From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Ibold v. 3920 Lake Shore Drive Bldg. Corp.

Appellate Court of Illinois, First District
May 18, 1945
326 Ill. App. 257 (Ill. App. Ct. 1945)

Opinion

Gen. No. 42,886. (Abstract of Decision.)

Opinion filed May 18, 1945 Rehearing denied June 8, 1945 Released for publication June 8, 1945

CONTRACTS, § 357contract as lacking mutuality because of indefiniteness of provision for compensation. In action on written contract of employment for five years as manager of residential building, which provided compensation "not to exceed 4% of gross rental income," where plaintiff was discharged after completing less than four years as manager, during which he was paid the maximum provided for in the contract, and thereafter rendered no services for defendant, held plaintiff could not recover on contract because salary provision was indefinite, since it set only a maximum, and therefore "contract" lacked mutuality; that its terms, not being ambiguous, were not subject to definition by conduct of parties relating to remuneration prior to plaintiff's discharge.

See Callaghan's Illinois Digest, same topic and section number.

Appeal from the Circuit Court of Cook county; the Hon. DANIEL P. TRUDE, Judge, presiding.

Judgment reversed, and remanded. Heard in the third division, first district, this court at the December term, 1943.

Poppenhusen, Johnston, Thompson Raymond for appellant;

Henry J. Brandt, Abraham L. Rittenberg, and Adolf Loeb, of counsel;

Adams, Moses Culver, for appellee;

Charles G. Culver, of counsel.


Not to be published in full. Opinion filed May 18, 1945; rehearing denied June 8, 1945; released for publication June 8, 1945.


Summaries of

Ibold v. 3920 Lake Shore Drive Bldg. Corp.

Appellate Court of Illinois, First District
May 18, 1945
326 Ill. App. 257 (Ill. App. Ct. 1945)
Case details for

Ibold v. 3920 Lake Shore Drive Bldg. Corp.

Case Details

Full title:Leander J. Ibold, Appellee, v. 3920 Lake Shore Drive Building Corporation…

Court:Appellate Court of Illinois, First District

Date published: May 18, 1945

Citations

326 Ill. App. 257 (Ill. App. Ct. 1945)
61 N.E.2d 305

Citing Cases

Meadows v. Radio Industries

See Davis v. Fidelity Fire Insurance Co., 208 Ill. 375, at page 385, 70 N.E. 359 and Joliet Bottling Co. v.…

Cook-Master, Inc. v. Nicro Steel Products, Inc.

The count charges that it was understood and agreed between the parties that plaintiff was to pay a…