From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Miller v. Whittington

Supreme Court of Alabama
Apr 22, 1920
85 So. 394 (Ala. 1920)

Opinion

4 Div. 827.

April 22, 1920.

Appeal from Probate Court, Barbour County; Bob T. Roberts, Judge.

Farmer, Merrill Farmer, of Dothan, and A. H. Merrill Sons, of Eufaula, for appellants.

Counsel discuss the various assignments of error, with citation of authority; but, in view of the opinion, it is not deemed necessary to here set it out.

George W. Peach, of Clayton, and Jones Thomas, of Montgomery, for appellee.

The bill must be stricken, because not filed in time nor signed. Sections 3019, 3020, Code 1907; 184 Ala. 598, 64 So. 69; 195 Ala. 272, 71 So. 106; 15 Ala. App. 434, 73 So. 756.


The bill of exceptions, as appears on its face, was not presented to the trial judge within 90 days from the date the decree appealed from was entered, as is required by section 2863 of the Code of 1907, nor does the bill appear to have been signed by the judge as an act of approval. The only signature of the judge appears to be as certifying that he "accepted" the presentation which, however, was more than 90 days after the judgment purports to have been entered. The presentation of the bill of exceptions within the time specified in the statute is a jurisdictional requisite to the judge's authority to sign it, so as to make it a part of the record; and the indorsement of the fact of its presentation, signed by the judge, is the only evidence to which this court will look, unless the bill is signed within the period allowed for presentation.

Nothing is presented on the record proper for review, and as the bill of exceptions was not made a part of the record, as required by law, the matters therein sought to be presented for review are not available to appellants.

Affirmed.

ANDERSON, C. J., and SAYRE and GARDNER, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

Miller v. Whittington

Supreme Court of Alabama
Apr 22, 1920
85 So. 394 (Ala. 1920)
Case details for

Miller v. Whittington

Case Details

Full title:MILLER et al. v. WHITTINGTON

Court:Supreme Court of Alabama

Date published: Apr 22, 1920

Citations

85 So. 394 (Ala. 1920)
204 Ala. 207

Citing Cases

Beatty v. McMillan

The bill of exceptions cannot be aided by extraneous evidence. Code 1923, §§ 6433, 6434; Ettore v. State, 214…

Harris v. Whittington

Miller v. Whittington, 202 Ala. 406, 80 So. 499. Upon the second trial in the probate court the issues of…