From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Dutton v. City of Oklahoma City

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Mar 17, 1953
254 P.2d 995 (Okla. 1953)

Opinion

No. 35805.

March 17, 1953.

(Syllabus.)

APPEAL AND ERROR — Appeal dismissed where question presented has become moot. When the question presented by an appeal has become moot, the appeal will be dismissed.

Appeal from District Court, Oklahoma County; Glen O. Morris, Judge.

Action by W.A. Dutton, as plaintiff, against the City of Oklahoma City and another to obtain an injunction. From a judgment for the defendants, plaintiff appeals. Dismissed.

Harlan Deupree and W.A. Blackburn, Oklahoma City, for plaintiff in error.

A.L. Jeffrey, Municipal Counselor, Edward H. Moler, Asst. Municipal Counselor, and Robinson, Shipp, Robertson Barnes, Oklahoma City, for defendants in error.


W.A. Dutton commenced an action for injunction against the city of Oklahoma City and another to prohibit the city of Oklahoma City from leasing certain property to Leo Portman.

The plaintiff alleged that he represents himself and those similarly situated; that defendant city of Oklahoma City was about to enter into an illegal lease contract and sought to enjoin the execution of the lease.

A temporary injunction was issued and thereafter a hearing was held at the conclusion of which the court entered a judgment for the defendants. Plaintiff has appealed.

A motion to dismiss has been filed for the reason the judgment of the trial court was not superseded and the court having held that in the absence of an order superseding the judgment the defendant city of Oklahoma City had a right to lease the property; that said lease has been executed and the question on appeal has been rendered moot. The appeal must be dismissed. In Harden v. Morris, 198 Okla. 398, 179 P.2d 144, we said:

"When the question presented by an appeal has become moot, the appeal will be dismissed.

Appeal dismissed.

HALLEY, C.J., and WELCH, CORN, DAVISON, O'NEAL, WILLIAMS, and BLACKBIRD, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

Dutton v. City of Oklahoma City

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Mar 17, 1953
254 P.2d 995 (Okla. 1953)
Case details for

Dutton v. City of Oklahoma City

Case Details

Full title:DUTTON v. CITY OF OKLAHOMA CITY et al

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Mar 17, 1953

Citations

254 P.2d 995 (Okla. 1953)
1953 OK 78

Citing Cases

Firefighters Pension v. City of Spencer

American Ins. Ass'n, supraAmerican Ins., supra note 13, at ¶ 6, at 739 (citing Greer County Election Board v.…

Wolfe v. Hart's Bakeries, Inc.

In the absence of any of the above acts the holder of the checks had a right to deliver the checks and the…