From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Billiter v. United States

Circuit Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit
Jan 17, 1928
23 F.2d 678 (6th Cir. 1928)

Opinion

No. 5044.

January 17, 1928.

In Error to the District Court of the United States for the Northern District of Ohio; John M. Killits, Judge.

Proceeding by the United States against Henry Billiter. To review the judgment, defendant brings error. Affirmed.

Larry Bevan, of Toledo, Ohio, for plaintiff in error.

Harry G. Levey, Asst. U.S. Atty., of Toledo, Ohio.

Before DENISON and MOORMAN, Circuit Judges, and TUTTLE, District Judge.


The errors assigned being examined, we find only one requiring comment. Upon the argument to the jury, the district attorney indulged in denunciation of the respondent and comment upon his bad character, going distinctly beyond permissible limits. Volkmor v. U.S. (C.C.A.) 13 F.2d 594. The respondent's counsel objected to this comment as being misconduct by the district attorney. The court said, "That may be withdrawn," and the district attorney thereupon "withdrew the remark."

We need not decide whether a reversal on this account would be necessary, if the question were properly preserved. In such a situation, the harm done may sometimes be cured by a mere withdrawal of the offending language, and sometimes it would be the duty of the court to caution the jury emphatically and to reprimand the offending counsel; possibly sometimes it would be beyond cure, and would require the entry of a mistrial. In this case the judge considered a withdrawal to be remedy enough, and gave respondent that benefit. If counsel thought this remedy was insufficient, he should have said so; the record contains nothing to show that he was not content with the ruling which was made in response to his objection, and which clearly showed the intent of the court to give the relief thought necessary.

The judgment is affirmed.


Summaries of

Billiter v. United States

Circuit Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit
Jan 17, 1928
23 F.2d 678 (6th Cir. 1928)
Case details for

Billiter v. United States

Case Details

Full title:BILLITER v. UNITED STATES

Court:Circuit Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit

Date published: Jan 17, 1928

Citations

23 F.2d 678 (6th Cir. 1928)

Citing Cases

Schino v. United States

" In this that court follows this holding in Billiter v. United States, 6 Cir., 23 F.2d 678, 679 and in Pharr…

De Bonis v. United States

In Volkmor v. U.S., 13 F.2d 594, we reversed a conviction for language by the district attorney no worse than…