Opinion
No. 18,046.
Decided September 30, 1957.
From dismissal of his complaint for failure to state a claim the plaintiff brings error.
Writ of Error Dismissed.
1. APPEAL AND ERROR — Review — Final Judgment. Where there is nothing in the record on error to indicate that a judgment was ever entered, or a motion for a new trial filed or overruled, the write of error must be dismissed.
Error to the District Court of Fremont County. Hon. Joseph D. Blunt, Judge.
Messrs. JENKINS, STEWART TURSI, Mr. JACK JENKINS, for plaintiff in error.
Mr. JACK MERWIN, for defendants in error.
THE record before us contains (1) a complaint, (2) motion to dismiss for the reason that the complaint does not state a claim, (3) motion to dismiss for the reason that the matters involved in this case had been finally adjudicated in case No. 7417 in the same court and between the same parties, this motion being supported by the record in case No. 7417 consisting of complaint, motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim and order sustaining motion to dismiss, (4) order sustaining motion to dismiss.
The record does not indicate any proceedings in the trial court subsequent to the order sustaining the motion to dismiss. There is nothing in the record to indicate that, the plaintiff was given an opportunity to amend his complaint as he had a right to do under Rule 15, R.C.P. Colo.; nothing to indicate that the plaintiff elected to stand on his complaint; nothing to indicate that a judgment was ever entered or a motion for a new trial filed or dispensed with.
Apparently case No. 7417 remains in the same unfinished state that we find in the case before us.
There being no judgment before us to review, affirm, reverse or modify, the writ of error must be dismissed. See Nutter v. Wright, 132 Colo. 304, 287 P.2d 655, and the numerous decisions of this court therein referred to.
The writ of error is dismissed without prejudice to further appropriate proceedings in the trial court and this court.