From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Constantine v. Grenier

Supreme Court of New Hampshire Hillsborough
Nov 5, 1924
127 A. 656 (N.H. 1924)

Summary

In Constantine v. Grenier, 81 N.H. 550, a case of trespass, counsel was permitted, subject to exception, to cross-examine the defendant for the purpose of discrediting him, as to whether he had been convicted of violating the liquor laws.

Summary of this case from State v. Duke

Opinion

Decided November 5, 1924.

TRESPASS, vi et armis. In the cross-examination of the defendant, the plaintiff was permitted to inquire if the witness had been convicted of violating the liquor laws, and as to the sentence. The defendant's, bill of exceptions was allowed in the superior court by Branch, J.

John M. Stark, Peter J. King and Robert W. Upton, for the plaintiff.

Arthur B. Hayden, for the defendant.


"The extent to which an examination of this character should be carried is settled at the trial. Gutterson v. Morse, 58 N.H. 165." Benoit v. Perkins, 79 N.H. 11, 18. The authority relied upon by the defendant (Genest v. Company, 75 N.H. 365) is not in point. It relates to the introduction of independent impeaching evidence, and has no application to cross-examination of the witness whose integrity is called in question.

Exception overruled.


Summaries of

Constantine v. Grenier

Supreme Court of New Hampshire Hillsborough
Nov 5, 1924
127 A. 656 (N.H. 1924)

In Constantine v. Grenier, 81 N.H. 550, a case of trespass, counsel was permitted, subject to exception, to cross-examine the defendant for the purpose of discrediting him, as to whether he had been convicted of violating the liquor laws.

Summary of this case from State v. Duke
Case details for

Constantine v. Grenier

Case Details

Full title:WAYNE W. CONSTANTINE v. JOSEPH L. GRENIER

Court:Supreme Court of New Hampshire Hillsborough

Date published: Nov 5, 1924

Citations

127 A. 656 (N.H. 1924)
81 N.H. 550

Citing Cases

State v. Travis

The inquiry objected to in the present case was competent on the issue of the defendant's integrity.…

State v. Sturtevant

State v. Travis, 82 N.H. 220. See also, Constantine v. Grenier, 81 N.H. 550. On redirect examination the…