From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Gay v. Nash

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jan 1, 1878
78 N.C. 100 (N.C. 1878)

Opinion

(January Term, 1878.)

Crop Lien — Registration.

A crop lien to secure agricultural advances (executed under Bat. Rev., ch. 65, secs. 19, 20) is valid inter partes, although not registered within thirty days, as required by the statute.

PROCEEDING to enforce a lien for advances for agricultural purposes, commenced by affidavit before the clerk and heard upon issue joined at Fall Term, 1877, of RICHMOND, before Seymour, J.

Upon the trial it appeared that the parties had entered into a written contract in which the plaintiff, merchant, agreed to furnish supplies to the amount of $700 to the defendant, planter, to enable him to cultivate a crop, in consideration of which the defendant agreed to deliver to the plaintiff so much of the cotton, etc., as might be sufficient to pay said sum. The contract was executed 14 January, 1876, admitted to probate 14 February, and registered 17 February thereafter. (101) And his Honor dismissed the proceeding upon the ground that the contract was not registered within thirty days. Judgment in favor of defendant for costs. Appeal by plaintiff.

T. P. Devereux and J. W. Hinsdale for plaintiff.

T. S. Ashe and Battle Mordecai for defendant.


The statute provides that a written lien upon a crop, for advances of means to make the crop, shall have preference of other liens, etc.; and such written liens are required to be registered within thirty days. Bat. Rev., ch. 65, secs. 19, 20. In this case the written lien was not registered within thirty days. That fact would certainly make it void as to third persons; but the question here is, whether it is good as between the parties.

We are of the opinion that it is good inter partes.

The object of registration is to give notice. The parties have notice without registration.

PER CURIAM. Reversed.

Cited: S. c., 84 N.C. 334; Reese v. Cole, 93 N.C. 90; Butts v. Screws, 95 N.C. 218; Nichols v. Speller, 120 N.C. 79.

(102)


Summaries of

Gay v. Nash

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jan 1, 1878
78 N.C. 100 (N.C. 1878)
Case details for

Gay v. Nash

Case Details

Full title:JOHN C. GAY v. R. S. NASH

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Jan 1, 1878

Citations

78 N.C. 100 (N.C. 1878)

Citing Cases

Reese Co. v. Cole

3. As it has been held that the registration of the agreement is not essential to the validity of the lien,…

Butts v. Screws

Mr. Geo. M. Lindsay, for the defendant. ( Clayton v. Hester, 80 N.C. 275; Ellison v. Jones, 26 N.C. 48;…