From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

McArthur v. Mt. Shasta Power Corp.

Supreme Court of California
May 29, 1935
3 Cal.2d 766 (Cal. 1935)

Opinion

Docket No. Sac. 4710.

May 29, 1935.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Shasta County. Walter E. Herzinger, Judge. Reversed and remanded for a new trial on the issue of damages alone.

The facts are stated in the opinion of the court.

Wm. B. Bosley, Thos. J. Straub, Chenoweth Leininger, Athearn, Chandler Farmer and Frank R. Devlin for Appellant.

Arthur C. Huston, Sr., Jesse W. Carter and Annette Abbott Adams for Respondent.


This action is referred to in the opinion this day filed in the case of McArthur v. Mt. Shasta Power Corp. (Sac. No. 4765), ante, p. 704 [ 45 P.2d 816], and is a companion case to the Anna McArthur case. Respondent's lands front on Pittville Pool, and are located on the opposite side of said pool from the Anna McArthur lands and the lands of Roderick McArthur, involved in action Sac. No. 4711, ante, p. 765. [1] The same factual situation exists in this case as was presented in the Anna McArthur case. For this reason the decision in this case must be the same as that rendered and filed in the Anna McArthur case. Upon the authority of that case the judgment in the present action is reversed and the case is remanded for a new trial on the issue of damages alone, in accordance with the views expressed in the opinion this day filed in the case of McArthur v. Mt. Shasta Power Corp., Sac. No. 4765. Each party to pay his own costs.

Shenk, J., Waste, C.J., Thompson, J.. Spence, J., pro tem., and Nourse, J., pro tem., concurred.

Rehearing denied.


Summaries of

McArthur v. Mt. Shasta Power Corp.

Supreme Court of California
May 29, 1935
3 Cal.2d 766 (Cal. 1935)
Case details for

McArthur v. Mt. Shasta Power Corp.

Case Details

Full title:LUTHER McARTHUR, Respondent, v. MT. SHASTA POWER CORPORATION (a…

Court:Supreme Court of California

Date published: May 29, 1935

Citations

3 Cal.2d 766 (Cal. 1935)
45 P.2d 816

Citing Cases

Albaugh v. Mt. Shasta Power Corp.

The three McArthur cases have been before this court on one prior occasion. Upon appeals by the defendant…