From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Lyerly v. Wheeler

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Aug 1, 1851
34 N.C. 290 (N.C. 1851)

Opinion

(August Term, 1851.)

The date of a deed or other writing is prima facie evidence of the time of its execution, upon the principle that the acts of every person in transacting business are presumed to be consistent with truth, in the absence of any motive for falsehood.

APPEAL from Battle, J., at ROWAN Spring Term, 1851.

Ejectment. The facts are stated in the opinion.

Craig and Osborne for plaintiff.

Boyden for defendant.


The lessor claimed title under a sheriff's sale and deed. The demise was on 6 November, 1848. The deed was dated on the same day.

The defendant contended that the date of the deed was no evidence that it was executed on that day, and the plaintiff could not recover without proving that it was executed on the day it bore date.

The court charged that the date of the deed was prima facie evidence of the time of its execution. To this the defendant excepts, which is the only point made in the case.

There is no error. The date of the deed or other writing is prima facie evidence of the time of its execution, upon the general principle that the acts of every person in transacting business are presumed to be consistent with truth in the absence of any motive for falsehood.

PER CURIAM. No error.

Cited: Newlin v. Osborne, 49 N.C. 158; Meadows v. Cozart, 76 N.C. 452; Kendrick v. Dellinger, 117 N.C. 493; Kendrick v. Ins. Co., 124 N.C. 317; Fortune v. Hunt, 149 N.C. 362.


Summaries of

Lyerly v. Wheeler

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Aug 1, 1851
34 N.C. 290 (N.C. 1851)
Case details for

Lyerly v. Wheeler

Case Details

Full title:DOE ON DEMISE OF ISAAC LYERLY v. CLAUDIUS B. WHEELER

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Aug 1, 1851

Citations

34 N.C. 290 (N.C. 1851)

Citing Cases

Turlington v. Neighbors

When a deed is said to be executed, the meaning is, that, with all the other requisites, it has been…

Monteith v. Welch

The date recited in a deed is at least prima facie evidence that it was executed and delivered on that date.…