From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Kelley v. Light

Oregon Supreme Court
Jun 4, 1976
550 P.2d 427 (Or. 1976)

Opinion

Argued April 30, 1976

Affirmed June 4, 1976

Appeal from Circuit Court, Multnomah County.

Affirmed.

William M. Dale, Judge.

Denny Z. Zikes, of Hedrick, Fellows, McCarthy Zikes, P.C., Portland, argued the cause and filed a brief for appellant.

Douglas S. Robertson, of Bouneff, Muller Marshall, Portland, argued the cause and filed a brief for respondent.

Before O'Connell, Chief Justice, and McAllister, Denecke and Howell, Justices.


DENECKE, J.


The only issue in this personal injury case is whether there was evidence to support the trial court's submitting the issue of permanency of the injury to the jury.

The plaintiff's head went through the window of her car lacerating her head. At the time of the trial, two years after the collision, plaintiff had a scar running from the middle of her forehead down and across her left eyelid. The prominence of the scar was in dispute; however, the plaintiff testified she was aware of it; that the area remained numb; and that her left eyelid drooped. The jury awarded plaintiff $7,125.

The existence of a scar two years after an accident is itself sufficient evidence of permanency. Senkirik v. Royce, 192 Or. 583, 593-594, 235 P.2d 886 (1955). In addition there was the following evidence. On cross-examination the plaintiff testified: "I expect to have the drooping of my eyelid fixed. They can't do anything to the upper part of the scar, because it is going against the lines. It is going down * * *. But the only thing that they can do is fix this part right here [indicating] so that it wouldn't droop as much when I got older."

Based upon plaintiff's previous testimony and attempts to testify, we believe plaintiff's testimony above quoted was hearsay, probably being a restatement of what her surgeon told her. Her surgeon did not testify. Hearsay testimony which is not objected to, however, is competent evidence. Kraxberger v. Rogers, 231 Or. 440, 451, 373 P.2d 647 (1962).

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Kelley v. Light

Oregon Supreme Court
Jun 4, 1976
550 P.2d 427 (Or. 1976)
Case details for

Kelley v. Light

Case Details

Full title:KELLEY, Respondent, v. LIGHT, Appellant

Court:Oregon Supreme Court

Date published: Jun 4, 1976

Citations

550 P.2d 427 (Or. 1976)
550 P.2d 427

Citing Cases

Laubach v. Industrial Indemnity Co.

The only reasonable ground that we can see for refusing to give substantive weight to the deposition…