From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Hopper v. Kalkman

Supreme Court of California
Jan 1, 1861
17 Cal. 517 (Cal. 1861)

Opinion

         Appeal from the Seventh District.

         COUNSEL

          Tod Robinson, for the motion.

         J. B. Harmon, contra.


         JUDGES: Field, C. J. delivered the opinion of the Court. Baldwin, J. concurring.

         OPINION

          FIELD, Judge

         The defendants at the time of entering their appearance--one of them by answer and the other by demurrer--moved the District Court, upon a petition setting forth that they were aliens, and citizens of the free town of Bremen, in Germany, to transfer the action for trial to the Circuit Court of the United States for the Northern District of California. (Pr. Act, sec. 523.) The motion was denied; and from the order of denial the appeal is taken.

         The appeal must be dismissed; as from the order no appeal lies. The statute enumerates the orders from which an appeal will lie before final judgment; and this is not embraced among them. (Pr. Act, sec. 347.) The remedy of the appellants, if entitled to the transfer, is to apply to this Court for a mandamus upon the District Court.

         Appeal dismissed.


Summaries of

Hopper v. Kalkman

Supreme Court of California
Jan 1, 1861
17 Cal. 517 (Cal. 1861)
Case details for

Hopper v. Kalkman

Case Details

Full title:HOPPER v. KALKMAN et al.

Court:Supreme Court of California

Date published: Jan 1, 1861

Citations

17 Cal. 517 (Cal. 1861)

Citing Cases

Brooks v. Calderwood

         J. B. Harmon, for Respondent, moved to dismiss the appeal, citing Hopper v. Kalkman (17 Cal. 517).…