Argued June 14, 1872
Decided December 24, 1872
Henry R. Selden for the appellant.
S.D. Faulkner for the respondent.
ALLEN, J., reads opinion for reversal and new trial.
FOLGER, RAPALLO and ANDREWS, JJ., concur upon the first ground discussed.
PECKHAM, J., reads opinion for affirmance. CHURCH, Ch. J., and GROVER, J., concur.
Judgment reversed.
Full title:LEVANTIA S. CARPENTER, Respondent v . ZARA H. BLAKE Appellant
Court:Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Date published: Dec 24, 1872
But no man, whether skilled or unskilled, undertakes that the task he assumes shall be performed successfully…
Rosen v. State of New YorkHis implied engagement with his patient does not guarantee a good result, but he promises by implication to…