From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Eikelberger v. Rogers

Supreme Court of Nevada
Jun 17, 1976
549 P.2d 748 (Nev. 1976)

Summary

holding that a claim brought by a third party who allegedly suffered damages as a result of an accountant's advice to his client could sue for negligent misrepresentation

Summary of this case from Green Tree Servicing LLC v. Valencia Mgmt. LLC Series 4

Opinion

No. 7962

May 13, 1976 Rehearing denied June 17, 1976

Appeal from the Second Judicial District Court, Washoe County; Llewellyn A. Young, J.

Lohse and Lohse, Chartered, of Reno, for Appellants.

Ellis R. Ferguson, of Reno, J. Rayner Kjeldsen, of Lovelock, and Vargas, Bartlett Dixon, of Reno, for Respondent.


OPINION


This appeal is from a judgment of the district court entered for the defendant notwithstanding a jury verdict for the plaintiffs in the total sum of $63,000. That court ruled, as a matter of law, that the plaintiffs were not entitled to judgment. Dudley v. Prima, 84 Nev. 549, 445 P.2d 31 (1968). We agree with that determination and affirm.

The Eikelbergers commenced this action against Rogers, a certified public accountant, to recover damages for accounting errors in statements prepared by Rogers for John and Mary Tolotti for use in litigation between the Eikelbergers and the Tolottis. The Eikelbergers did not employ Rogers. The Eikelbergers did not rely upon the accounting statements prepared by Rogers. To the contrary, they challenged those statements in the litigation with the Tolottis. Absent a professional relationship between the Eikelbergers and Rogers, or a reliance upon the accounting statements prepared, we perceive no legal basis for damages claimed to have been incurred by the Eikelbergers.

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Eikelberger v. Rogers

Supreme Court of Nevada
Jun 17, 1976
549 P.2d 748 (Nev. 1976)

holding that a claim brought by a third party who allegedly suffered damages as a result of an accountant's advice to his client could sue for negligent misrepresentation

Summary of this case from Green Tree Servicing LLC v. Valencia Mgmt. LLC Series 4
Case details for

Eikelberger v. Rogers

Case Details

Full title:FRED L. EIKELBERGER AND MARGARET A. EIKELBERGER, APPELLANTS, v. EARL W…

Court:Supreme Court of Nevada

Date published: Jun 17, 1976

Citations

549 P.2d 748 (Nev. 1976)
549 P.2d 748

Citing Cases

Green Tree Servicing LLC v. Valencia Mgmt. LLC Series 4

Two of defendant's citations support the theory that a third party can sue for the tort of negligent…

Eikelberger v. Tolotti

1. The extensive litigation between the Eikelbergers and the Tolottis stems from a sublease agreement between…