From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Epple v. Taylor

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Oct 10, 1950
223 P.2d 352 (Okla. 1950)

Opinion

No. 34718.

October 10, 1950.

(Syllabus.)

APPEAL AND ERROR — Dismissal of appeal where question becomes moot. Where a motion to dismiss is filed upon the ground that the appeal is moot and the court calls for a response to such motion and none is filed, and no excuse offered for such failure this court may, in its discretion, dismiss the appeal.

Appeal from District Court, Pottawatomie County; J. Knox Byrum, Judge.

Action for injunction by William F. Epple et al. against J.O. Taylor et al. From judgment for defendants, plaintiffs appeal. Dismissed.

Reily, Reily, Spurr, of Shawnee, for plaintiffs in error.

Wyatt, Wyatt Edwards, of Shawnee, for defendants in error.


Plaintiffs commenced an action to enjoin the defendants from the use of a driveway and garage. Judgment was for the defendants, and plaintiffs have appealed.

A motion to dismiss has been filed for the reason that the question presented on the appeal has become moot by reason of a conveyance of the property and that the appeal is for delay only. This court called for a response to the motion to dismiss and none has been filed.

We have held that the Supreme Court will not attempt to determine abstract, hypothetical, or moot questions, but, where it is made to appear that the questions brought up for review have become moot, the proceedings will be dismissed. Harden v. Morris et al., 198 Okla. 398, 179 P.2d 144; Glass et al. v. Banfield Bros. Packing Co., 168 Okla. 217, 32 P.2d 713; Douglas v. Baker, 167 Okla. 348, 29 P.2d 619; Campbell v. Reynolds, 167 Okla. 365, 29 P.2d 941; State ex rel. Rives v. Halley, 167 Okla. 504, 30 P.2d 915; Hudson v. Moore, 169 Okla. 12, 35 P.2d 886.

It being made reasonably to appear that the appeal is moot and should be dismissed, it is so ordered.

Appeal dismissed.

DAVISON, C.J., ARNOLD, V.C.J., and WELCH, CORN, HALLEY, and O'NEAL, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

Epple v. Taylor

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Oct 10, 1950
223 P.2d 352 (Okla. 1950)
Case details for

Epple v. Taylor

Case Details

Full title:EPPLE et al. v. TAYLOR et al

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Oct 10, 1950

Citations

223 P.2d 352 (Okla. 1950)
203 Okla. 467

Citing Cases

Edwards v. Hanna Lumber Company

This court has consistently held that where, after a proceeding in error has been instituted in this court, a…