From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Maryland Casualty Company v. W. H. Stewart Sons

Supreme Court of Louisiana
Apr 1, 1957
232 La. 527 (La. 1957)

Opinion

No. 42567.

April 1, 1957.

APPEAL FROM FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT, PARISH OF ACADIA, STATE OF LOUISIANA, HONORABLE R. J. PUTMAN, J.

Mouton, Champagne Colomb, Lafayette, for plaintiff-appellant.

Charles T. Everett, Crowley, for defendants-appellees.


The plaintiff brings this suit under subrogation as workmen's compensation insurer of one Bennett Fontenot, employer of Ovey Smith, deceased, for the amount of compensation and funeral expenses paid by it to the widow and heirs of Ovey Smith, and against W. H. Stewart Sons, Inc., a corporation operating a flying service conducting spraying operations, who had been engaged by Fontenot to spray his rice crop, and Charles Edward Stewart, the pilot operating the corporation's plane that struck and killed Ovey Smith, who at the time was acting as flagman for Fontenot directing the path and direction of the operator of the plane in the spraying operation.

Since the appeal was lodged in this Court, the parties to this litigation filed a joint motion to transfer this case to the Court of Appeal, First Circuit, based on the ground that this Court is without jurisdiction to entertain the appeal relying on the recent holding in the case of Maryland Casualty Co. v. Gulf Refining Co., 231 La. 714, 92 So.2d 697.

In the case of Maryland Casualty Co. v. Gulf Refining Co., supra, we held that the appellate jurisdiction in a suit brought by the subrogee of a compensation insurer lies in the court of appeal because the suit arises out of and by virtue of the compensation statute.

For the reasons assigned, the appeal is hereby transferred to the Court of Appeal, First Circuit, pursuant to the provisions of LSA-R.S. 13:4441 and 13:4442, the record to be filed in that court by appellants within thirty days from the date on which this decree shall become final, otherwise, the appeal shall stand dismissed. All costs to await the final disposition of the cause.


Summaries of

Maryland Casualty Company v. W. H. Stewart Sons

Supreme Court of Louisiana
Apr 1, 1957
232 La. 527 (La. 1957)
Case details for

Maryland Casualty Company v. W. H. Stewart Sons

Case Details

Full title:MARYLAND CASUALTY COMPANY v. W. H. STEWART SONS, INC

Court:Supreme Court of Louisiana

Date published: Apr 1, 1957

Citations

232 La. 527 (La. 1957)
94 So. 2d 655

Citing Cases

Maryland Casualty Co. v. W. H. Stewart Sons, Inc.

Suit by compensation insurer to recover death benefits paid to employee who was killed as result of being…