From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Green v. Road Commission

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Dec 1, 1922
114 S.E. 819 (N.C. 1922)

Opinion

(Filed 20 December, 1922.)

Appeal and Error — Fragmentary Appeal — Roads and Highways — Road Commission.

An appeal to the Supreme Court in an action to recover damages from a county road commission for injury to land in laying out a highway will be dismissed as premature when it appears that in the orderly procedure in such matters the commission has not reached the stage for the assessment of damages, and has not assessed them, and the appeal is properly dismissed in the Superior Court.

APPEAL by plaintiff from Bryson, J., at March Term, 1922, of WATAUGA.

W. C. Newland for plaintiff.

Linney Coffey for defendant.


This case proceeded very irregularly before the road commission, and also in the court below, and in the state of the pleadings there was nothing for the judge to do but dismiss the appeal as he did. The case was not ripe for an appeal, as, judging from the complaint filed by the plaintiff and the other proceedings, the plaintiff was seeking to recover the sum of $1,500 as damages for injury to his land by laying out the road thereon. It does not appear that the commission or local authorities have as yet reached the stage of the proceedings for the assessment of damages, or for ascertaining the amount of the plaintiff's compensation for taking his land, or for any injury thereto, and as the plaintiff seems to be seeking compensation, he should wait until the time comes for fixing it, of which he should have, and we presume will have, due notice.

The order dismissing the appeal is affirmed, and the cause will be remanded without prejudice to the good roads commission, for such other and further proceedings therein as may be proper in the premises and according to law.

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Green v. Road Commission

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Dec 1, 1922
114 S.E. 819 (N.C. 1922)
Case details for

Green v. Road Commission

Case Details

Full title:W. L. GREEN v. GOOD ROADS COMMISSION OF WATAUGA COUNTY

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Dec 1, 1922

Citations

114 S.E. 819 (N.C. 1922)
114 S.E. 819

Citing Cases

Raleigh v. Edwards

This being so, the nuisance defense is premature. No subsisting affirmative defense is alleged presently…

Hardee v. Henderson

HOKE and ALLEN, JJ., dissent. Cited: Woodall v. Highway Com., 176 N.C. 391 (2g); Morris v. Trustees, 184 N.C.…