From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Money Service Co. v. Stuart

Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia
May 31, 1932
112 W. Va. 370 (W. Va. 1932)

Opinion

No. 7337

Submitted May 24, 1932.

Decided May 31, 1932.

Proceedings by the State, on the relation of the Money Service Company and others, for writ of prohibition, opposed by J.T. Stuart, Justice of the Peace, and others.

Writ issued.

Geoge S. Wallace, for petitioners.

Robert E. White, for respondents.


In this proceeding the petitioner seeks to prohibit the enforcement of a judgment obtained on a summons of which the justice had no knowledge prior to issuance but which was issued by a clerk under general direction from the justice to sign his name to all official papers.

It is Hornbook law that a public officer cannot delegate a discretionary power. Throop on Public Officers, sec. 571; 46 C. J., subject Officers, sec. 291; 6 R. C. L., subject Constitutional Law. So we look to the statutes relating to the issuance of a summons by a justice to ascertain if the act involves any discretion. These statutes show that before a summons is issued a justice should determine (1) whether the action sought to be brought is within his general and territorial jurisdiction; (2) whether he is under any statutory disability to act; (3) whether the process should be directed to a regular or a special constable; (4) whether the summons is prepared in form or in substance as the statute directs; (5) whether the security for costs or security on a bond is good, where security is required at the institution of the action; (6) whether the person is credible where an oath is offered to secure an order or a warrant of arrest; and (7) in such case whether the complaint states an offense. Consequently it appears that the issuance of every summons involves the discretion of the justice.

The writ will therefore issue.

Writ issued.


Summaries of

Money Service Co. v. Stuart

Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia
May 31, 1932
112 W. Va. 370 (W. Va. 1932)
Case details for

Money Service Co. v. Stuart

Case Details

Full title:STATE ex rel . MONEY SERVICE COMPANY, et al. v . J. T. STUART, J. P., et al

Court:Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia

Date published: May 31, 1932

Citations

112 W. Va. 370 (W. Va. 1932)
164 S.E. 409

Citing Cases

State ex Rel. Perry v. Miller

Under a similar statute, this Court held in Algoma Coal Coke Co. v. Alexander, 136 W. Va. 521, 529, 66 S.E.2d…

Algoma Coal v. Alexander

Reese v. Biddle, 112 Pa. 72, 3 A. 814; Crockett v. Coal Coke Co., 75 W. Va. 467, 84 S.E. 948. Likewise a fire…