From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Kegler, Admx. v. Kempter

Court of Appeals of Ohio
Mar 9, 1942
58 N.E.2d 701 (Ohio Ct. App. 1942)

Opinion

No. 6106

Decided March 9, 1942.

Wills — Devisee-wife predeceased testator — Wife's daughter cannot take under Section 10504-73, General Code.

The daughter of a testator's wife cannot, under Section 10504-73, General Code, take property which such wife would have taken under her husband's will had she survived him.

APPEAL: Court of Appeals for Hamilton county.

Mr. Albert D. Castellini, for appellee Maria J. Kegler, Admx.

Messrs. Peck, Shaffer, Williams Gorman, for appellant.


The question presented in this case is whether the daughter of the wife of the testator takes, under Section 10504-73, General Code, the estate which her mother would have taken under the will of her husband had she survived him.

It is conceded that the Supreme Court in Schaefer v. Bernhardt, 76 Ohio St. 443, 81 N.E. 640, construed the almost identical provision as that involved in the instant case, found in the code section referred to above, to include only those related by consanguinity to the testator. As the wife was not so related, the daughter cannot take, and the gift to the wife must lapse unless this court should give to the section a different construction.

It is urged upon us that the testator considered his wife's daughter as his daughter and so referred to her; that this fact should be considered in construing the will; and that the statute should be considered as a part of the will.

As we view it, this would be giving the daughter the status of an adopted child, when no adoption proceedings had been taken, and would be permitting a party to change or amend Section 10504-73, General Code, to include relatives by affinity, when the Supreme Court has decided that its benefits are limited to relatives by consanguinity.

The judgment is affirmed.

Judgment affirmed.

MATTHEWS, P.J., HAMILTON and ROSS, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

Kegler, Admx. v. Kempter

Court of Appeals of Ohio
Mar 9, 1942
58 N.E.2d 701 (Ohio Ct. App. 1942)
Case details for

Kegler, Admx. v. Kempter

Case Details

Full title:KEGLER, ADMX., APPELLEE v. KEMPTER ET AL., APPELLEES; CLARK, APPELLANT

Court:Court of Appeals of Ohio

Date published: Mar 9, 1942

Citations

58 N.E.2d 701 (Ohio Ct. App. 1942)
58 N.E.2d 701

Citing Cases

Hewes v. Mead

Rose Fox was not the child of testatrix, neither can she be classed as "other relative." Schaefer v.…