From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Bergeron v. Hunt

Supreme Court of New Hampshire Keene District Court
Jun 2, 1970
266 A.2d 121 (N.H. 1970)

Opinion

No. 6006

Decided June 2, 1970

1. Where the record transferred to the supreme court consists of findings of fact and rulings of law appearing in the reserved case and there is neither a transcript of the evidence nor any exhibit, the supreme court is limited to a consideration of errors apparent on the face of the record, and there is no question before the court as to the sufficiency of the evidence to sustain the verdict of the transferring court.

2. A real estate agent acting as an agent for a seller, with an agreed percentage of the sale price as his commission, is entitled to recover a real estate commission from the seller when he produces a customer able and willing to buy upon the seller's terms.

Joseph T. Cristiano, for the plaintiff, filed no brief.

R. J. Shortlidge, Jr., for the defendant, filed no brief.


This is an appeal from a decision of the Keene District Court which returned a verdict for the plaintiff for $600 in an action for a real estate commission. All exceptions taken during the trial to rulings of the court and to its denial of a motion to set aside the verdict were transferred by Davis, District Judge.

The court made findings of fact and rulings of law which appear in the reserved case, but no transcript of the evidence or any exhibits were transferred. In this situation, no question is before us as to the sufficiency of the evidence to sustain the verdict (Gobbi v. Moulton, 108 N.H. 183, 230 A.2d 747), and we are limited to the consideration of errors apparent on the face of the record. Pike v. Hartford, 100 N.H. 473, 130 A.2d 540.

The court's findings of fact sustain its conclusions that the plaintiff, acting as agent for the defendant, with an agreed percentage of the sale price as his commission, produced a customer able and willing to buy upon the defendant's terms. This entitled the plaintiff to recover. Richardson v. Sibley, 101 N.H. 377, 379, 143 A.2d 414, 416.

An examination of the transferred case discloses no errors, and the order is

Judgment on the verdict.


Summaries of

Bergeron v. Hunt

Supreme Court of New Hampshire Keene District Court
Jun 2, 1970
266 A.2d 121 (N.H. 1970)
Case details for

Bergeron v. Hunt

Case Details

Full title:LOUIS A. BERGERON v. RALPH C. HUNT

Court:Supreme Court of New Hampshire Keene District Court

Date published: Jun 2, 1970

Citations

266 A.2d 121 (N.H. 1970)
266 A.2d 121

Citing Cases

Trustees of Lexington Realty Trust v. Concord

If this were a transfer from a trial court, defendant's appeal would be dismissed on the presumption that the…

Timberlane Regional Educ. Ass'n v. Crompton

Since there is no record of the proceedings in the superior court, we cannot say that the evidence did not…