From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

GROVER v. COON

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Nov 1, 1848
1 N.Y. 536 (N.Y. 1848)

Opinion

November Term, 1848

C.P. Kirkland, for the respondent.

John Clarke, for the appellant.


The 282d section of the code of procedure applies to proceedings subsequent to the first of July, in suits which were pending on that day. ( Supp. Code, § 2.) The writ of error in this case was pending in the supreme court on the first of July, and was, we think, a suit within the meaning of the statute. The judgment of affirmance was subsequent to the first of July; and as the action was "originally commenced in a court of a justice of the peace," there was no right of appeal to this court. (§§ 282, 11.) The judgment of the supreme court was final.

We see no force in the objection urged by the appellant's counsel, that the statute is unconstitutional. The legislature did not take away a right of appeal which had already attached: they only said that for the future, no appeal to this court should be allowed in such cases.

Motion granted.


Summaries of

GROVER v. COON

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Nov 1, 1848
1 N.Y. 536 (N.Y. 1848)
Case details for

GROVER v. COON

Case Details

Full title:GROVER, appellant, vs . COON, respondent

Court:Court of Appeals of the State of New York

Date published: Nov 1, 1848

Citations

1 N.Y. 536 (N.Y. 1848)

Citing Cases

People v. Dunn

The right of appeal is not guaranteed by the Constitution. That is a matter entirely within the legislative…

People ex Rel. Crane v. Hahlo

That the legislature has the right, its action otherwise being valid and constitutional, to limit the right…