From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

McGregor v. Hammock

Supreme Court of Florida, En Banc
Mar 17, 1931
132 So. 815 (Fla. 1931)

Opinion

Opinion filed March 17, 1931.

An appeal from the Circuit Court for Volusia County; M. G. Rowe, Judge.

Affirmed.

M. S. McGregor, for Appellant;

Jones Green, for Appellee.


This case is before us on appeal from an order of the chancellor denying a motion of disqualification.

There was a motion filed suggesting the disqualification of the chancellor. The facts alleged in the motion are insufficient to constitute ground for disqualification under the terms of the statute on account of prejudice. The facts alleged as a basis for the belief that prejudice exists are:

"That during the month of November A.D. 1929, at a hearing of this cause in his Chambers at Daytona Beach, the said Hon. M. G. Rowe became incensed at affiant and refused to allow affiant to speak under penalty of imprisonment; that although the said Hon. M. G. Rowe afterwards stated to affiant that he (Hon. M. G. Rowe) had perhaps been hasty in his acts on that occasion, nevertheless, affiant realizes and believes that a re-occurrence of said anger would materially interfere with affiant's rights in the trial of this cause."

To hold that the existence of such facts would constitute grounds for disqualifying a trial judge on account of prejudice would divest the court of the power to maintain order and proper respect for the court. It should be said, however, that a judge should decline to officiate in a case where the judge is conscious of any bias or prejudice which might influence his official action against any party to the litigation, whether challenged or not. Judicial ermine should be zealously guarded, that it may not become the object of scorn nor warrant suspicion.

The order appealed from is affirmed.

BUFORD, C.J., AND WHITFIELD, ELLIS, BROWN AND DAVIS, J.J., concur.

TERRELL, J., not participating.


Summaries of

McGregor v. Hammock

Supreme Court of Florida, En Banc
Mar 17, 1931
132 So. 815 (Fla. 1931)
Case details for

McGregor v. Hammock

Case Details

Full title:M. S. McGREGOR, Appellant, vs. OLIN C. HAMMOCK, Appellee

Court:Supreme Court of Florida, En Banc

Date published: Mar 17, 1931

Citations

132 So. 815 (Fla. 1931)
132 So. 815

Citing Cases

Warren ex Rel. v. Dist. Ct.

We say that one change of judge had been granted in the action prior to the time petitioners herein filed the…

State v. Cannon

State ex rel. Davis v. Parks, 141 Fla. 516, 194 So. 613. Although the truth or falsity of the alleged fears…