From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Durrett Hardware Furniture Co. v. Howze

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit
Apr 30, 1937
174 So. 205 (La. Ct. App. 1937)

Opinion

No. 5463.

April 30, 1937.

Appeal from City Court of West Monroe; Jesse S. Heard, Judge.

Suit by the Durrett Hardware Furniture Company, Inc., against John A. Howze, Jr. From an order sustaining a plea of prescription, plaintiff appeals.

Appeal dismissed.

Travis Oliver, Jr., of Monroe, for appellant.

Fink Fink, of Monroe, for appellee.


The petition in this cause alleges an indebtedness of defendant in the sum of $170 as the balance due on the purchase price of certain household furnishings. Plaintiff prays for judgment for that amount, plus interest and attorney's fees, with recognition of an asserted vendor's lien and chattel mortgage on the described property.

In bar of the claim, defendant tendered and urged a plea of prescription of five years. This was sustained by the trial court.

Subsequently, according to the court minutes, an order for a devolutive appeal was requested by plaintiff and was granted.

There is no executed appeal bond in the record. We find therein a duly prepared form for such bond, but it is not signed by either the plaintiff or a surety and consequently is no bond at all.

In the absence of an appeal bond, we are not permitted to review the proceedings and judgment of the trial court. There has been no appeal, and the cause is still under the jurisdiction of that tribunal. Vacuum Oil Company v. Cockrell, 177 La. 623, 148 So. 898; R. P. Farnsworth Co., Inc., v. Estrade, Cotton Fricke (La.App.) 166 So. 160; Genco v. Union Berry Truck Association (La.App.) 166 So. 888.

The fact that a motion to dismiss the appeal has not been filed in this court by defendant is of no moment. It is the duty of an appellate court to take notice of its lack of jurisdiction and to dismiss the appeal ex proprio motu. Gagneaux v. Desonier, 104 La. 648, 29 So. 282; Genco v. Union Berry Truck Association, supra.

The appeal is dismissed at plaintiff's cost.


Summaries of

Durrett Hardware Furniture Co. v. Howze

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit
Apr 30, 1937
174 So. 205 (La. Ct. App. 1937)
Case details for

Durrett Hardware Furniture Co. v. Howze

Case Details

Full title:DURRETT HARDWARE FURNITURE CO., Inc., v. HOWZE

Court:Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit

Date published: Apr 30, 1937

Citations

174 So. 205 (La. Ct. App. 1937)

Citing Cases

Guilliot v. City of Kenner

The bond in the amount of $1,400 was signed by Reliance Insurance Company as surety and is otherwise in…

Schoolhouse v. Fanguy

On the other hand, if what purports to be a bond is nothing but blank unsigned paper it cannot be cured and…