From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Christian v. Giard

Appeals Court of Massachusetts
Jul 16, 1975
330 N.E.2d 855 (Mass. App. Ct. 1975)

Summary

requiring tender of payment to exercise option containing no provision for notice

Summary of this case from Mills v. Brody

Opinion

July 16, 1975.

The case was submitted on briefs.

George C. Christian, pro se.

David J. Giard, Jr., for the defendant.


The option to buy in the lease contained no provision for notice by the appellants of their intention to exercise it. Accordingly, the appellants' "[n]otice of intention to exercise, without tender of payment, . . . [did] not bind the . . . [appellee] to convey." Hurd v. Cormier, 358 Mass. 736, 738 (1971), and cases cited. Both the express terms of the lease and the conduct of the parties (compare C W Dyeing Cleaning Co. Inc. v. DeQuattro, 344 Mass. 739, 742 [1962]) show that the option term expired March 7, 1974. At no time prior thereto did the appellants make a legally effective "tender . . . [of] the purchase price, or at least show themselves ready, willing and able to do so." Hurd v. Cormier, 358 Mass. 736, 738-739 (1971). Contrast Slater v. Easter, ante, 757 (1975). Nor does the record indicate that the appellee was unable or unwilling to convey the property in question during the option term; the judge's thorough findings establish the opposite. We have considered the other contentions sought to be raised by the appellants and find them to be without merit.

Decree affirmed.


Summaries of

Christian v. Giard

Appeals Court of Massachusetts
Jul 16, 1975
330 N.E.2d 855 (Mass. App. Ct. 1975)

requiring tender of payment to exercise option containing no provision for notice

Summary of this case from Mills v. Brody
Case details for

Christian v. Giard

Case Details

Full title:GEORGE C. CHRISTIAN another vs. LAWRENCE GIARD

Court:Appeals Court of Massachusetts

Date published: Jul 16, 1975

Citations

330 N.E.2d 855 (Mass. App. Ct. 1975)
3 Mass. App. Ct. 770

Citing Cases

United Truck Leasing Corp. v. Cornucopia Natural Foods, Inc., 86-2143 (1997)

"An option expires if not exercised within the time limited." Cities Service Oil Company v. National Shawmut…

National Medical Care, Inc. v. Zigelbaum

The fundamental rationale of cases dealing with the exercise or nonexercise of options lends added force to…