From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Carlisle v. Carmichael

Supreme Court of Alabama
Dec 18, 1930
131 So. 445 (Ala. 1930)

Opinion

4 Div. 463.

December 18, 1930.

Appeal from Circuit Court, Coffee County; W. L. Parks, Judge.

Harry Adams, of Enterprise, for appellants.

The motion to set aside the decree dismissing the bill and to allow complainants to take further testimony should have been granted. Turner v. Turner, 193 Ala. 424, 69 So. 503; Carson v. Sleigh, 201 Ala. 373, 78 So. 229.

J. M. Loflin, of Enterprise, for appellees.

Brief did not reach the Reporter.


A final decree in equity denying relief to complainant was entered in the circuit court July 21, 1928. On July 27, 1928, complainants filed a motion to set aside the final decree and allow them to take further testimony. On November 26, 1928, the court overruled the motion. On March 22, 1929, complainants filed with the register and had him to approve security for costs of an appeal recited to be from a decree rendered on November 27, 1928. The certificate to the transcript shows that the appeal was from the decree of November 26, 1928. If the appeal had purported to be from the final decree rendered July 21, 1928, or if it could be so treated, it came too late — section 6127, Code — and the court would be without jurisdiction to consider it. Boshell v. Phillips, 207 Ala. 628, 93 So. 576; Lowry v. Hill, 211 Ala. 645, 101 So. 586.

But, as we have stated, the appeal purports to be from the decree overruling a motion to set aside the final decree. This court has often pointed out that such decrees are not appealable, though an appeal may be taken from a ruling on a motion for a new trial at law. Section 6088, Code; Ford v. Ford, 218 Ala. 15, 117 So. 462; Gibson v. Farmers' Bank of Luverne, 218 Ala. 554, 119 So. 664. This appeal is therefore dismissed.

Appeal dismissed.

ANDERSON, C. J., and GARDNER and BOULDIN, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

Carlisle v. Carmichael

Supreme Court of Alabama
Dec 18, 1930
131 So. 445 (Ala. 1930)
Case details for

Carlisle v. Carmichael

Case Details

Full title:CARLISLE et al. v. CARMICHAEL et al

Court:Supreme Court of Alabama

Date published: Dec 18, 1930

Citations

131 So. 445 (Ala. 1930)
131 So. 445

Citing Cases

Williams v. Knight

Julian Harris and Norman W. Harris, both of Decatur, for appellee. An appeal taken more than six months after…

Watson v. Castellow

Carmichael Tiller, of Geneva, for appellee. The decretal order denying appellants' application for a…