MOGAT1454635 1454635 AC NP: 1

Binder 21 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1t see fn 1 ²ⁿ see fn 2 ^3g see fn 3 ^4c see fn 4 TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1454646 1454646 AC Snively, David; P Hamilton, Nancy 1454647-x MOGAT1454648 1454648 AC Partridge, Scott; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles 1454649-x 1454650-x MOGAT1454661 1454661 AC Hansen, Myles; P Hoerner, Dennis 1454662 Hansen, Myles; P Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1454670 1454670 AC Hansen, Myles; P Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1454706 1454706 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy 1454707-x MOGAT1454710 1454710-x AC 1454711 NP: 1 MOGAT1454722 1454722-x AC 1454723-x MOGAT1454852 1454852 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1454853-x MOGAT1454857 1454857 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1454858-x 1454859-x 1454860-x 1454861-x 1454862-x 1454863-x MOGAT1454864 1454864-x AC 1454865 NP: 1, 3 1454866-x 1454867-x 1454868 Hoerner, Dennis; P Carrato, Tom 1454869-x 1454870-x MOGAT1454877 1454877 AC NP: 1, 3 1454878-x MOGAT1454880 1454880 AC Roman, Robert P 1454881-x MOGAT1454889 1454889-x AC 1454890-x MOGAT1454919 1454919 AC Rands, Todd P 1454920 Rands, Todd P MOGAT1454925 1454925 AC Hamilton, Nancy; P Snively, David 1454926 Hamilton, Nancy; P Snively, David MOGAT1454927 1454927 AC; WP Partridge, Scott; P Snively, David 1454928-x 1454929-x 1454930-x MOGAT1454931 1454931 AC; WP Partridge, Scott; P Snively, David 1454932-x 1454933-x 1454934-x MOGAT1454935 1454935 AC Partridge, Scott; P Snively, David; Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1454936 1454936-x AC; WP 1454937 Partridge, Scott; P Hansen, Myles 1454938 Snively, David P 1454939-x MOGAT1454940 1454940 AC Roman, Robert P 1454941-x MOGAT1454942 1454942 AC Rands, Todd P 1454943 Rands, Todd; P Roman, Robert 1454944-x 1454945-x MOGAT1454946 1454946-x AC 1454947-x 1454948 Roman, Robert P 1454949-x MOGAT1454950 1454950 AC Stater, Stacey P 1454951-x 1454952 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1454953 Roman, Robert; P Stater, Stacey 1454954 Roman, Robert; P Stater, Stacey 1454955 1454956-x MOGAT1454957 1454957 AC NP: 1 1454958 NP: 1 1454959-x 1454960-x MOGAT1454960 1454960-x AC 1454961-x 1454962 Roman, Robert P 1454963-x MOGAT1454964 1454964 AC Roman, Robert P 1454965-x MOGAT1454995 1454995-x AC MOGAT1455010 1455010 AC NP: 1 1455011 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1455012 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1455013 Roman, Robert; P Stater, Stacey 1455014 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1455015-x 1455016-x MOGAT1455017 1455017 AC Stater, Stacey P 1455018-x 1455019 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1455020 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1455021 Roman, Robert; Stater, Stacey P 1455022 1455023-x MOGAT1455024 1455024 AC Roman, Robert P 1455025 NP: 1 1455026-x MOGAT1455027 1455027 AC NP: 1 1455028 NP: 1 1455029-x MOGAT1455030 1455030 AC NP: 1 1455031 NP: 1 1455032-x MOGAT1455033 1455033 AC Stater, Stacey P 1455034 Stater, Stacey P 1455035-x 1455036 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1455037 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1455038 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1455039 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1455040 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert MOGAT1455041 1455041 AC Hansen, Myles; P Roman, Robert 1455042 Mariani, Randy P 1455043-x 1455044-x MOGAT1455045 1455045 AC NP: 1 1455046 1455047 NP: 1 MOGAT1455050 1455050 AC Roman, Robert; P Hansen, Myles; Duros, Karen 1455051 Mariani, Randy P 1455052-x MOGAT1455053 1455053 AC Roman, Robert P 1455054 Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles 1455055-x 1455056-x MOGAT1455063 1455063-x AC 1455064-x 1455065 NP:1 1455066-x MOGAT1455067 1455067 AC Roman, Robert P 1455068-x MOGAT1455069 1455069-x AC 1455070-x 1455071 Roman, Robert; P Bunning-Stevens, B. 1455072 Roman, Robert P 1455073 Roman, Robert P 1455074 Roman, Robert P 1455075 Roman, Robert P 1455076-x P 1455077-x MOGAT1455078 1455078 AC ? MOGAT1455084 1455084-x AC 1455085 Nelson, John P 1455086-x 1455087-x MOGAT1455088 1455088 AC 1455089 NP:1 1455090 Roman, Robert P MOGAT1455092 1455092 AC NP: 1, 3 1455093-x MOGAT1455094 1455094 AC Hansen, Myles P 1455095-x MOGAT1455127 1455127 AC Baucum, Scott P MOGAT1455137 1455137 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1455166 1455166 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1455174 1455174 AC Roman, Robert P 1455175-x MOGAT1455185 1455185 AC NP: 1 1455186-x MOGAT1455214 1455214 AC Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1455239 1455239 AC NP: 1 1455240-x MOGAT1455245 1455245 AC Hansen, Myles P 1455246 Hansen, Myles P 1455247-x MOGAT1455250 1455250 AC NP: 1 1455251-x MOGAT1455256 1455256 AC Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1455281 1455281 AC NP: 1

Binder 22 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1u see fn 1 ^{2o 3h} see fn 3 ^4d see fn 4 ^5b see fn 5 ^6b see fn 6 ^7a see fn 7 TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1455295 1455295-x AC; WP 1455296-x MOGAT1455300 1455300-x AC 1455301 Hansen, Myles; Roman, Robert MOGAT1455304 1455304 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1455331 1455331 AC NP: 1, 3 1455332-x MOGAT1455333 1455333 AC Roman, Robert P MOGAT1455358 1455358-x AC 1455359 NP:1 MOGAT1455366 1455366 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1455400 1455400-x AC MOGAT1455436 1455436-x AC 1455437 Rands, Todd P MOGAT1455442 1455442-x AC MOGAT1455452 1455452 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis; Rands, Todd; Degroot, Tom; Snively, David; Woods, Jennifer 1455453-x MOGAT1455454 1455454 AC Carrato, Tom P 1455455 Carrato, Tom P 1455456 Carrato, Tom P 1455457-x MOGAT1455464 1455464 AC Snively, David; P Hamilton, Nancy MOGAT1455567 1455567 AC Carrato, Tom P 1455568-x MOGAT1455569 1455569 AC Carrato, Tom P 1455570 Carrato, Tom P 1455571 Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1455572 Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1455573 Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1455574 Carrato, Tom; P Partridge, Scott; Snively, David 1455575 Carrato, Tom P 1455576 Carrato, Tom; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott 1455577 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1455578 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1455579 1455580-x MOGAT1455581 1455581 AC Partridge, Scott P 1455582 Partridge, Scott; P Carrato, Tom 1455583-x MOGAT1455584 1455584 AC NP: 1 1455585-x 1455586-x MOGAT1455607 1455607 AC Maroli, Alcides P 1455608-x MOGAT1455609 1455609-x AC 1455610 DeCamp, Michael; P Partridge, Scott 1455611 DeCamp, Michael; P Partridge, Scott MOGAT1455612 1455612-x AC 1455613 NP: 1 1455614-x 1455615-x 1455616-x MOGAT1455617 1455617-x AC 1455618 NP: 1 1455619-x 1455620-x 1455621-x MOGAT1455622 1455622 AC Carrato, Tom P 1455623-x 1455624-x MOGAT1455629 1455629 AC Carrato, Tom P 1455630-x MOGAT1455643 1455643 AC Stater, Stacey P 1455644 Stater, Stacey P MOGAT1455645 1455645 AC Maroli, Alcides P 1455646 Maroli, Alcides P 1455647 Maroli, Alcides P 1455648 Maroli, Alcides P 1455649 Maroli, Alcides P MOGAT1455650 1455650 AC Carrato, Tom P 1455651 Carrato, Tom P 1455652 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1455653 1455653 AC Stater, Stacey P 1455654 Stater, Stacey P 1455655-x 1455656 NP: 1, 3 1455657-x 1455658-x MOGAT1455659 1455659 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1455660-x MOGAT1455661 1455661 AC Rands, Todd; P Hoerner, Dennis; Spears, Steven 1455662 Rands, Todd; P Hoerner, Dennis; Spears, Steven 1455663 Hoerner, Dennis P 1455664-x 1455665-x MOGAT1455666 1455666 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Spears, Steven 1455667 Spears, Steven; P Hoerner, Dennis; Rands, Todd 1455668 Hoerner, Dennis P 1455669-x 1455670-x MOGAT1455671 1455671 AC Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1455680 1455680 AC NP: 1 1455681-x 1455682-x MOGAT1455683 1455683 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Stater, Stacey 1455684 1455685 NP: 1, 3 1455686 1455687-x 1455688-x MOGAT1455689 1455689 AC 1455690 NP: 1 1455691 NP: 1, 3 1455692 NP: 1, 3 1455693-x MOGAT1455694 1455694 AC Rands, Todd; P Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1455750 1455750 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Snively, David; Hansen, Myles; Lavin, Larry; Hamilton, Nancy MOGAT1455754 1455754 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Lavin, Larry; Martin, Chris 1455755 Hoerner, Dennis; P Lavin, Larry; Martin, Chris MOGAT1455762 1455762 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1455765 1455765 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Roth, Michael; McBride, Thomas; Kelly, Thomas; Lavin Larry; Lowry, Brian 1455766-x 1455767-x 1455768-x MOGAT1455769 1455769 AC 1455770 1455771 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1455788 1455788 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Martin, Chris; Stater, Stacey; Lavin, Larry; Hansen, Myles; McClain, Kyle; Partridge, Scott 1455789 Hoerner, Dennis; P Martin, Chris; Stater, Stacey; Lavin, Larry; Hansen, Myles; McClain, Kyle; Partridge, Scott MOGAT1455794 1455794 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Hoerner, Dennis; Hansen, Myles; McClain, Kyle 1455795-x MOGAT1455796 1455796 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis 1455797-x MOGAT1455802 1455802 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1455806 1455806 AC Degroot, Tom; P Hansen, Myles 1455807 Degroot, Tom; P Hansen, Myles MOGAT1455823 1455823 AC Rands, Todd P MOGAT1455827 1455827 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1455829 1455829-x AC MOGAT1455840 1455840 AC Hansen, Myles; Hoerner, Dennis 1455841-x MOGAT1455844 1455844-x AC 1455845-x 1455846-x 1455847 Rands, Todd P 1455848-x 1455849-x 1455850-x 1455851-x 1455852-x 1455853-x 1455854-x 1455855-x 1455856-x 1455857-x 1455858-x 1455859-x 1455860-x 1455861 NP: 1, 3 1455862-x 1455863-x 1455864-x 1455865-x 1455866 NP: 1, 3 1455867-x 1455868-x 1455869-x 1455870 NP: 1, 3 1455871 NP: 1, 3 1455872 NP: 1, 3 1455873 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1455874 1455874 AC DeCamp, Michael; P Snively, David 1455875 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; DeCamp, Michael; Hoerner, Dennis; Hansen, Myles; McClain, Kyle 1455876 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; DeCamp, Michael; Hoerner, Dennis; Hansen, Myles; McClain, Kyle 1455877-x 1455878-x MOGAT1455879 1455879 AC Rands, Todd; P Mariani, Randy 1455880-x 1455881-x MOGAT1455897 1455897 AC Rands, Todd; P Mariani, Randy 1455898 Rands, Todd; P Mariani, Randy 1455899-x 1455900-x 1455901-x MOGAT1455902 1455902 AC Partridge, Scott; P Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis; DeCamp, Michael 1455903-x 1455904-x 1455905-x 1455906-x 1455907-x 1455908-x

Binder 23 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1455909 1455909-x AC 1455910 DeCamp, Michael; P Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis 1455911-x MOGAT1456028 1456028 AC Hansen, Myles; P Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1456243 1456243 AC; WP Partridge, Scott; P Snively, David MOGAT1456244 1456244 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis 1456245 Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1456257 1456257 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1456370 1456370 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1456434 1456434 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy 1456435-x MOGAT1456497 1456497 AC DeCamp, Michael P MOGAT1456517 1456517 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1456681 1456681 AC Mariani, Randy P 1456682 Mariani, Randy P 1456683 Mariani, Randy P 1456684-x 1456685-x MOGAT1456686 1456686 AC Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1456689 1456689 AC Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1456692 1456692 AC Mariani, Randy; P Partridge, Scott 1456693-x MOGAT1456696 1456696 AC DeCamp; Michael; P Mariani, Randy; Roman, Robert 1456697 Partridge, Scott; P Roman, Robert 1456698 Partridge, Scott; P Roman, Robert MOGAT1456700 1456700 AC; WP Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1456701 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1456702-x 1456703-x 1456704-x 1456705-x 1456706-x 1456707-x 1456708-x 1456709-x 1456710-x 1456711-x 1456712-x MOGAT1456734 1456734 AC; WP Mariani, Randy 1456735-x 1456736-x 1456737-x 1456738-x MOGAT1456739 1456739 WP Mariani, Randy P 1456740 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1456741 1456741-x AC; WP MOGAT1456756 1456756 AC; WP Mariani, Randy P 1456757 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1456758 1456758 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Snively, David 1456759-x MOGAT1456760 1456760 AC; WP Hoerner, Dennis P 1456761 Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1456762 1456762 AC Mariani, Randy P 1456763 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1456764 1456764 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1456765 1456765 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1456769 1456769-x AC MOGAT1456773 1456773 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis 1456774-x 1456775-x 1456776-x 1456777-x MOGAT1456778 1456778 AC; WP Mariani, Randy WP 1456779-x

Binder 24 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1v see fn 1 ^2p see fn 2 ³ⁱ see fn 3 ^4e TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1456792 1456792-x AC MOGAT1456803 1456803 AC Carrato, Tom P 1456804-x MOGAT1456807 1456807 AC Carrato, Tom P 1456808 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1456809 1456809 AC NP: 1 1456810 NP: 1 MOGAT1456811 1456811 AC NP: 1 1456812-x MOGAT1456813 1456813 AC Stater, Stacey P 1456814 Hoerner, Dennis P 1456815 Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1456816 1456816 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1456817 Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1456818 1456818-x AC 1456819 Hoerner, Dennis P 1456820-x MOGAT1456821 1456821 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Roman, Robert; Hoerner, Dennis 1456822 Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Roman, Robert 1456823 Roman, Robert P 1456824-x MOGAT1456830 1456830 AC McClain, Kyle P 1456831-x 1456832-x MOGAT1456833 1456833 AC Hansen, Myles P 1456834-x MOGAT1456835 1456835 AC NP: 1 1456836 NP: 1 MOGAT1456841 1456841 AC NP: 1 1456842-x MOGAT1456849 1456849 AC; WP NP: 1, 3 1456850 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1456854 1456854 AC NP: 1, 3 1456855 NP: 1, 3 1456856-x 1456857 NP: 1 MOGAT1456858 1456858 AC Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1456862 1456862 AC Roman, Robert P MOGAT1456874 1456874 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1456887 1456887 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1456925 1456925 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1456930 1456930 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1456937 1456937 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1456947 1456947 AC Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy; Lavin, Larry 1456948 Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy; Lavin, Larry MOGAT1456959 1456959 AC Hoerner, Dennis P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1456961 1456961 AC 1456962 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1456966 1456966 AC Carrato, Tom P 1456967 Carrato, Tom P 1456968-x 1456969-x MOGAT1456972 1456972 AC Partridge, Scott; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles 1456973-x MOGAT1456984 1456984 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1456985 Hoerner, Dennis P 1456986-x MOGAT1456987 1456987 AC Partridge, Scott; P Snively, David; Mariani, Randy 1456988-x MOGAT1456989 1456989 AC Duros, Karen; P Lowry, Brian; Hamilton, Nancy; Zucker, Martin; Duncan; Melissa; Rands, Todd; Walsh, Kevin Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis; Partridge, Scott; Snively, David 1456990-x 1456991-x MOGAT1456992 1456992 AC 1456993-x 1456994-x MOGAT1457006 1457006 AC Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy; Duros, Karen; Roman, Robert MOGAT1457010 1457010 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1457013 1457013-x AC 1457014-x 1457015-x 1457016-x 1457017-x 1457018-x 1457019-x 1457020-x 1457021-x 1457022-x 1457023-x 1457024 NP: 1, 3 1457025 NP: 1 1457026-x 1457027 NP: 1, 3 1457028-x 1457029-x 1457030-x 1457031-x 1457032-x 1457033-x 1457034-x 1457035-x 1457036-x 1457037-x 1457038-x 1457039-x 1457040-x 1457041-x MOGAT1457042 1457042 AC Carrato, Tom; P Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy 1457043 Maroli, Alcides P MOGAT1457044 1457044 AC Martin, Chris; P Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy; Partridge, Scott MOGAT1457528 1457528 AC Mariani, Randy P 1457529 Mariani, Randy; P Partridge, Scott 1457530 Mariani, Randy P 1457531-x MOGAT1457532 1457532 AC Martin, Chris; P Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles

Binder 25 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1w TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1458039 1458039 AC Snively, David P MOGAT1458066 1458066 AC Mariani, Randy; P Snively, David MOGAT1458093 1458093 AC Stater, Stacey; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1458103 1458103 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1458173 1458173 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1458194 1458194 AC Carrato, Tom P Stater, Stacey MOGAT1458227 1458227 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Stater, Stacey; Mariani, Randy 1458228-x 1458229-x MOGAT1458230 1458230 AC Mariani, Randy P 1458231 Mariani, Randy P 1458232 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1458257 1458257 AC Mariani, Randy; P Roman, Robert; Rands, Todd; Hoerner, Dennis 1458258 Rands, Todd; P Hoerner, Dennis 1458259-x MOGAT1458260 1458260 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles MOGAT1458281 1458281 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles MOGAT1458302 1458302 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1458320 1458320 AC Stater, Stacey; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1458323 1458323 AC Woods, Jennifer; P Mariani, Randy 1458324 Mariani, Randy; P Hamilton, Nancy; Woods, Jennifer 1458325 Hoerner, Dennis; P Lowry, Brian MOGAT1458326 1458326 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis; Woods, Jennifer; Hamiltoin, Nancy MOGAT1458383 1458383 AC Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy; Duros, Karen; Rands, Todd; Hoerner, Dennis; Snively, David 1458384-x 1458385-x MOGAT1458386 1458386 AC Roman, Robert; P Hanse, Myles MOGAT1458483 1458483 AC Mariani, Randy P 1458484 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1458515 1458515 AC; WP Li, Chunping; P Hoerner, Dennis; Mariani, Randy

Binder 26 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1458524 1458524 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy; McClain, Kyle 1458525-x 1458526-x MOGAT1458534 1458534 AC Mariani, Randy; P Partridge, Scott; Hansen, Myles 1458535 Mariani, Randy; P Partridge, Scott; Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1458539 1458539 AC Woods, Jennifer; P Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis; Stater, Stacey Bunning-Stevens, B.; Lavin, Larry 1458540-x 1458541-x 1458542-x 1458543-x 1458544-x 1458545-x 1458546-x 1458547-x 1458548-x 1458549-x 1458550-x 1458551-x 1458552-x 1458553-x 1458554-x 1458555-x 1458556-x 1458557-x 1458558-x 1458559-x 1458560-x 1458561-x 1458562-x 1458563-x 1458564-x 1458565-x 1458566-x 1458567-x 1458568-x 1458569-x 1458570-x 1458571-x 1458572-x MOGAT1458600 1458600 AC McClain, Kyle; P Hansen, Myles; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Conran, Joe; Gutzler, Gregg; Hoerner, Dennis 1458601 McClain, Kyle; P Hansen, Myles; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Conran, Joe; Gutzler, Gregg; Hoerner, Dennis 1458602-x MOGAT1458603 1458603 AC Woods, Jennifer; P Lavin, Larry; Stater, Stacey; McClain, Kyle; Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy; Duncan, Melissa MOGAT1458645 1458645 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis 1458646-x 1458647-x 1458648-x 1458649-x 1458650-x MOGAT1458658 1458658 AC Woods, Jennifer; P Duncan, Melissa MOGAT1458700 1458700 AC Rovira, Gonzalo P 1458701 Rovira, Gonzalo P 1458702 Rands, Todd; P Rovira, Gonzalo; Partridge, Scott 1458703-x P 1458704 Rands, Todd; Rovira Gonzalo 1458705-x MOGAT1458706 1458706 AC DeCamp, Michael; P Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis 1458707 DeCamp, Michael; P Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1458708 1458708 AC Mariani, Randy 1458709-x MOGAT1458710 1458710 AC Mariani, Randy 1458711-x 1458712-x 1458713-x 1458714-x 1458715-x 1458716-x 1458717-x 1458718-x 1458719-x MOGAT1458720 1458720 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Snively, David 1458721-x MOGAT1458730 1458730 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Snively, David 1458731 Bunning-Stevens. B.; P Snively, David 1458732 Bunning-Stevens, B. P 1458733-x MOGAT1458742 1458742 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles; Duros, Karen MOGAT1458767 1458767 AC Snively, David; P Hansen, Myles; Partridge, Scott; Shelton, Reuben; Mariani, Randy MOGAT1458787 1458787 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1458821 1458821 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis; Hansen, Myles 1458822 Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles; Stater, Stacey; Lavin, Larry; Degroot, Tom MOGAT1458823 1458823 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1458841 1458841 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Woods, Jennifer 1458842 Woods, Jennifer P MOGAT1458864 1458864 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Mariani, Randy 1458865 Bunning-Stevens, B. P MOGAT1458867 1458867 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Snively, David 1458868 Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Snively, David 1458869-x 1458870-x MOGAT1458871 1458871 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1458885 1458885 AC Duros, Karen P 1458886 Duros, Karen P 1458887-x MOGAT1458890 1458890 AC Snively, David; P Hoerner, Dennis; Mariani, Randy; Hamilton, Nancy; Woods, Jennifer MOGAT1458902 1458902 AC Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy MOGAT1458914 1458914 AC Hamilton, Nancy; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles; Degroot, Tom; Woods, Jennifer MOGAT1458923 1458923 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1458961 1458961 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1459066 1459066 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles MOGAT1459133 1459133 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1459168 1459168 AC Mariani, Randy; P Woods, Jennifer 1459169 Woods, Jennifer; P Lavein, Larry 1459170 Roth, Michael; P Lavin, Larry 1459171 Lavin, Larry P 1459172-x 1459173-x MOGAT1459174 1459174 AC Mariani, Randy P 1459175 MOGAT1459178 1459178 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1459215 1459215 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy; Lowry, Brian 1459216-x MOGAT1459318 1459318 AC Hamilton, Nancy; P Martin, Chris; Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy 1459319-x 1459320-x MOGAT1459321 1459321 AC Mariani, Randy; P Martin, Chris; Hamilton, Nancy; Hansen, Myles 1459322-x 1459323-x MOGAT1459324 1459324 AC Martin, Chris; P Mariani, Randy 1459325-x 1459326 Martin, Chris P 1459327-x

Binder 27 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^{1x 2q} TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1459328 1459328 AC Martin, Chris P 1459329 Martin, Chris P 1459330 Martin, Chris P 1459331-x 1459332-x MOGAT1459333 1459333 AC Martin, Chris; P Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy; Stater, Stacey; McClain, Kyle; Lavin, Larry; Hamilton, Nancy MOGAT1459343 1459343 AC Martin, Chris; P Hamilton, Nancy; Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy MOGAT1459355 1459355 AC Martin, Chris; P Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy; Stater, Stacey; Bunning-Stevens, B.; Snively, David 1459356-x 1459357-x 1459358-x 1459359-x 1459360-x 1459361-x 1459362-x MOGAT1459368 1459368 AC Mariani, Randy; P Martin, Chris 1459369-x 1459370-x 1459371 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1459376 1459376 AC Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles; Martin, Chris 1459377 Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1459406 1459406 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1459417 1459417 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1459438 1459438 AC Hamilton, Nancy; P Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles; Avioli, Nancy M. MOGAT1459458 1459458 AC Snively, David; P DeCamp, Michael; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Hoerner, Dennis 1459459 Snively, David; P DeCamp, Michael; Partridge, Scott 1459460 DeCamp, Michael; P Snively, David; Partridge, Scott 1459461-x MOGAT1459462 1459462 AC Martin, Chris; P Hamilton, Nancy; Mariani, Randy; Hansen, Myles; Stater, Stacey; Lavin, Larry 1459463-x MOGAT1459479 1459479 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles; Martin, Chris; Ugarte, Mike MOGAT1459490 1459490 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles; Martin, Chris 1459491-x 1459492-x 1459493 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1459498 1459498 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles; Woods, Jennifer; Ugarte, Mike MOGAT1459531 1459531 AC Mariani, Randy P 1459532-x 1459533-x MOGAT1459553 1459553 AC Woods, Jennifer; P Mariani, Randy; Ugarte, Mike; Hamilton, Nancy; Partridge, Scott 1459554-x MOGAT1459575 1459575 AC Mariani, Randy; P Duros, Karen MOGAT1459587 1459587 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles; Woods, Jennifer; Duros, Karen MOGAT1459598 1459598 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1459608 1459608 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles; Woods, Jennifer MOGAT1459615 1459615 AC Mariani, Randy P MOGAT1459637 1459637 AC Snively, David; P 1459638-x Hansen, Myles; Shelton, Reuben MOGAT1459648 1459648 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Roth, Mike 1459649 Snively, David P 1459650 Snively, David P 1459651-x MOGAT1459652 1459652 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Bunning-Stevens, B. 1459653 Snively, David P 1459654 Snively, David P 1459655-x MOGAT1459656 1459656 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Roth, Mike; Bunning-Stevens, B. 1459657 Snively, David P 1459658 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy 1459659-x 1459660-x MOGAT1459661 1459661 AC Roth, Mike; P Snively, David; Bunning-Stevens, B.; Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy 1459662 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy; Roth, Mike 1459663 Snively, David P 1459664 Partridge, Scott P 1459665-x MOGAT1459666 1459666 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott; Mariani, Randy 1459667 Snively, David P 1459668-x 1459669-x MOGAT1459670 1459670 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P 1459671-x Degroot, Tom; Partridge, Scott; Lavin, Larry MOGAT1459672 1459672 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy 1459673-x MOGAT1459674 1459674 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy 1459675-x MOGAT1459682 1459682 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis 1459683-x 1459684-x MOGAT1459688 1459688 AC McBride, Thomas P MOGAT1459691 1459691 AC Lavin, Larry P 1459692-x MOGAT1459710 1459710-x AC 1459711 NP: 1 MOGAT1459744 1459744 AC; WP NP: 1, 3 1459745 NP: 1, 3 1459746 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1459815 1459815-x AC MOGAT1459864 1459864 AC Mariani, Randy; P Hansen, Myles MOGAT1459892 1459892 AC Mariani, Randy; P Lavin, Larry P 1459893 Mariani, Randy Lavin, Larry MOGAT1459914 1459914-x AC 1459915-x 1459916-x 1459917-x MOGAT1459939 1459939 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1459942 1459942 AC; WP Snively, David P 1459943 Snively, David P 1459944-x MOGAT1459945 1459945-x AC MOGAT1459947 1459947 AC; WP Partridge, Scott P 1459948-x MOGAT1459951 1459951 AC Partridge, Scott P 1459952 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1459953 1459953 AC; WP Partridge, Scott P 1459954 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1459955 1459955 AC Roman, Robert; P Hoerner, Dennis; Rands, Todd MOGAT1459958 1459958-x AC 1459959 Hansen, Myles P 1459960 Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1459966 1459966 AC Hansen, Myles P 1459967 Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1459968 1459968 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1459970 1459970 AC; WP Winski, John P 1459971-x 1459972-x MOGAT1460002 1460002 AC; WP Snively, David P 1460003 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1460004-x

Binder 28 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1y TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1460008 1460008 AC; WP Hansen, Myles; P Mariani, Randy; McClain, Kyle 1460009-x MOGAT1460013 1460013 AC Hansen, Myles P 1460014 Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1460024 1460024 AC Shelton, Reuben; P Hansen, Myles; Partridge, Scott; Gleklen, Jonathan MOGAT1460032 1460032 AC Hansen, Myles P 1460033 Hansen, Myles P MOGAT1460062 1460062 AC Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1460068 1460068 AC Carrato, Tom P 1460069-x MOGAT1460070 1460070 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1460089 1460089 AC Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1460095 1460095 AC Partridge, Scott P 1460096-x MOGAT1460097 1460097 AC NP: 1, 3 1460098 NP: 1, 3 1460099 NP: 1, 3 1460100 Bosch, Henry P 1460101 Bosch, Henry P

Binder 29 of 29 — Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

^1z see fn 1 ^{2r 3j} see fn 3 ^4f see fn 4 TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1461238 1461238-x AC 1461239-x 1461240-x 1461241-x 1461242-x 1461243 NP: 1 1461244-x 1461245-x 1461246-x MOGAT1461249 1461249 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1461265 1426565 AC NP: 1, 3 1426566 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1461283 1461283 AC NP: 1, 3 1461284 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1461301 1461301 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1461314 1461314 AC; WP McClain, Kyle P 1461315 McClain, Kyle P 1461316 McClain, Kyle P MOGAT1461324 1461324 AC Mariani, Randy P 1461325-x MOGAT1461342 1461342-x AC 1461343-x 1461344-x 1461345-x 1461346 NP: 1, 3 1461347 NP: 1, 3 1461348 NP: 1, 3 1461349-x 1461350-x 1461351-x 1461352-x 1461353-x 1461354-x 1461355-x 1461356-x 1461357-x 1461358-x 1461359-x 1461360-x 1461361-x 1461362-x 1461362-x 1461364-x 1461365-x 1461366-x 1461367-x 1461368-x 1461369-x 1461370-x 1461371-x 1461372-x 1461373-x 1461374-x 1461375-x 1461376-x 1461377-x 1461378-x 1461379-x 1461380-x 1461381-x 1461382-x 1461383-x 1461384-x 1461385-x 1461386-x 1461387-x 1461388-x 1461389-x 1461390-x 1461391-x 1461392-x 1461393-x 1461394-x 1461395-x 1461396-x 1461397-x 1461398-x 1461399-x 1461400-x 1461401-x 1461402-x 1461403-x 1461404-x 1461405-x 1461406-x 1461407-x 1461408-x 1461409-x 1461410-x 1461411-x 1461412-x 1461413-x 1461414-x 1461415-x 1461416-x 1461417-x 1461418-x 1461419-x 1461420-x 1461421-x 1461422-x 1461423-x 1461424-x 1461425-x MOGAT1461431 1461431 AC Mariani, Randy P 1461432-x MOGAT1461437 1461437 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1461452 1461452 AC Partridge, Scott P 1461453-x MOGAT1461463 1461463 AC Partridge, Scott; P Snively, David 1461464 Partridge, Scott; P Snively, David MOGAT1461465 1461465 AC Martin, Chris P 1461466-x 1461467-x MOGAT1461468 1461468 AC Partridge, Scott; P DeCamp, Michael MOGAT1461469 1461469 AC Partridge, Scott; P DeCamp, Michael MOGAT1461470 1461470 AC Partridge, Scott; P 1461471-x DeCamp, Michael MOGAT1461472 1461472 AC Bunning-Stevens, B. P 1461473 Bunning-Stevens, B. P 1461474 MOGAT1461476 1461476 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1461492 1461492 AC; WP Bosch, Henry P 1461493 Bosch, Henry P MOGAT1461500 1461500 AC; WP Bosch, Henry P 1461501 Bosch, Henry P 1461502 Bosch, Henry P 1461503-x 1461504-x MOGAT1461603 1461603 AC Walsh, Kevin P 1461604 Walsh, Kevin MOGAT1461605 1461605 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1461608 1461608 AC; WP Gutzler, Greg P 1461609-x 1461610-x MOGAT1461611 1461611 AC Hamilton, Nancy; P Martin, Chris MOGAT1461618 1461618 AC Stater, Stacey MOGAT1461622 1461622 AC Partridge, Scott; P Hansen, Myles; Ugarte, Mike DeCamp, Michael MOGAT1461625 1461625 AC Carrato, Tom P 1461626-x MOGAT1461628 1461628 AC Partridge, Scott; P Hansen, Myles; Ugarte, Mike; DeCamp, Michael 1461629 Partridge, Scott; P Hansen, Myles; Ugarte, Mike; DeCamp, Michael 1461630-x MOGAT1461633 1461633 AC Partridge, Scott P 1461634-x MOGAT1461637 1461637-x AC MOGAT1461661 1461661-x AC 1461662-x 1461663 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1461664 1461664 AC Li, Chunping P Roth, Mike 1461665 Li, Chunping P Roth, Mike 1461666 Snively, David; P Li, Chunping; Roth, Mike MOGAT1461667 1461667-x AC 1461668-x 1461669 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1461670 1461670-x AC P 1461671 Stater, Stacey MOGAT1461676 1461676 AC NP: 1 1461677-x MOGAT1461687 1461687 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1461688 Snively, David P 1461689-x 1461690 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1461691 1461691 AC Partridge, Scott P 1461692 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1461693-x 1461694 Partridge, Scott P 1461695 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1461696 1461696 AC Snively, David; P DeCamp, Michael 1461697 Partridge, Scott P 1461698 Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1461699-x 1461700 Partridge, Scott P MOGAT1461701 1461701 AC; WP Partridge, Scott P 1461702 Snively, David P 1461703-x 1461704-x MOGAT1461705 1461705 AC Hansen, Myles; P Partridge, Scott; Ugarte, Mike; DeCamp, Michael MOGAT1461719 1461719-x AC 1461720 DeCamp, Michael; P Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy; Ugarte, Mike 1461721 DeCamp, Michael; P Hansen, Myles; Mariani, Randy; Ugarte, Mike 1461722 Ugarte, Mike P 1461723-x MOGAT1461724 1461724-x AC; WP 1461725 Snively, David P 1461726 Snively, David P MOGAT1461727 1461727 AC DeCamp, Michael P MOGAT1461754 1461754 AC Carrato, Tom P 1461755 Carrato, Tom P 1461756 Carrato, Tom P 1461757 Carrato, Tom P 1461758-x MOGAT1461759 1461759 AC Degroot, Tom P 1461760-x MOGAT1461774 1461774 AC NP: 1 1461775-x 1461776-x MOGAT1461777 1461777 AC; WP Hansen, Myles P 1461778-x MOGAT1461781 1461781 AC Roman, Robert P 1461782-x 1461783-x MOGAT1461810 1461810 AC Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1461811 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1461812 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1461813 Stater, Stacey; P Roman, Robert 1461814 1461815 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1461819 1461819 AC NP: 3 1461820 NP: 3 1461821-x 1461822 Roman, Robert P 1461823-x MOGAT1461832 1461832 AC Roman, Robert P 1461833-x 1461834-x MOGAT1461835 1461835 AC Baucum, Scott P 1461836 Baucum, Scott; P Roman, Robert; Stater, Stacey MOGAT1461837 1461837-x AC 1461838-x 1461839 Bunning-Stevens, B.; P Roman, Robert 1461840-x MOGAT1461845 1461845-x AC 1461846 NP: 1, 3 1461847 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1461848 1461848-x AC 1461849 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1461850 1461850 AC NP: 3 1461851-x 1461852-x 1461853-x MOGAT1461856 1461856 AC Roman, Robert P 1461857-x MOGAT1461890 1461890-x AC 1461891-x 1461892-x 1461893-x 1461894 Roman, Robert; P Hansen, Myles 1461895 Roman, Robert; P Hansen, Myles MOGAT1461896 1461896 AC 1461897-x 1461898-x MOGAT1461899 1461899 AC Bunning-Stevens, B. P 1461900 Bunning-Stevens, B. P 1461901-x MOGAT1461902 1461902-x AC 1461903 Mariani, Randy; P Hoerner, Dennis MOGAT1461904 1461904 AC Hoerner, Dennis P MOGAT1461907 1461907 AC Hansen, Myles; P Hoerner, Dennis

Supplemental Binder (August 4, 2011)

— Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1461910 1461910-x AC 1461911 Carrato, Tom P 1461912 Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1461913 1461913 AC; WP Carrato, Tom P 1461914-x MOGAT1461915 1461915-x AC 1461916 Hoerner, Dennis; P Hansen, Myles MOGAT1461917 1461917 AC Rands, Todd P 1461918 Rands, Todd P 1461919-x 1461920-x 1461921-x 1461922-x 1461923-x 1461924-x MOGAT1461925 1461925 AC Rands, Todd P 1461926 Rands, Todd P 1461927 Rands, Todd; P Bunning-Stevens, B. 1461928-x 1461929-x 1461930-x 1461931-x 1461932-x 1461933-x MOGAT1461934 1461934-x AC MOGAT1461945 1461945 AC Hoerner, Dennis P 1461946-x 1461947-x 1461948-x MOGAT1461950 1461950 AC DeCamp, Michael P 1461951 Snively, David P 1461952-x MOGAT1461962 1461962 AC Snively, David; P Partridge, Scott 1461963 DeCamp, Michael; P Snively, David 1461964 Snively, David; P DeCamp, Michael 1461965-x MOGAT1461966 1461966-x AC; WP MOGAT1461969 1461969 AC Partridge, Scott; P Hansen, Myles; Snively, David 1461970-x 1461971-x 1461972-x 1461973-x 1461974-x 1461975-x MOGAT1461976 1461976 AC Macek, Gary P MOGAT1461979 1461979 AC NP: 1 1461980-x MOGAT1461983 1461983 AC Hansen, Myles; P Roman, Robert 1461984-x

Supplemental Binder

— Previously Produced Redacted Documents

— Monsanto's Partially Privileged Redacted and Unredacted Documents

Note: An "x" after production number indicates an unredacted document.

Note from Court: The claimed privilege documents were not assembled in the order of the privilege log. Some documents, as noted, were redacted in this binder, but not listed on the privilege log. They were ruled. ^1aa see fn 1 ^2s see fn 2 see fn 2 see fn 2 ^3k see fn 3

1aa This document was ruled P as part of a chain of documents, but in this context, it is not privileged.

2s Request for more information. This is not on privilege log, but is redacted. This is a settlement agreement. Based on what is presented to the Court, without more, it is not privileged.

3k This document was not supplied.

TAB PRODUCTION PRIVILEGE ATTORNEY COURT NUMBER RULING MOGAT1242640 1242640-x AC 1242641-x MOGAT1308995 1308995-x AC 1308996-x 1308997 NP: 1, 3 1308998-x MOGAT1309444 1309444-x AC 1309445 NP: 1, 3 1309446-x 1309447-x MOGAT1309529 1309529-x AC MOGAT1310060 1310060-x AC 1310061 NP: 1 MOGAT1310503 1310503 AC NP: 1, 3 1310504-x MOGAT1311772 1311772 AC Mariani, Randy; P Dennis Hoerner MOGAT1312498 1312498-x AC MOGAT1312499 1312499 NP: 1 1312500-x 1312501-x MOGAT1312563 1312563-x AC 1312564-x MOGAT1312565 1312565 1312566 NP: 1, 3 1312567 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1312637 1312637 AC Lavin, Larry P 1312638-x 1312639 NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1312657 1312657 AC Hoerner, Dennis; P Mariani, Randy 1312658-x MOGAT1319396 1319396 AC Carrato, Tom P MOGAT1323215 1323215 AC NP: 1, 3 MOGAT1331952 1331952-x AC 1331953-x 1331954 NP: 1, 3 1331955-x MOGAT1331956 1331956-x AC 1331957 NP: 1, 3 1331958-x MOGAT1332100 1332100-x AC 1332101 NP: 1, 3 1332102-x 1332103 NP: 1, 3 1332104-x MOGAT1337717 1337717 AC NP: 1, 3 1337718-x MOGAT1344216 1344216 AC DeCamp, Michael; P Myles Hansen 1344217-x MOGAT1351772 1351772-x AC 1351773-x 1351774 NP: 1, 3 1351775-x MOGAT1352272 1352272 AC NP: 1 MOGAT1352403 1352403 AC NP: 1 1352404 NP: 1 1352405-x MOGAT1353332 1353332-x AC MOGAT1356237 1356237-x AC 1356238-x MOGAT1356251 1356251 1356252 1356253 MOGAT1361839 1361839-x AC 1361840-x 1361841 NP: 1, 3 1361842-x MOGAT1362353 1362353-x WP 1362354-x 1362355-x MOGAT1362460 1362460 AC 1362461 NP: 1, 3 1362462 MOGAT1363728 1363728-x AC 1363729 NP: 1, 3 1363730-x 1363731-x MOGAT1363732 1363732-x AC 1363733 NP: 1 1363734-x MOGAT1365510 1365510 AC MOGAT1367896 1367896-x AC MOGAT1368016 1368016-x AC MOGAT1368963 1368963 AC; WP Bosch, Henry P 1368964-x MOGAT1371433 1371433 AC NP: 1, 3 1371434-x 1371435-x MOGAT1372125 1372125-x AC 1372126 Hoerner, Dennis P 1372127-x MOGAT1374717 1374717 AC NP: 1 1374718-x MOGAT1375434 1375434-x AC Note: The individuals identified as "source" are not always the "source" concluded by the Court.

Volume 1 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 37134 37134 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 2 37222 37222 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 3 122205 122205 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal P 4 146087 146087 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean; Jacobi, Dan P 5 170358 170358 Atty-Client Thomas, Jeane P 6 234670 234670 Atty-Client Baldwin, Glen P 7 254599 254599 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 8 254602 254602 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 9 261621 261621 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 301194 Atty-Client Faegre Benson P 10 268560 268560 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 318098 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 11 283754 283754 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 12 339284 339284 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 13 339287 339287 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 14 340484 340484 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 15 344714 344714 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 16 391540 391540 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 17 413705 413705 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan; P 461390 Cosgrove, Dan 18 438240 438240 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 19 547220 547220 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 20 575852 575852 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 21 607354 607354 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 22 607907 607907 Atty-Client Hinderaker, John H. P 23 614561 614561 Atty-Client Smith, Wm Randolph P 24 614938 614938 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 25 617387 617387 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 26 617391 617391 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 27 617402 617402 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 28 668624 668624 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 29 668631 668631 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 30 1130135 1130135 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 31 1130137 1130137 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 32 1276149 1483885 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 33 1276187 1483940 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal P 34 1276202 1483949 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal P 35 1277789 1277789 Atty-Client McKay, Judith P

Volume 2 of 46 — Defendant's Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 1277791 1277791 Atty-Client McKay, Judith P 2 1277795 1277795 Atty-Client McKay, Judith P 3 1311816 1311816 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 4 1558479 1558479 Atty-Client Callistein, Steve; P Cosgrove, Dan 5 1558480 1558480 Atty-Client Callistein, Steve; P Cosgrove, Dan 6 1558481 1558481 Atty-Client Callistein, Steve; P Cosgrove, Dan 7 1558482 1558482 Atty-Client Callistein, Steve; P Cosgrove, Dan 8 1560452 1560452 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 9 1576838 1585686 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 10 1577928 1588981 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 1588982 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 1588987 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1

Volume 3 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

^1ab see fn 1 ^2t see fn 2 ^{3l 4g 5c} TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 1843161 1843935 Atty-Client; Edgar, Cassie P Work Product 2 1897731 1897731 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 1903072 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal P 3 2460624 2460624 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 4 2460626 2460626 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 5 2691489 2691489 Atty-Client Callistein, Steve 6 2731911 2731911 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 7 2739789 2739789 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 8 2740071 2740071 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 9 2773344 2773344 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 2820036 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 10 2773480 2773480 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 2820032 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 11 3078467 3078467 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 12 3811778 3816622 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 13 3942861 3942861 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 14 4050774 4050774 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 15 11727090 11727090 Atty-Client Miller, Justin P 16 11807047 11807047 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean; P Callistein, Steve 17 11807139 11807139 Atty-Client Morh, Dean; P Callistein, Steve 18 11855653 11855807 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 19 11936658 11936658 Atty-Client Miller, Justin P 20 11966820 11966820 Atty-Client; Jacobi, Dan P Work Product 21 11966822 11966822 Atty-Client; Jacob, Dan P Work Product 22 11966823 11966823 Atty-Client; Jacobi, Dan P Work Product 23 11966841 11968122 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 24 11988960 11988960 Atty-Client Christenbury, Lynne P 11989643 Christenbury, Lynne NP: 1, 3 25 12048326 12063590 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 26 12051688 12084051 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 27 12133202 12183403 Atty-Client Koszewski, Andrew P 28 12201122 12201122 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1, 3

Volume 4 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 12220851 12220851 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 12241607 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 12241608 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 12268970 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean NP: 1

Volume 5 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 12220954 12220954 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 12241634 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 12241637 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 12269046 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean NP: 1

Volume 6 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

^{1ac 2u 3m 4h 5d 6c} see fn 6 ^7b see fn 7 ^{8a 9a 10a 11 12 13 14 15 16} see fn 9 ¹⁷ see fn 10 TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 12331659 12331659 Atty-Client; Edgar, Cassie NP: 1 Work Product 2 12331663 12331663 Atty-Client; Edgar, Cassie NP: 1 Work Product 3 12331909 12331909 Atty-Client; Edgar, Cassie NP: 1 Work Product 4 12373426 12381165 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 12381166 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 12382766 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 5 12373429 12381179 Atty-Client; Edgar, Cassie NP: 1 Work Product 6 12373552 12373552 Atty-Client; Johnson, Chad P Work Product 7 12373918 12373918 Atty-Client Miller, Justin P 8 12374883 12381559 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 9 12375667 12375667 Atty-Client; Edgar, Cassie P Work Product 10 12423355 12423355 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff 11 12423369 12423369 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff 12 12426039 12426039 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 13 15059631 15059631 Atty-Client; Pioneer Legal NP: 1, 3 Work Product 14 15059632 15059632 Atty-Client; Pioneer Legal NP: 1, 3 Work Product 15 15100798 15100798 Atty-Client McKay, Judith P 16 18297981 18297981 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean NP: 1 17 18498680 18498680 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1, 3 18 18587279 18587279 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1, 3 19 23790766 23790766 Atty-Client; Beardell, Lori NP: 1 Work Product 20 23791515 23791515 Atty-Client; Beardell, Lori NP: 1 Work Product 21 23807031 23807031 Atty-Client; Beardell, Lori NP: 1 Work Product 22 23807449 238074449 Atty-Client; Pioneer Legal NP: 1, 3 Work Product 23 23807460 23807460 Atty-Client; Beardell, Lori P Work Product 24 23962279 23973895 Atty-Client; Edgar, Cassie NP: 1 Work Product 23973899 Atty-Client; Edgar, Cassie NP: 1 Work Product 25 24333062 24333062 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 Beardell, Lori 26 24421795 24430667 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean 24430669 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean 27 MONP0034294 MONP0034294 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P

Volume 7 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 9596 9596 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 2 23521 23521 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 3 25620 25620 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1, 6 4 27306 67817 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff NP: 1 67818 Rowe, Jeff NP: 1 5 27312 67760 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 6 27440 27440 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 7 49603 49603 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 91103 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 8 85023 85023 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 9 94589 94589 Atty-Client Gorsche, Jim P 10 113957 113957 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1, 3 11 146036 146036 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 12 248546 248546 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 13 248548 248548 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 14 254823 254823 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 15 254908 254908 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 16 255138 255138 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 17 256311 256311 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 18 256828 256828 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 19 256955 256955 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 20 256987 321058 Atty-Client Grauel, Todd P 21 256998 321115 Atty-Client Grauel, Todd P 22 256999 321088 Atty-Client Grauel, Todd P

Volume 8 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 258092 258092 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 316573 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1

Volume 9 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 258118 316732 Atty-Client Kurtz, Bradley NP: 1 316733 Atty-Client Kurtz, Bradley NP: 1 2 258987 323286 Atty-Client McKay, Judith NP: 1 3 259190 316955 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 323517 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 323519 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 4 260956 300770 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 5 263837 263837 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 6 266641 266641 Atty-Client McKay, Judith P

Volume 10 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 269310 269310 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 2 269704 269704 Atty-Client McKay, Judith P 3 272673 319466 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 4 272677 272677 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 319496 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 319497 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean NP: 1 5 283368 283368 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 6 284887 284887 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 7 337240 337240 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 489300 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 8 337508 337508 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 9 339666 339666 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 10 346547 346547 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 11 346842 346842 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 12 347975 347975 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 13 349255 349255 Atty-Client Jervis, Herb P 14 349256 349256 Atty-Client Jervis, Herb P 15 361234 361234 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 16 361526 361526 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 17 361713 361713 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 18 372725 372725 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 19 377149 451578 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 20 379115 452169 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P

Volume 11 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 383344 383344 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 2 391241 391241 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 3 401909 401909 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 4 401912 401912 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 5 401915 401915 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 6 401920 401920 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 7 401925 401925 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 8 408679 462250 Atty-Client Prochaska, Cassie P 9 409161 409161 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 10 413705 413705 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 461390 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan; P Cosgrove, Dan P 11 427797 427797 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 12 427803 427803 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 13 427806 427806 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 14 545816 545816 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 15 545895 552581 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 16 546973 546973 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 553292 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 17 546981 546981 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 553236 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 18 547019 553262 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 19 547111 547111 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 553331 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 20 547115 553499 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 21 548527 548527 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 22 549299 549299 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal P 23 551891 556991 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1

Volume 12 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 566853 568879 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 2 572023 577531 Atty-Client DuPont Legal P 3 575604 575604 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 4 576702 576702 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 5 614936 614936 Atty-Client; Jacobi, Dan P Work Product 6 615063 615063 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 7 615476 615476 Atty-Client Sager, Thomas P 8 619036 619036 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 9 623970 623970 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P

Volume 13 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 655119 655119 Atty-Client; Bartholomaus, Carl P Work Product 2 658685 658685 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 3 658751 658751 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 4 668623 668623 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P

Volume 14 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

^1ad see fn 1 TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 668633 668633 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 2 1074064 1074064 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 3 1107051 1107051 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 4 1109911 1109911 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 5 1166150 1166150 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 6 1166156 1166156 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 7 1274274 1274274 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan 8 1306277 1306277 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan (Sauber) P 9 1314698 1314698 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan (Sauber) P 10 1314702 1314702 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean (Sauber) P 11 1380180 1500974 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 12 1571884 1571884 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 13 1572102 1572102 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 14 1572134 1572134 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 15 1582630 1602215 Atty-Client Yates, Michael NP: 1 16 1597614 1597614 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 17 1672934 1706158 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P

Volume 15 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 1766428 1768097 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 1768370 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 1768938 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 1768939 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P

Volume 16 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 1766430 1768093 Atty-Client Costrove, Dan NP: 1 1768353 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 1768950 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal P 1768951 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal P 2 1772655 1772655 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 3 1780934 1780934 Atty-Client Busse, Paul P 4 1781241 1781241 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan; Costrove, P Dan; Estrin, Barry

Volume 17 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 1781142 1787565 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 1788119 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 1788126 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 1788127 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P

Volume 18 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

^1ae see fn 1 TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 1802560 1806115 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 2 1825166 1825166 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 3 1826395 1826395 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 4 1830348 1830348 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 5 1840670 1840670 Atty-Client Johnson, Chad P 6 1861629 1861629 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 7 1861648 1861648 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 8 1861649 1861649 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 9 1939432 1939432 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise 10 1947874 1947874 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 11 1973223 1973223 Atty-Client Rehberg, Edward NP: 1 12 2199917 2199917 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan NP: 1, 3 13 2226523 2226523 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 14 2240939 2240939 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 15 2292812 2292812 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P

Volume 19 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 2292868 2292868 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 2 2295470 2314353 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1

Volume 20 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

^{1af 2v} see fn 2 ³ⁿ see fn 3 TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 2295470 2318263 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 2320456 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 2320457 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 2 2295491 2315114 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 2318178 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 2318179 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 2318184 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 2318961 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 2318971 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas 2318972 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas

Volume 21 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 2295517 2313848 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 2317168 Foutch, Louise NP: 1 2 2295536 2313923 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 2317167 Foutch, Louise NP: 1 3 2295893 2295893 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 4 2295894 2295894 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 5 2295954 2295954 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 6 2296130 2315123 Atty-Client DuPont Legal NP: 1 2317533 DuPont Legal NP: 1 7 2296150 2315079 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry NP: 1 2317483 Estrin, Barry NP: 1 8 2296546 2296546 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 9 2296549 2296549 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 10 2338058 2338058 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 11 2338110 2338110 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 12 2338113 2338113 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 13 2462075 2462075 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 14 2474571 2475835 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff NP: 1 15 2494859 2495238 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1

Volume 22 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 2572012 2588884 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 2588890 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 2588893 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 2588896 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 2588907 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 2588914 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 2588923 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1

Volume 23 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 2572237 2588887 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 2588909 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 2588918 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 2588921 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1

Volume 24 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

^1ag see fn 1 ^2w see fn 2 TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 2581038 2581876 Atty-Client Katz, Elliott NP: 1 2 2581059 2581944 Atty-Client Katz, Elliott P 3 2581211 2581211 Atty-Client Pond, Nigel NP: 1, 3 4 2581225 2581225 Atty-Client Pond, Nigel NP: 1, 3 5 2641800 2641800 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean 6 2645956 2646141 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise 2646142 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 7 2650285 2701790 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1

Volume 25 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 2650570 2701480 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 2 2650586 2701464 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 3 2654950 2654950 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 4 2655864 2655864 Atty-Client Kuhn, Meredith P 5 2676512 2697431 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 6 2676558 2697400 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 7 2678833 2678833 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 8 2679785 2679785 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 9 2680616 2680616 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 10 2688920 2688920 Atty-Client Callistein, Steve P

Volume 26 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

^1ah see fn 1 TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 2689448 2689448 Atty-Client Gorsche, Jim NP: 1 2 2689874 2689874 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 3 2691414 2691414 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 4 2710784 2710784 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 5 2710785 2710785 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 6 2710786 2710786 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 7 2710787 2710787 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 8 2710788 2710788 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 9 2710790 2710790 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 10 2710791 2710791 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 11 2710793 2710793 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 12 2710795 2710795 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 13 2713606 2713606 Atty-Client Callistein, Steve P 14 2715578 2715578 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie 15 2723781 2723781 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 16 2735231 2735231 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan NP: 1 17 2752279 2795563 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 18 2763439 2763439 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 19 2765811 2770168 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 20 2767625 2767625 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 21 2767626 2767626 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 22 2767627 2767627 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 23 2767628 2767628 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 24 2767629 2767629 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 25 2767630 2767630 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 26 2767631 2767631 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 27 2767632 2767632 Atty-Client Estrin, Barry P 28 2770167 2770167 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 29 2772375 2819880 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 30 2772378 2819957 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 31 2831240 2831240 Atty-Client Johnson, Chad P 32 2831437 2831653 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie; P Callistein, Steve 33 2831446 2831642 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 34 2833473 2833473 Atty-Client Bunz, Susan P 2889583 Atty-Client Bunz, Susan P

Volume 27 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 2834076 2890240 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 2897192 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan; NP: 1 Foutch, Louise 2897193 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan; NP: 1 Cosgrove, Dan 2897196 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 2898175 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 2898176 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal P 2898207 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1

Volume 28 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 2834147 2834147 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 2889754 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 2 2835075 2835075 Atty-Client Moxon, Claire P 3 2900684 2901913 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean NP: 1 4 2901160 2901160 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1, 3 2904564 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 5 2925803 2927310 Atty-Client Callistein, Steve P 6 2964934 2964934 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 7 2965032 2965032 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 8 2969150 2969150 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 9 2969155 2969155 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 10 2969158 3005854 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 3010320 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 3010322 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 11 2969162 3005863 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 3010452 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 3010454 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1

Volume 29 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

^1ai see fn 1 TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 3074961 3975375 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 2 3543018 3543018 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 3 3558799 3558799 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 4 3559156 3559156 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 5 3566408 3566408 Atty-Client Callistein, Steve P 6 3589519 3613238 Atty-Client Callistein, Steve P 3615769 Atty-Client Callistein, Steve P 7 3590331 3590331 Atty-Client Gorsche, Jim P 8 3694749 3694749 Atty-Client Katz, Elliott P 9 3694782 3694782 Atty-Client Katz, Elliott P 10 3769599 3769599 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 11 3789447 3789447 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 12 3809569 3809569 Atty-Client Katz, Elliott P 13 3811605 3811605 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan NP: 1 14 3844467 3844467 Atty-Client Koszewski, Andrew NP: 1 15 3884740 3887247 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 16 3889586 3889586 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 17 3896841 3896841 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 18 3896916 3896916 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 19 3896917 3896917 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 20 3897112 3897112 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 21 3942850 3942850 Atty-Client Pond, Nigel NP: 1 22 4054378 4054378 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan NP: 1 23 4091819 4091819 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan 24 4160264 4160264 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 4162966 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan NP: 1 25 4826965 4826965 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 26 4826966 4826966 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 27 4861209 4861209 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 28 4861742 4861742 Atty-Client Cigan, Amy P 29 4886011 4886011 Atty-Client Estri, Barry P 30 4888392 4888392 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 31 6036564 6036564 Atty-Client Callistein, Steve P 32 11689319 11692563 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 Foutch, Louise

Volume 30 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

^1aj see fn 1 ^2x see fn 2 ^3o see fn 3 TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 11725998 11725998 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 2 11819475 11820821 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 3 11819476 11820864 Atty-Client Kreuger, Andreas; P McKenna Long Aldridge 4 11819478 11820834 Atty-Client Kreuger, Andreas; P McKenna Long Aldridge 5 11819481 11820890 Atty-Client Kreuger, Andreas; P McKenna Long Aldridge 6 11819484 11820848 Atty-Client Kreuger, Andreas; P McKenna Long Aldridge 7 11920988 11920988 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 8 12012018 12044271 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 9 12014180 12014180 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie NP: 1 12052522 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 10 12092948 12215996 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff NP: 1 12216011 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 11 12092956 12216026 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff NP: 1 12216050 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 12 12096125 12096125 Atty-Client Cigan, Amy P 13 12096153 12096153 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff 14 12096165 12096165 Atty-Client Cigan, Amy 15 12096166 12096166 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise 16 12096179 12096179 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise P 17 12219263 12219263 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1

Volume 31 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

^{1ak 2y 3p 4i 5e} TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 12219628 12219628 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 12240988 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan; P Jacobi Dan 2 12373442 12373442 Atty-Client Johnson, Chad P 3 12374912 12374912 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie NP: 1 4 12375954 12375954 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 5 12375967 12375967 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie NP: 1 6 12397273 12397273 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 7 12397280 12397280 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 8 12404539 12404539 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff P 9 12404628 12404628 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 10 12423614 12423614 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff NP: 1 11 12516892 12518272 Atty-Client Katz, Elliott NP: 1 12 13707527 13708616 Atty-Client; Pioneer Legal NP: 1 Work Product 13708617 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 13711316 Atty-Client; Pioneer Legal NP: 1 Work Product 13711317 Atty-Client; Pioneer Legal NP: 1 Work Product 13711318 Atty-Client; Pioneer Legal NP: 1 Work Product 13 14216898 14216898 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 14 15005881 15005881 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 15 15005883 15005883 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 16 15069479 15069479 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan NP: 1

Volume 32 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 15147753 15147753 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean NP: 1, 3 2 15230081 15272641 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 3 15257202 15257202 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 4 15296245 15296245 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 5 15298864 15298864 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 6 15354411 15354411 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 7 15431853 15431853 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 8 15507649 15507649 Atty-Client Smith, Steven P 9 15519796 15520107 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1, 4 10 15535696 15535696 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 11 15539648 15539803 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1, 3 12 15545224 15545224 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P

Volume 33 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 15546044 15546299 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean NP: 1 2 15546076 15546103 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal P 3 15549635 15549700 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean NP: 1

Volume 34 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 15560950 15561403 Atty-Client Michel, Marianne P 15561921 Atty-Client Michel, Marianne NP: 1

Volume 35 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 15560952 15561648 Atty-Client Callistein, Steve NP: 1

Volume 36 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 15589443 15591756 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 2 15594250 15594250 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 3 15654481 15656431 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 4 15700103 15720521 Atty-Client Akrad, Lila P 5 15705710 15725353 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 6 15733041 15733041 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan P 7 15738155 15768056 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 8 15786085 15786085 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 15832592 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 9 15786560 15786560 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1

Volume 37 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 15786563 15786563 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 15814377 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 15818245 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 15818246 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 2 15788680 15788680 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1

Volume 38 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

^1al see fn 1 TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 15788681 15788681 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 15816293 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 15820377 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 15820379 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 2 15788683 15788683 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan

Volume 39 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 15788689 15816090 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 15818532 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P 15818534 Atty-Client Krueger, Andreas P

Volume 40 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

^1am see fn 1 TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 15899019 15899019 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 2 17788034 17788034 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 3 17788157 17788157 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie 4 17788207 17788207 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie; NP: 1 Cosgrove, Dan 5 17788219 17788219 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie; NP: 1 Cosgrove, Dan 6 17830819 17830819 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 7 18360549 18360549 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 8 18360550 18360550 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 9 18360579 18360579 Atty-Client DuPont Legal NP: 1 10 18360630 18360630 Atty-Client DuPont Legal NP: 1 11 18360718 18360718 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 12 18360720 18360720 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1

Volume 41 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 18362968 18362968 Atty-Client Michel, Marianne NP: 1 2 18383983 18383983 Atty-Client Michel, Marianne NP: 1 3 18383990 18383990 Atty-Client Michel, Marianne NP: 1

Volume 42 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 18498222 18498222 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 18501178 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 18501181 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 2 18498223 18498223 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 18501194 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 18501196 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 3 18498555 18498555 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 4 18498679 18498679 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 5 18499379 18499379 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1

Volume 43 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 18499380 18499380 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 2 18499731 18499731 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 3 18563689 18563689 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 4 18639236 18639236 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 18664529 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1

Volume 44 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

^{1an 2z} TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 18655246 18655246 Atty-Client; Pioneer Legal NP: 1 Work Product 2 18673936 18673936 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 3 18957561 18957561 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 4 21857733 21857733 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 5 23745592 23745592 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 6 23805885 23805885 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 7 23962460 23974094 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 8 23962561 23973992 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie NP: 1 9 23962591 23974063 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 10 23977790 23985709 Atty-Client; Pioneer Legal NP: 1 Work Product

Volume 45 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 24013029 24027166 Atty-Client Gorsche, Jim NP: 1 24027167 Atty-Client Gorsche, Jim NP: 1 24027168 Atty-Client Gorsche, Jim NP: 1 2 24337587 24337587 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 3 24339598 24339598 Atty-Client Beardell, Lori NP: 1 4 24341156 24341156 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 5 24341224 24341224 Atty-Client Foutch, Louise NP: 1 6 24341839 24341839 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff NP: 1

Volume 46 of 46 — Defendants' Redacted Documents

^1ao TAB FAMILY ID ITEM ID PRIVILEGE SOURCE COURT RULING 1 24343186 24343186 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 2 24406210 24406210 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean NP: 1 24422834 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean NP: 1 3 MONP0027566 MONP0027567 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 4 MONP0031460 MONP0031464 Atty-Client Rowe, Jeff NP: 1 MONP0031479 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 MONP0031485 Atty-Client Pioneer Legal NP: 1 5 MONP0033670 MONP0033670 Atty-Client Jacobi, Dan P 6 MONP0034172 MONP0034172 Atty-Client Mohr, Dean P 7 MONP0035443 MONP0035443 Atty-Client; Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1 Work Product 8 MONP0037333 MONP0037333 Atty-Client Edgar, Cassie P 9 MONP167271 MONP167271 Atty-Client Cosgrove, Dan NP: 1