From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Chernaik v. Crean

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts
Jun 4, 1965
349 Mass. 765 (Mass. 1965)

Opinion

June 4, 1965.

Irving Goldblatt for the plaintiff.

J. Edward Fitzgerald for the defendant.


Chernaik seeks from Crean, inter alia, an accounting of a partnership formerly engaged in obtaining compulsory motor vehicle insurance for assigned risks. A master's report was modified and then confirmed. Chernaik's only appeal is from the final decree (1) that the partnership was dissolved on December 9, 1961; (2) that each partner's interest then was worth $6,000, of which each has received $3,192.74; and (3) that either partner may buy the other's remaining interest for $2,807.26. There was basis in the master's report for the conclusion that the dissolution took place as provided in the partnership agreement. See Murray v. Bateman, 315 Mass. 113, 115. See also G.L. (Ter. Ed.) c. 108A, § 31 (1) (b). Prompt surrender of the partnership insurance license showed that the partnership was not intended to continue. Cf. G.L. (Ter. Ed.) c. 108A, § 23 (2). The determination of the value of each partner's interest at dissolution was justified upon the modified master's report. See Whitman v. Jones, 322 Mass. 340, 342-343. Chernaik since 1961 has acquiesced in Crean's collecting, for the former partners, the income from former partnership accounts, thus realizing for each partner a portion of the partnership's value at its dissolution. Crean has not been shown to have acted in any respect improperly. The final decree is affirmed, provided, however, that, if Crean so requests within thirty days after the date of the rescript, the final decree may be modified to provide that Crean may purchase Chernaik's remaining share for $2,807.26 without interest, less any amount from former partnership accounts paid to Chernaik by Crean since the date of the original final decree. Crean is to have costs of appeal.


Summaries of

Chernaik v. Crean

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts
Jun 4, 1965
349 Mass. 765 (Mass. 1965)
Case details for

Chernaik v. Crean

Case Details

Full title:JOSEPH M. CHERNAIK vs. JOHN P. CREAN

Court:Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts

Date published: Jun 4, 1965

Citations

349 Mass. 765 (Mass. 1965)
208 N.E.2d 229

Citing Cases

Flynn v. Haddad

Steele v. Estabrook, 232 Mass. 432, 439-441 (1919). Chernaik v. Crean, 349 Mass. 765 (1965). Application of…