From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Cook's Lessee v. Hunter and Farmer

Circuit Court of the United States
Jun 1, 1809
2 Tenn. 113 (Tenn. Cir. 1809)

Opinion

June 1809.

When a party holds under a deed with general warranty, the law presumes the title papers to be in the hands of the warrantor, and the warrantee is not required to produce them in evidence, certified copies being sufficient. [Acc. Tillery v. Simmons, and King v. Hall, 1 Tenn. 209. And see Hopkins v. Lane, 9 Y. 83.]

A register may certify by his deputy, and whether the certificate be "A. B., register, by C. D., deputy," or "C. D., deputy for A. B., register," is immaterial. [See Code, 2012.]


Where it is shown to the Court that the party claims under a deed with a general waranty, the law presumes the title papers to be in the hands of the warrantor; and the warrantee is not required to produce them in evidence. Certified copies are sufficient. See 1 Rep. 2.

WHITE, who argued for the person offering the copy in evidence, relied on the practice in the superior courts.

The copy of the deed produced was certified by A. B., deputy register, for C. D., register.

HAYWOOD, for the defendants, objected that it ought to have been certified by the principal register by his deputy, and not by the deputy for the principal.


This is a mere verbal criticism. The meaning is the same, either way. The general rule is that a person can do that by another which he can do himself. The register might by his deputy certify; and whether it is signed thus, A. B., register, by C. D., deputy register, or thus: C. D., deputy register, for A. B., register, is immaterial, for it means the same thing; viz., the act of the principal by the deputy, and is good.


Summaries of

Cook's Lessee v. Hunter and Farmer

Circuit Court of the United States
Jun 1, 1809
2 Tenn. 113 (Tenn. Cir. 1809)
Case details for

Cook's Lessee v. Hunter and Farmer

Case Details

Full title:COOK'S LESSEE v. HUNTER AND FARMER

Court:Circuit Court of the United States

Date published: Jun 1, 1809

Citations

2 Tenn. 113 (Tenn. Cir. 1809)

Citing Cases

King's Lessee v. Hall

[Acc. Tillery's Lessee v. Simmons, next case above. Smith, T. v. Martin, 2 Tenn. 209, citing this case; and…

Blackwell v. R.R

But where damage is done to the land of the owner adjacent to that within the condemned boundary, if it…