From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Meredith v. McLaughlin

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts
Apr 26, 1961
342 Mass. 778 (Mass. 1961)

Opinion

April 26, 1961.

Esther Maltzman, for the plaintiff.

Endicott Peabody, for the defendants.


Exceptions overruled. In this action of tort the judge directed a verdict for the defendants, subject to the plaintiff's exception. There was evidence of the following; The plaintiff and her daughter visited the home of the defendants for social purposes. During the visit they stated that they were going to the bathroom, which was on the second floor. They had been to the defendants' home on prior occasions but there was no evidence that they had ever been upstairs. When they went up the stairs there was no light in the upper hall. As the plaintiff was approaching the second floor landing she "called down to . . . the defendants . . . `Where is the light?'" One of the defendants replied, "It's on the wall, keep walking and you'll find it." The plaintiff "thereupon turned right at the second floor landing" and while "feeling" for the light switch she "fell down an open stairway that she knew nothing about." The stairway was unlighted and there were no barriers or handrails; it was "located at the right of the upper landing and within several feet or `two or three steps' of the head of the first stairway and off the same landing." The plaintiff, who was a guest of the defendants, could recover only upon proof of gross negligence. Comeau v. Comeau, 285 Mass. 578. The evidence would not warrant a finding of gross negligence and the judge rightly directed a verdict for the defendants. See Aragona v. Parrella, 325 Mass. 583; Palter v. Zarinsky, 338 Mass. 256; Holiday v. First Parish Church of Groton, 339 Mass. 692.


Summaries of

Meredith v. McLaughlin

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts
Apr 26, 1961
342 Mass. 778 (Mass. 1961)
Case details for

Meredith v. McLaughlin

Case Details

Full title:EVA MEREDITH vs. MARION McLAUGHLIN another

Court:Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts

Date published: Apr 26, 1961

Citations

342 Mass. 778 (Mass. 1961)
174 N.E.2d 651

Citing Cases

Montellier v. United States

In Massachusetts one owes to a licensee the duty to refrain from acts constituting gross negligence. An…

Boyajian v. Kachadorian

The plaintiffs could recover only on proof of gross negligence and the judge rightly directed the verdicts…