From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Downing v. Stamford Community Chest, Inc.

Supreme Court of Connecticut
Feb 7, 1939
4 A.2d 329 (Conn. 1939)

Opinion

Argued January 6, 1939

Decided February 7, 1939.

APPEAL from a finding and award of the compensation commissioner for the fourth district, in favor of the defendants, taken to the Superior Court in Fairfield County, Quinlan, J.; judgment dismissing the appeal and affirming the award, from which the plaintiff appealed to this court. No error.

Sidney Vogel, with whom were Ernest L. Josem and William J. Sullivan, for the appellant (plaintiff).

John M. Comley, for the appellees (defendants).


The defendant Community Chest, engaged in soliciting funds for charitable purposes, secured permission from the town authorities to erect a large sign in front of the town hall in Stamford, and made an agreement with Barnes, independent contractor, to do the work. The plaintiff's husband, an employee of Barnes, was killed by a fall while working on the sign. The plaintiff claimed workmen's compensation as a dependent against the Community Chest as principal employer, but the compensation commissioner denied it and the Superior Court sustained him in so doing. The statute provides that an employee of a contractor may recover compensation from the principal employer when, among other conditions, the work upon which the employee was engaged was being performed "in, on or about premises" under the control of the principal employer. General Statutes, § 5230. The situation before us does not differ in any material respect from that involved in Wilson v. Largay Brewing Co., 125 Conn. 109, 3 A.2d 668, and our decision in that case is controlling.


Summaries of

Downing v. Stamford Community Chest, Inc.

Supreme Court of Connecticut
Feb 7, 1939
4 A.2d 329 (Conn. 1939)
Case details for

Downing v. Stamford Community Chest, Inc.

Case Details

Full title:ALICE DOWNING v. STAMFORD COMMUNITY CHEST, INC., ET AL

Court:Supreme Court of Connecticut

Date published: Feb 7, 1939

Citations

4 A.2d 329 (Conn. 1939)
4 A.2d 329

Citing Cases

Mancini v. Bureau of Public Works

" Wilson v. Largay Brewing Co., 125 Conn. 109, 112, 3 A.2d 668. The proposition that the public highway did…

Evary v. E F Construction Co.

The conditions and situation surrounding the injured employee were not sufficiently under the observation or…