From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

London Co. v. Industrial Com

Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc
Oct 4, 1926
249 P. 642 (Colo. 1926)

Opinion

No. 11,613.

Decided October 4, 1926.

Proceeding under the workmen's compensation act. Judgment of the district court affirming an award of the commission for accidental injury to a wooden leg.

Reversed.

1. WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION — Personal Injuries — Artificial Limbs. Under the workmen's compensation act compensation can be awarded for personal injuries only, and not for injury to an artificial limb.

Error to the District Court of the City and County of Denver, Hon. George F. Dunklee, Judge.

Mr. WILLIAM E. HUTTON, Mr. J. P. NORDLUND, for plaintiffs in error.

Mr. WILLIAM L. BOATRIGHT, Attorney General, Mr. JEAN S. BREITENSTEIN, Assistant, for defendants in error.


THE district court affirmed an award of the commission to the claimant Chambers for the accidental injury of his wooden leg.

Compensation can be awarded for personal injuries only (C.L. §§ 4389, 4387, 4388, 4404), which means injury to the person. 1 Honnold on Workmen's Comp. § 92; Miller v. American Steel Wire Co., 90 Conn. 349, 360, 97 Atl. 345, L.R.A. 1916 E, 510; Linnane v. Aetna Brewing Co., 91 Conn. 158, 99 Atl. 507, L.R.A. 1917 D, 77; C.J. Treatise on Work. Comp. p. 63, § 54. So in criminal law. State v. Clayborne, 14 Wash. 622, 45 P. 303; 30 Cyc. 1529; Bouv. L.D. A wooden leg is a man's property, not part of his person, and no compensation can be awarded for its injury.

Judgment reversed with directions to disaffirm the award.

MR. JUSTICE CAMPBELL not participating.


Summaries of

London Co. v. Industrial Com

Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc
Oct 4, 1926
249 P. 642 (Colo. 1926)
Case details for

London Co. v. Industrial Com

Case Details

Full title:LONDON GUARANTEE AND ACCIDENT CO., ET AL. v. INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION, ET AL

Court:Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc

Date published: Oct 4, 1926

Citations

249 P. 642 (Colo. 1926)
249 P. 642

Citing Cases

Stewart v. Home Life Ins. Co. of New York

What would be his rights in the event of failure? Where would we draw the line? The plaintiff's eyes do not…

Southern Electric, Inc. v. Spall

Section 440.02(6), Florida Statutes (1959), F.S.A. 1 Larson, Workmen's Compensation Law § 42 (1952); London…