From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

In the Matter of Lee

Court of Appeal of California, Second District
Nov 4, 1915
28 Cal.App. 806 (Cal. Ct. App. 1915)

Summary

In Branting v. Salt Lake City, 153 P. 995 (Utah 1915), Salt Lake City had passed an ordinance "by virtue of which a certain local improvement, to wit, a sewer, was ordered constructed, and a special tax was assessed and levied upon the abutting property to defray the cost of constructing the same."

Summary of this case from VR Acquisitions LLC v. Wasatch Cnty.

Opinion

Crim. No. 435.

November 4, 1915.

APPLICATION originally made to the District Court of Appeal for the Second Appellate District for a Writ of Habeas Corpus directed to the Chief of Police of the City of San Diego.

The facts are stated in the opinion of the court.

Lane D. Webber, for Petitioner.

T. B. Cosgrove, City Attorney, and Sweet, Stearns and Forward, for Respondent.

Herbert N. Ellis, Amicus Curiae.


The petition herein sets forth that the petitioner is under arrest and in custody of the chief of police of the city of San Diego pursuant to a complaint charging him with violations of a penal ordinance of that city. The specifications in that complaint are somewhat different from those mentioned in the Matter of the Application of Lee for Writ of Habeas Corpus, (Crim. No. 434), ante, p. 719, [ 153 P. 992], wherein the decision of the court has been filed this day; but the reasons given for that decision are amply sufficient to dispose of the questions presented in this case.

The writ is discharged and the petitioner remanded to custody.

James, J., and Shaw, J., concurred.


Summaries of

In the Matter of Lee

Court of Appeal of California, Second District
Nov 4, 1915
28 Cal.App. 806 (Cal. Ct. App. 1915)

In Branting v. Salt Lake City, 153 P. 995 (Utah 1915), Salt Lake City had passed an ordinance "by virtue of which a certain local improvement, to wit, a sewer, was ordered constructed, and a special tax was assessed and levied upon the abutting property to defray the cost of constructing the same."

Summary of this case from VR Acquisitions LLC v. Wasatch Cnty.

In Branting v. Salt Lake City, 47 Utah 296, 153 P. 995 (1915), a plaintiff filed an action asking the court to annul municipal ordinances and proceedings approving the construction of a sewer and levying a special tax on abutting property.

Summary of this case from Powder Run at Deer Valley Owner Ass'n v. Black Diamond Lodge at Deer Valley Ass'n of Unit Owners & Park City Mun. Corp.

applying a statute of limitations to a claim asking a court “to declare certain proceedings whereby a certain tax was assessed and levied against [the plaintiff's] property void and of no effect and to annul said proceedings”

Summary of this case from Powder Run at Deer Valley Owner Ass'n v. Black Diamond Lodge at Deer Valley Ass'n of Unit Owners & Park City Mun. Corp.

In Branting itself and all of the cases that Branting cites on this point, the courts concluded that the parties sought affirmative relief where there were active, adverse claimants.

Summary of this case from In re Malualani B. Hoopiiaina Trusts
Case details for

In the Matter of Lee

Case Details

Full title:In the Matter of the Application of H. G. LEE for a Writ of Habeas Corpus

Court:Court of Appeal of California, Second District

Date published: Nov 4, 1915

Citations

28 Cal.App. 806 (Cal. Ct. App. 1915)
153 P. 995

Citing Cases

Powder Run at Deer Valley Owner Ass'n v. Black Diamond Lodge at Deer Valley Ass'n of Unit Owners & Park City Mun. Corp.

Regardless of whether Powder Run would be able to successfully overcome the presumption of validity under the…

Voogd v. Joint Drainage Dist. No. 3-11

In other jurisdictions where the question of a governing body acting on an erroneous estimate of cost has…