From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Lawrence v. B. Belzer Fruit Co.

Supreme Court of Minnesota
Sep 29, 1933
250 N.W. 75 (Minn. 1933)

Opinion

No. 29,565.

September 29, 1933.

Workmen's compensation act — award of compensation sustained.

Evidence examined and found to support the award of the industrial commission.

Certiorari upon the relation of B. Belzer Fruit Company, employer, and Western Casualty Insurance Company, its insurer, to review an order of the industrial commission awarding compensation to Chester Lawrence, employe, for an accidental injury to his eye. Affirmed.

Merriam Wright, for relators.

W.T. Coe, for respondent.



This case comes here upon a writ of certiorari from the industrial commission. Respondent was awarded compensation, before a referee of the industrial commission, for an injury to his eye, and the employer and its insurer appealed to the industrial commission, which affirmed the award.

Respondent was a truck driver in the employ of the B. Belzer Fruit Company. March 4, 1932, he had trouble with one of his eyes and consulted a doctor. The doctor testified that he removed a foreign substance from the eye. The doctor treated the eye later and reported it to be doing well. Respondent went back to work, and May 17, 1932, he was obliged to discontinue working because of the pain in the eye. He was sent to several physicians by the insured or its representative. The evidence is somewhat conflicting; but the respondent himself, upon cross-examination, and his wife upon direct examination, testified that the eye never completely recovered from the original injury, which the evidence shows was inflicted by a particle of wood from the boxes which the employe was handling in the course of his employment.

The industrial commission has found for the employe. We think the evidence justifies its finding. Respondent is allowed $50 attorney's fees over and above his taxable costs and disbursements.

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Lawrence v. B. Belzer Fruit Co.

Supreme Court of Minnesota
Sep 29, 1933
250 N.W. 75 (Minn. 1933)
Case details for

Lawrence v. B. Belzer Fruit Co.

Case Details

Full title:CHESTER LAWRENCE v. B. BELZER FRUIT COMPANY AND ANOTHER

Court:Supreme Court of Minnesota

Date published: Sep 29, 1933

Citations

250 N.W. 75 (Minn. 1933)
250 N.W. 75

Citing Cases

Robbins v. National Life Acc. Ins. Co.

The following rule is relied upon it in support of this theory: "`* * * It being within the scope of his…

National Casualty Co. v. Hudson

The words "sickness", "disease", or "bodily infirmity", when used in accident and health insurance policies,…